5 Seconds of Summer EVERYONE'S A STAR!
5 Seconds of Summer's EVERYONE'S A STAR! opens with a knowing wink, an album that turns the band's past into playful fuel while staking a claim to grown-up pop ambition. Critics' reviews coalesce around a record that mixes Y2K and '80s synth revival with retro alt-rock and pop-punk energy, and the quick verdict from the critical consensus is generally favorable. Across 4 professional reviews the collection earned a 75/100 consensus score, with reviewers praising its self-aware lyrics and muscular production.
Reviewers consistently point to “Boyband” as the album's clearest standout, a track that balances satire and celebration of fame; other repeatedly cited highlights include “No. 1 Obsession”, “Evolve” and the stirring “I’m Scared I’ll Never Sleep Again”. Critics note recurring themes of growth and reflection, identity reclamation and parasocial pressure, where vulnerability and cheeky commentary coexist. AllMusic and Rolling Stone emphasize the record's hook-forward, synth-laced production, while Clash and Kerrang! underline its emotional heft and nostalgic textures, making the best songs on EVERYONE'S A STAR! those that pair sharp melodies with lyrical self-awareness.
While some reviews temper enthusiasm by observing the band is having fun with their past rather than radically reinventing themselves, the consensus suggests EVERYONE'S A STAR! is a confident, often irresistible statement. For readers asking "is EVERYONE'S A STAR! good" or searching for the best songs on EVERYONE'S A STAR!, critics agree the record is worth attention, especially for tracks like “Boyband” and “No. 1 Obsession” that crystallize its themes of fame, nostalgia and self-reclamation.
Critics' Top Tracks
The standout songs that made critics take notice
the album truly coalesces around "Boyband"
Track Ratings
How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.
Everyone’s A Star!
NOT OK
Telephone Busy
Boyband
No. 1 Obsession
I'm Scared I’ll Never Sleep Again
istillfeelthesame
Ghost
Sick of Myself
Evolve
The Rocks
Jawbreaker
What Critics Are Saying
Deep insights from 4 critics who reviewed this album
Critic's Take
5 Seconds of Summer return with EVERYONE'S A STAR!, a bombastically fun, knowingly self-aware cybercore dance record where the best songs - notably Boyband and NOT OK - fuse '90s big beat bravado with wry pop commentary. The album's standout, Boyband, balances evisceration and celebration of their teen-idol past with cutting humor and an outro of genuine laughter that crystallizes the record's playful spirit. Other top tracks like NOT OK and the opener Everyone’s A Star! carry frenetic energy and hooky production, while moments such as No. 1 Obsession and Jawbreaker reveal yearning and romantic warmth. Overall, the record sounds confident in retro textures and succeeds in turning nostalgia into a sonically adventurous pop statement.
Key Points
-
The best song, "Boyband", crystallizes the album by mixing wry humor with dance-floor grit and an unforgettable outro.
-
The album's core strengths are its confident use of Y2K and early-2000s electronic aesthetics and a self-aware, playful lyrical stance.
Themes
Critic's Take
5 Seconds of Summer return with EVERYONE'S A STAR!, a record that channels their pop-punk origins while stretching into raucous alt-pop and aching balladry. The review singles out Evolve and The Rocks as the album's standouts, songs that balance reckless abandon with incisive reflection and supply the record's chief thrills. Tracks like No. 1 Obsession, I’m Scared I’ll Never Sleep and Ghost show the band's knack for vulnerability, making clear why listeners ask about the best songs on EVERYONE'S A STAR!. This is their most assured record yet, equal parts noisy swagger and tender confession, which explains why fans searching for the best tracks on EVERYONE'S A STAR! will find themselves returning to these key cuts.
Key Points
-
Evolve is the album's best song because it fuses rhythmic charge with striking vocal experimentation and a memorable spoken-word bridge.
-
The album's core strengths are balancing raucous, nostalgic pop-punk energy with intimate, vulnerable songwriting.
Themes
Critic's Take
Maura Johnston writes with dry amusement that 5 Seconds of Summer mostly lean into their knack for big hooks on EVERYONE'S A STAR!, naming songs like Boyband and No. 1 Obsession as sharp examples of their cheeky, synth-forward pop. She praises the stadium-ready sweep of I’m Scared I’ll Never Sleep Again and the emotional ambition of Ghost, while noting the band is having fun with their past rather than reinventing themselves. The piece frames the best songs on EVERYONE'S A STAR! as those that pair self-aware lyrics with muscular production, making clear that the album’s strongest moments are its confident, hooky tracks.
Key Points
-
The best song succeeds by pairing self-aware lyrics with big, synth-driven hooks and confident production.
-
The album’s core strengths are humor, musical restlessness, and polished, stadium-ready popcraft.
Critic's Take
5 Seconds Of Summer approach EVERYONE'S A STAR! like archaeologists of their own image, scraping back layers to find the youthful, knuckle‑headed core. The review frames Boyband as the clearest excavation, where retro synth and grooving bass underline lyrics about being a puppet on strings. It also highlights the album's blend of modern rock, pop, funk and '80s synth, which makes tracks like Boyband and the title mood pieces the best songs on EVERYONE'S A STAR!. The result is thoughtful reclamation more than reinvention, and those searching for the best tracks on EVERYONE'S A STAR! will find them where nostalgia and critique collide.
Key Points
-
The best song is Boyband because it most directly addresses the album's themes with fitting retro production.
-
The album's core strengths are its candid revisiting of past identity and its blend of modern rock, pop, funk and '80s synth textures.