One More Time by Aerosmith & YUNGBLUD
80
ChoruScore
1 review
Early read
Dec 5, 2025
Release Date
Queen of Denial, Inc.
Label
Early read Broadly positive consensus

Early read based on 1 professional reviews. Aerosmith and YUNGBLUD's One More Time arrives as a compact, celebratory handoff between generations, a brief EP that foregrounds homage to classic rock while staking a contemporary, emotionally charged claim. Critics note the record's conversational energy and Steven Tyler's surprise appearances, with songs like “One

Reviews
1 review
Last Updated
Feb 21, 2026
Confidence
90%
Scale
0-100 critics
Primary Praise

The best song is notable for bringing new Aerosmith music out of the studio after 12 years, making it the standout moment.

Primary Criticism

Standout tracks cited include “Back In the Saddle - 2025 Mix”, the nostalgic centerpiece, alongside new cuts like “My Only Angel” and “Problems” that broaden the record's emotional

Who It Fits

Best for listeners looking for collaboration across generations and homage to classic rock, starting with Back In the Saddle - 2025 Mix and My Only Angel.

Standout Tracks
Back In the Saddle - 2025 Mix My Only Angel Problems

Full consensus notes

Aerosmith and YUNGBLUD's One More Time arrives as a compact, celebratory handoff between generations, a brief EP that foregrounds homage to classic rock while staking a contemporary, emotionally charged claim. Critics note the record's conversational energy and Steven Tyler's surprise appearances, with songs like “One More Time” and “Back In the Saddle - 2025 Mix” emerging as the collection's most resonant moments.

Across one professional review, the critical consensus awards One More Time an 80/100 from a single review, framing the release as a passing-the-torch gesture rather than a full-scale comeback. Reviewers consistently praise the collaborations for feeling weighty and celebratory, and they highlight the EP format as a strength - concise, purposeful, and free of filler. Standout tracks cited include “Back In the Saddle - 2025 Mix”, the nostalgic centerpiece, alongside new cuts like “My Only Angel” and “Problems” that broaden the record's emotional range.

While some readers may have hoped for a longer statement from Aerosmith, critics agree that the project succeeds on its own terms: a respectful homage to the band's legacy that lets YUNGBLUD's urgency inject fresh life. The critical reception suggests One More Time is worth hearing for fans of classic rock and for those curious about cross-generational collaboration, offering a focused, celebratory snapshot in the artists' catalogs.

Critics' Top Tracks

The standout songs that made critics take notice

1

Back In the Saddle - 2025 Mix

1 mention

"drags new Aerosmith music out of the studio for the first time in 12 years"
Kerrang!
2

My Only Angel

1 mention

"their collaboration was revealed. That resultant EP, One More Time, follows on organically from June’s YUNGBLUD album Idols"
Kerrang!
3

Problems

1 mention

"a convincing homage to classic rock"
Kerrang!
drags new Aerosmith music out of the studio for the first time in 12 years
K
Kerrang!
about "Back In the Saddle - 2025 Mix"
Read full review
1 mention
85% sentiment

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

My Only Angel

1 mention
75
04:15
2

Problems

1 mention
70
04:22
3

Wild Woman

1 mention
65
03:35
4

A Thousand Days

1 mention
60
03:57
5

Back In the Saddle - 2025 Mix

1 mention
85
03:30
6

Wild Woman - Lainey Wilson Version

1 mention
60
03:32

Get the next albums worth your time.

Critic-backed picks in one clean digest. No clutter.

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 6 critics who reviewed this album

80

Critic's Take

Aerosmith and YUNGBLUD’s One More Time reads like a passing-of-the-torch gesture and a convincing homage to classic rock, with the title track and collaborations feeling weighty and celebratory. The review’s voice is conversational and slightly astonished, noting Steven Tyler’s surprise appearance and the EP arriving organically after YUNGBLUD’s Idols. The tone stays measured but upbeat, framing the record as a brief, meaningful last hurrah rather than a full-scale comeback.

Key Points

  • The best song is notable for bringing new Aerosmith music out of the studio after 12 years, making it the standout moment.
  • The album’s core strengths are its intergenerational collaboration and its convincing homage to classic rock.

Themes

collaboration across generations homage to classic rock passing the torch brief EP format