All Them Witches House Of Mirrors
Consensus is still forming across 3 professional reviews. All Them Witches's House Of Mirrors arrives as a brooding, technically assured collection that folds 70s blues-rock swagger into tales of passed-down trauma and apocalyptic storytelling. Across professional reviews the record earns a cautious thumbs-up, balancing muscular riffing with quieter, atmospheric passages that
“Red Rocking Chair” is the best song for its dramatic oscillation between delicate verses and monster riffs, setting the album’s tone.
The consensus score sits at 66.67/100 across 3 professional reviews, signaling a generally favorable but measured critical reception.
Best for listeners looking for 70s blues-rock influence and dynamic soft-loud juxtapositions, starting with Red Rocking Chair and The Welterweight.
Explore the full Chorus artist page, discography, and related genre paths.
See where this record sits inside the full critic-ranked discography.
Jump from this record into the broader critic-consensus lists for 2026.
Full consensus notes
All Them Witches's House Of Mirrors arrives as a brooding, technically assured collection that folds 70s blues-rock swagger into tales of passed-down trauma and apocalyptic storytelling. Across professional reviews the record earns a cautious thumbs-up, balancing muscular riffing with quieter, atmospheric passages that often pivot into explosive payoff. The consensus score sits at 66.67/100 across 3 professional reviews, signaling a generally favorable but measured critical reception.
Critics consistently point to the album's technical prowess and pacing as its chief strength, with reviewers praising the band's command of dynamic soft-loud juxtapositions and restrained soloing. Standout tracks highlighted by multiple critics include “Red Rocking Chair” and “The Welterweight”, each noted for gossamer verses that swell into monster riffs and storytelling rooted in inherited fear. Other notable songs flagged for attention are “Starting Line”, “Aethernet” and “Angel On The Wayside”, cited for their nods to classic 12-bar structures and carefully measured atmospherics that reward repeated listens.
While admiration for musicianship and mood is common, some reviews temper praise with the observation that the record rarely pushes beyond well-honed genre touchstones. In other words, critics agree the collection is expertly executed and contains several standout songs, even if it stops short of full reinvention. For readers searching for an House Of Mirrors review, or wondering whether the album is worth listening to, the critical consensus suggests a rewarding listen for fans of taut, blues-rock storytelling and finely tuned dynamics.
Critics' Top Tracks
The standout songs that made critics take notice
Red Rocking Chair
1 mention
"the album opening on a high note: “Red Rocking Chair” oscillates between gossamer verses and choruses marked by monster riffs."— The Line of Best Fit
The Welterweight
1 mention
"All Them Witches similarly share their talent for pacing and composition via “The Welterweight”. A gossamer opening feeds into a moodily atmospheric section."— The Line of Best Fit
Starting Line
1 mention
"On “Starting Line”, Parks entertains how the all-for-one commitment can fall to the wayside when one is presented with a me-or-him situation"— The Line of Best Fit
the album opening on a high note: “Red Rocking Chair” oscillates between gossamer verses and choruses marked by monster riffs.
Track Ratings
How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.
Red Rocking Chair
Culling Line
Aethernet
Hold Up, Say What?
Go-getter
Starting Line
Turn On The Light
Angel On The Wayside
The Welterweight
Saturn Song
Get the next albums worth your time.
Critic-backed picks in one clean digest. No clutter.
What Critics Are Saying
Deep insights from 3 critics who reviewed this album
Critic's Take
In his muscular, reference-rich voice John Amen praises All Them Witches on House Of Mirrors, singling out “Red Rocking Chair” and “The Welterweight” as the album's best songs for their oscillation between gossamer verses and monster riffs and for moods that shift from delicate to eruptive. Amen notes how “Red Rocking Chair” opens the record on a high note, and how “The Welterweight” marries atmospheric passages with aggressive grooves and storytelling about inherited fear. He also highlights “Starting Line” and “Aethernet” as notable for their restrained solos and nods to classic 12-bar structure, reinforcing why listeners searching for the best tracks on House Of Mirrors should start there. The narrative is admiring but measured, framing these best tracks as evidence of fervour and technical skill rather than outright reinvention.
Key Points
-
“Red Rocking Chair” is the best song for its dramatic oscillation between delicate verses and monster riffs, setting the album’s tone.
-
The album’s core strengths are fervour, technical skill, and dynamic soft-loud arrangements rooted in 70s blues-rock templates.
Themes
