Modern Times by Bob Dylan

Bob Dylan Modern Times

86
ChoruScore Critic consensus / 100

Released Aug 6, 2006 Columbia

Established consensus 23 professional reviews Updated Aug 27, 2026

Strong critical consensus

Bob Dylan's Modern Times arrives as a late-career statement that folds blues, folk and old-time pop into weary, witty songs of love, mortality and prophecy.

How ChoruScore works

Critics' Top Tracks

The songs critics returned to most

01

Nettie Moore

6 critic mentions

“On 'Nettie Moore', Dylan does that alchemical thing, making a traditional folk ballad even more darkly spellbinding.” — The Guardian
02

When the Deal Goes Down

6 critic mentions

“Tomorrow keeps turning around/We live and we die, we know not why/But I’ll be with you when the deal goes down.” — Rolling Stone
03

Ain't Talkin'

5 critic mentions

“the final track, "Ain't Talkin'," where a lonesome fiddle, piano, and hand percussion spill out a gypsy ballad” — AllMusic
Full critic consensus

Bob Dylan's Modern Times arrives as a late-career statement that folds blues, folk and old-time pop into weary, witty songs of love, mortality and prophecy. Across professional reviews, critics consistently point to the record's vintage style and lyrical dexterity, praising its brooding atmosphere and the way Dylan's rasping delivery turns decay into charm. With a consensus score of 85.57/100 from 23 professional reviews, the critical reception skews decisively positive while noting moments of elegiac restraint and sly humor.

Reviewers agree that the best songs on Modern Times are those that marry plain-spoken narratives with mythic weight. “Nettie Moore” and “When the Deal Goes Down” recur as standout tracks for their dark spellbinding lyricism and metaphysical tenderness, while “Ain't Talkin'” is often cited as the chilling, moral closer that crystallizes the album's foreboding. Critics also single out “Thunder On the Mountain” and “Rollin' and Tumblin'” for their buoyant blues energy, and several reviews highlight “Workingman's Blues #2” and “Spirit On the Water” as exemplary of Dylan's blend of social comment and warm production. Across 23 reviews, professional critics note recurring themes of nostalgia, divine reckoning, ambivalence and aging artistry.

While many reviews celebrate the record as a convincing continuation of Dylan's strengths, some temper praise with the observation that the album charms more than it astonishes. That nuance—admiration for craft combined with measured reserve—frames Modern Times as a must-hear for fans of American roots traditions and anyone curious whether Dylan's late work can still produce essential songs. Below, the full reviews unpack how these best tracks and themes cohere across the record.

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

Thunder On the Mountain

6 mentions
74
05:53
2

Spirit On the Water

5 mentions
73
07:41
3

Rollin' and Tumblin'

4 mentions
100
06:01
4

When the Deal Goes Down

6 mentions
100
05:04
5

Someday Baby

3 mentions
46
04:55
6

Workingman's Blues #2

7 mentions
61
06:07
7

Beyond the Horizon

3 mentions
15
05:34
8

Nettie Moore

6 mentions
100
06:52
9

The Levee's Gonna Break

4 mentions
61
05:43
10

Ain't Talkin'

5 mentions
100
08:48

Get the next albums worth your time.

Critic-backed picks in one clean digest. No clutter.

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 23 critics who reviewed this album

100

Critic's Take

Bob Dylan sounds at ease on Modern Times, a relaxed but great album that blends blues, folk and balladry in his vintage voice. The review singles out “Thunder On the Mountain” as a dramatic, bluesy opener and highlights “Workingman's Blues #2” and “The Levee's Gonna Break” for their faint political touch, so listeners asking about the best tracks on Modern Times should start there. Keir Hind's tone is approving and wry, noting clever wordplay and repeated listens rewarding the patient fan.

Key Points

  • The best song opener is “Thunder On the Mountain” because it provides a dramatic, bluesy launch that epitomizes the album's mix.
  • The album's core strengths are vintage Dylan wordplay, a blend of blues and folk, and subtle political touches.

Themes

blues folk politics wordplay vintage style

Critic's Take

Bob Dylan sounds like a weathered traveler on Modern Times, his croak and rasp making the best tracks feel lived-in and inevitable. He praises “When the Deal Goes Down” as a divine, metaphysical love song and names “Nettie Moore” darkly spellbinding, which positions these as among the best songs on Modern Times. The critic's tone is elegiac and comparative, rooting Dylan in tradition while noting the persistent regret that binds the album together.

Key Points

  • Nettie Moore is best for its dark, spellbinding inhabitation of traditional ballad form.

Themes

mortality brooding traditionalism love and regret blues revival

Critic's Take

Bob Dylan's Modern Times is a record where the best tracks - notably “Thunder On the Mountain” and “Ain't Talkin'” - condense prophecy and intimacy into compact, authoritative songs. The reviewer lingers on “Thunder On the Mountain” as a piling-up of devotion, lust and the second coming, and frames “Ain't Talkin'” as a hard-boiled moral close that sends the listener toward Eden. The album's strongest songs trade in American roots and biblical weight, making those tracks the best songs on Modern Times because they marry plain-spoken language with mythic scope. Overall, these best tracks show Dylan's command and accumulated knowledge, the very reason many listeners seek the best tracks on Modern Times.

