Aerosmith & YUNGBLUD One More Time
Released Dec 5, 2025 Queen of Denial, Inc.
Established consensus 6 professional reviews Updated Sep 4, 2026
Mostly positive consensus
Aerosmith's One More Time pairs the veteran rockers with YUNGBLUD in a compact, celebratory set that critics say recaptures classic rock urgency while staking a sincere cross-generational claim.
How ChoruScore worksCritics' Top Tracks
The songs critics returned to most
Back In the Saddle - 2025 Mix
2 critic mentions
“the real measure of this melding of worlds comes to roost. The licks are sharper, the croons more savage, and the bodacious intent of the track more sensational than ever;” — Classic Rock Magazine
My Only Angel
2 critic mentions
“It only takes a few seconds of My Only Angel to feel that; the hedonistic howls of Tyler and Harrison battling each other for pole position hit like a freight train of exhilarating proportions.” — Classic Rock Magazine
Problems
2 critic mentions
“Problems has as much 80s pomp as it does 90s brashness, culminating in a vortex of fret-bashing and banshee croons,” — Classic Rock Magazine
Full critic consensus
Aerosmith's One More Time pairs the veteran rockers with YUNGBLUD in a compact, celebratory set that critics say recaptures classic rock urgency while staking a sincere cross-generational claim. Across professional reviews the record earned a 72.5/100 consensus score from six reviews, and reviewers consistently point to visceral moments of give-and-take that make the EP feel less like a nostalgia stunt and more like mutual artistic admiration.
Critics praise standout tracks such as “Back In the Saddle - 2025 Mix” and “My Only Angel” for sharpened guitar licks, combustible vocal interplay and a freight-train energy that nods to Aerosmith's prime. Reviews note recurring themes: a revival of classic rock energy, the passing of the torch between Steven Tyler and YUNGBLUD, and the brief EP format that concentrates the impact. While some critics frame the release as a meaningful last hurrah rather than a full comeback, others highlight moments like “Problems” and “Wild Woman” as evidence the collaboration expands rather than merely repackages the band's legacy.
Taken together, the critical consensus suggests One More Time is worth hearing for fans curious about the collision of generations and a focused dose of homage to classic rock; professional reviews agree it offers enough standout tracks and spirited performances to justify attention without overstating its ambitions. Below, read the full reviews for a track-by-track verdict and deeper context on how this EP fits into Aerosmith's catalogue.
Track Ratings
How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.
My Only Angel
Problems
Wild Woman
A Thousand Days
Back In the Saddle - 2025 Mix
Wild Woman - Lainey Wilson Version
Get the next albums worth your time.
Critic-backed picks in one clean digest. No clutter.
What Critics Are Saying
Deep insights from 6 critics who reviewed this album
Cl
Critic's Take
Aerosmith sound reinvigorated on One More Time, and Jack Rogers writes with eager conviction that the best songs - notably “My Only Angel” and “Back In the Saddle - 2025 Mix” - showcase raw, freight-train excitement and sharpened licks. He praises the interplay between Tyler and Dom Harrison, calling the vocal sparring on “My Only Angel” exhilarating, and says the updated “Back In the Saddle - 2025 Mix” finds the licks sharper and the croons more savage. The review frames these tracks as clear evidence that Aerosmith and YUNGBLUD bring out the best in each other, making the album one of Aerosmith's strongest in decades.
Key Points
-
The best song is “My Only Angel” for its exhilarating vocal duel and freight-train energy.
-
The album's core strength is reinvigorating classic Aerosmith energy through cross-generational collaboration with YUNGBLUD.
Themes
Critic's Take
Aerosmith and YUNGBLUD’s One More Time reads like a passing-of-the-torch gesture and a convincing homage to classic rock, with the title track and collaborations feeling weighty and celebratory. The review’s voice is conversational and slightly astonished, noting Steven Tyler’s surprise appearance and the EP arriving organically after YUNGBLUD’s Idols. The tone stays measured but upbeat, framing the record as a brief, meaningful last hurrah rather than a full-scale comeback.
Key Points
-
The best song is notable for bringing new Aerosmith music out of the studio after 12 years, making it the standout moment.
-
The album’s core strengths are its intergenerational collaboration and its convincing homage to classic rock.
