Brògeal Tuesday Paper Club
Released Oct 17, 2025 Play It Again Sam
Established consensus 5 professional reviews Updated Mar 13, 2026
Mostly positive consensus
Brògeal's Tuesday Paper Club plants its flag in energetic, communal folk with a clear eye for festival-sized singalongs and old-school charm.
How ChoruScore worksCritics' Top Tracks
The songs critics returned to most
Apples And Leaves
1 critic mention
“The beautiful ‘Apples And Leaves” — God Is In The TV Zine
Tuesday Paper Club
1 critic mention
“The album starts with the title track and liveliest thing on offer here” — God Is In The TV Zine
Draw The Line
1 critic mention
“the likes of ‘Draw The Line’ are already live favourites” — God Is In The TV Zine
Full critic consensus
Brògeal's Tuesday Paper Club plants its flag in energetic, communal folk with a clear eye for festival-sized singalongs and old-school charm. Critics point to a record that leans into Celtic instrumentation and live-bred momentum, balancing stomping anthems with moments of plaintive melody. Across professional reviews the collection earned a 72/100 consensus score from five reviews, signaling generally favorable notice with room for refinement.
Reviewers consistently praise standout tracks such as “Apples And Leaves”, the album title track “Tuesday Paper Club” and “Draw The Line” as highlights—“Apples And Leaves” surfaces as the tender, Smiths-tinged counterpoint to the festival-ready stomp of the opener, while “Draw The Line” already reads as a crowd-rouser. Critics note the tasteful use of accordion, banjo and fiddle, and several reviews emphasize the record's live energy and folk revivalist instincts, as well as nostalgic covers and toe-tapping arrangements that map neatly onto packed-house singalongs.
While some professional reviews flag occasional rough edges in pacing and production, the critical consensus celebrates Brògeal's commitment to a natural voice and communal, venue-ready songwriting. For those searching for the best songs on Tuesday Paper Club or wondering whether the record is worth a listen, the reviews suggest its strengths lie in memorable hooks, Celtic textures and anthems built for live performance. The detailed reviews below unpack how these songs translate from the studio to the stage and what the record means for Brògeal's place in the ongoing folk revival.
Track Ratings
How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.
Tuesday Paper Club
Vicar Street Days
Friday On My Mind
Lady Madonna
Turn And Walk Away
Scarlet Red
Dippin' n Divin'
One For The Ditch
Draw The Line
Racing Track
Apples And Leaves
Stuck Inside
Go Home Tae Yer Bed
Lonesome Boatman
Get the next albums worth your time.
Critic-backed picks in one clean digest. No clutter.
What Critics Are Saying
Deep insights from 5 critics who reviewed this album
Fa
Go
Critic's Take
Brògeal's Tuesday Paper Club is a breath of fresh air, a record that plants its flag with communal, Celtic-flavoured singalongs and venue-ready stompers. The best tracks on Tuesday Paper Club are the title cut, “Apples And Leaves” and “Draw The Line” - the opener is an immediate, folk-laden stomper, “Apples And Leaves” is the album's most beautiful, Smiths-tinged moment, and “Draw The Line” already sounds festival-bound. Steven Doherty's review praises the band for sticking to their natural voice while mixing accordion, banjo and fiddle into genuinely catchy songs. The record feels like a satisfying debut that will make Brògeal many listeners' new favourite band in 2026.
Key Points
-
The title track's stomping energy and communal hooks make it an instant live favourite.
-
The album's strengths are its Celtic instrumentation, catchy fiddle-led songs, and subtle, heartfelt moments like "Apples And Leaves".