Key Points

  • “Thunder On the Mountain” is the best song because it concentrates devotion, lust and apocalyptic prophecy into a commanding opener.
  • The album’s core strengths are its rooted American musical vocabulary, plain-spoken language, and mythic, prophetic themes.

Themes

apocalypse and prophecy love and lust American roots traditions divine reckoning

Critic's Take

Bob Dylan delivers on Modern Times with a weary wit and aural gumption that makes the best tracks feel lived-in and vital. The reviewer's tone fixes on the loveliest moments, especially “Spirit On the Water” and “When the Deal Goes Down”, which render the record's apocalypse palatable through warm production and aching melody. There is a consistent mournful charisma here - songs fold blues, jazz, and rockabilly into compact stories of unrequited love and hard-luck lives. In short, the best songs on Modern Times are intimate, well-worn gems that let Dylan's gravelly tenor and his touring band shine together.

Key Points

  • The best song is intimate and lovely because it renders the record's apocalypse palatable with warm production.

Themes

melancholy uncertainty nostalgia blues/jazz influence foreboding
90

Critic's Take

Bob Dylan sounds both raucous and tender on Modern Times, and the best tracks - “Thunder On the Mountain”, “When the Deal Goes Down”, “Ain't Talkin'” - showcase that range. Jurek revels in the barn-burning electricity of “Thunder On the Mountain” while pointing to the parlor-sweetness of “When the Deal Goes Down” as evidence of Dylan's old-time swing. He lets “Ain't Talkin'” close the record with a lonesome, gypsy-ballad sense of foreboding that feels like the album's emotional center. The review emphasizes how these best songs trade between bawdy joy and bottomless sadness, making them the standout tracks on Modern Times by virtue of performance and historical depth.

Key Points

  • The best song is "Thunder On the Mountain" because its barn-burning energy and vivid instrumentation make it the album's showpiece.
  • The album's core strengths are its command of American folk-blues forms and the emotional ambivalence that balances bawdy joy with bottomless sadness.

Themes

blues tradition mortality love American folk forms ambivalence

Critic's Take

Bob Dylan keeps cooking familiar pleasures on Modern Times, and the best songs here - notably “Rollin' and Tumblin'” and “Nettie Moore” - show why that matters. Petrusich's eye for sly detail surfaces in how “Rollin' and Tumblin'” is punched up with "peppery guitar" while “Nettie Moore” staggers as a spare, airy ballad, proof that Dylan's decaying pipes can still coax sweetness. The record rewards listeners who like their Dylan weathered and wry, and the best tracks on Modern Times make a persuasive case for his late-career charm.

Key Points

  • Nettie Moore is the emotional center, a staggering, spare ballad showcasing Dylan's vocal fragility.
  • The album's core strengths are its expert band performances and the charming, weathered late-career songwriting.

Themes

late-career continuity blues and honky-tonk influences vocal decay and charm nostalgia and appropriation

Ir

Irish Times

Unknown
Aug 25, 2006
80

Critic's Take

Bob Dylan sounds both reflective and boisterous on Modern Times, and the best tracks are those that marry his verbal dexterity with familiar forms. The review elevates “When the Deal Goes Down”, “Workingman's Blues #2” and “Nettie Moore” as signature Dylan ballads, while also praising “Thunder On the Mountain” and “Someday Baby” for their pre-rock simplicity. The writer's voice is admiring and slightly astonished - at 65 Dylan still delivers cutting social criticism, ribald humour and textbook rock'n'roll philosophising across the album. This makes the question of the best songs on Modern Times tilt toward the ballad/folk tracks that feel like classic Dylan, even as the livelier numbers hold their own.

Key Points

  • The best song(s) are the ballad/folk tracks like "When the Deal Goes Down" because they showcase Dylan's signature lyrical dexterity.
  • The album's core strengths are its blend of reflective and boisterous moods and Dylan's enduring verbal skills.

Themes

aging artistry lyrical dexterity folk and blues traditions reflection and satire

Critic's Take

Bob Dylan sounds rueful and sardonic across Modern Times, and the best tracks - notably "Spirit On the Water" and "Nettie Moore" - show him still able to beguile with a descending riff and an insistent pulse. The record prefers muted rockabilly shuffles and polite, country-inflected pop to bombast, so the best songs on Modern Times are those small, unsettling croons rather than grand statements. There are also longer, elegiac pieces like "Workingman's Blues #2" and the chilling closer "Ain't Talkin'" that underline the album's intimations of doom. Overall, the album charms more than it astonishes, its highlights proving Dylan's renaissance is musical rather than miraculous.

Key Points

  • The best song moments are intimate, riff-driven pieces like "Spirit On the Water" that beguile rather than astonish.
  • The album's core strengths are its rootsy arrangements, elegiac mood, and Dylan's distinctive croak that turns mild-mannered tunes unsettling.
Mojo logo

Mojo

Unknown
Unknown date
80