Bret McKenzie Freak Out City
Bret McKenzie's Freak Out City plays like a sunlit wobble between carnival bravado and domestic unease, and critics' reviews reflect that ambivalence. Across three professional reviews the record earned a 53.5/100 consensus score, with praise for inventive arrangements and melodicism tempered by recurring notes about its uneven focus. Critics consistently point to the title track “Freak Out City” as a highlight, alongside “Eyes on the Sun” and “The Only Dream I Know” as songs that best balance McKenzie's knack for melody with thematic weight.
Critics' Top Tracks
The standout songs that made critics take notice
Freak Out City
3 mentions
"Freak Out City's title track is a veritable smorgasbord of jazzy salsa rhythms"— At The Barrier
Eyes on the Sun
2 mentions
"Defining track – ‘Eyes on the Sun’: McKenzie’s flair for melody is all over this album"— Far Out Magazine
The Only Dream I Know
3 mentions
"More harmonies fly on The Only Dream I Know."— At The Barrier
Freak Out City's title track is a veritable smorgasbord of jazzy salsa rhythms
Track Ratings
How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.
Bethnal Green Blues
Freak Out City
The Only Dream I Know
All the Time
That's the Way That the World Goes 'Round
All I Need
Eyes on the Sun
Too Young
Highs and Lows
Shouldna Come Here Tonight
What Critics Are Saying
Deep insights from 3 critics who reviewed this album
Critic's Take
In this review Ray Finlayson finds the best songs on Freak Out City are the ones that lean into the party mood, notably “Freak Out City” and opening gambit “Bethnal Green Blues”. Finlayson praises the title track as an "infectious samba-inflected rollercoaster ride" and celebrates the peppy swing of “Bethnal Green Blues”, while also noting quieter charms in “Highs and Lows” and “The Only Dream I Know”. The verdict is warm but measured - McKenzie sounds like he’s having more fun, even if some songs overstay their welcome.
Key Points
-
The title track “Freak Out City” stands out for its infectious samba feel and topical lyrics.
-
The album’s strengths are warm, well-arranged pastiches and vibrant party-leaning tracks, offset by occasional overlong moments and muted lyrical impact.
Themes
Critic's Take
In a brilliant follow-up, Bret McKenzie’s Freak Out City finds its best songs in both the melancholic and the exuberant - notably “All I Need” and the title track “Freak Out City”. Dominic Walsh lauds the album’s lush harmonies and top-tier band, pointing to “The Only Dream I Know” and “Shouldna Come Here Tonight” as moments where McKenzie’s craft and sly humour collide. The record balances country-tinged balladry, gospel-tinged soul and jazzy salsa flourishes, giving listeners clear answers when searching for the best tracks on Freak Out City.
Key Points
-
Shouldna Come Here Tonight is the album highlight for its evocative intro and Beatles-era groove.
-
The album's core strengths are sumptuous harmonies, versatile band arrangements, and a balance of melancholia and danceable moments.
Themes
Fa
Critic's Take
There is a self-assured melodic gift at the heart of Freak Out City, and it is in moments like “Eyes on the Sun” that Bret McKenzie proves his songwriting can stand alone. In the reviewer's clipped, observant voice, McKenzie is praised for marrying personal worry to an ironically sunny sound, while elsewhere the record occasionally feels too indebted to its touchstones. The best songs on Freak Out City - notably “Eyes on the Sun” and the title track “Freak Out City” - show why he should be taken seriously beyond comedy. Ultimately, the album delights by being fun rather than funny, even if it sometimes stays in one lane.
Key Points
-
The best song is “Eyes on the Sun” because it crystallises McKenzie’s melodic gift with an unexpected chorus and poignant theme.
-
The album's core strengths are strong songwriting, tasteful nods to influences, and the ability to be fun without resorting to outright comedy.