Honey by Caribou

Caribou Honey

67
ChoruScore
12 reviews
Oct 4, 2024
Release Date
Merge Records
Label

Caribou's Honey arrives as a clear pivot back toward club-ready electronics, trading some of the introspective warmth of earlier records for propulsive, dancefloor-focused craft. Across professional reviews, critics point to immediate highlights - “Honey”, “Broke My Heart” and “Climbing” - as the album's most vivid moments, where meticulous production and euphoric drops meet earworm melodies and layered synth work.

The critical consensus is measured: Honey earned a 66.67/100 consensus score across 12 professional reviews, with many praising its retro electronica, tight dance/house grooves and moments of joyous, layered production. Reviewers consistently noted the record's cohesiveness in its first half, citing opener “Broke My Heart” and the title track “Honey” as standout tracks, while mid-album cuts like “Come Find Me” and “Over Now” were praised for warmth and hooky resonance. Critics repeatedly highlight the duality between ecstatic dance-floor euphoria and bittersweetness, and they applaud Snaith's production craft even when songs trade narrative depth for rhythmic immediacy.

Nuance appears in recurring concerns: some critics flagged AI-manipulated or pitched-up vocals as emotionally distancing and questioned moments of appropriation or melodic thinness, and several reviews observed a loss of earlier album charm in the record's more relentless, frenetic stretches. Still, when the production and melody click - notably on “Broke My Heart”, “Honey” and “Climbing” - reviewers agreed the best songs on Honey reward repeated listens. For readers wondering what critics say about Honey, the consensus suggests a dance-forward, occasionally divisive record that delivers club-ready highs even as it raises provocative questions about experimentation and vocal manipulation.

Critics' Top Tracks

The standout songs that made critics take notice

1

Honey

11 mentions

"The title track continues in this vein with pulsating drum loops and electronic grooves: this is pure feel-good music"
DIY Magazine
2

Broke My Heart

10 mentions

"Opener ‘Broke My Heart’ is an unstoppable force of nature"
DIY Magazine
3

Climbing

9 mentions

"‘Climbing’ sends the listener on what feels like a morale-boosting pivot of self-discovery"
Clash Music
The title track continues in this vein with pulsating drum loops and electronic grooves: this is pure feel-good music
D
DIY Magazine
about "Honey"
Read full review
11 mentions
78% sentiment

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

Broke My Heart

10 mentions
100
02:46
2

Honey

11 mentions
100
04:22
3

Volume

7 mentions
65
03:58
4

Do Without You

10 mentions
77
02:16
5

Come Find Me

9 mentions
93
03:56
6

August 20/24

5 mentions
37
01:32
7

Dear Life

9 mentions
70
03:44
8

Over Now

9 mentions
93
04:27
9

Campfire

8 mentions
35
02:32
10

Climbing

9 mentions
100
04:10
11

Only You

8 mentions
62
03:36
12

Got To Change

9 mentions
78
03:11

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 14 critics who reviewed this album

Critic's Take

OnHoney, Caribou trades the introspective gravity of earlier records for buoyant, club-ready textures; the review points to the best tracks as anchors of that shift. The reviewer highlights “Do Without You” as the clearest link to Caribou’s past and praises its melodic callbacks, calling it a standout that grounds Honey. They also single out “Climbing” for its cascading synths that lift the album’s otherwise slight arrangements. Overall, the best songs on Honey are framed as moments where production wizardry and melodic memory combine to make the record enjoyable, if not deeply stirring.

Key Points

  • “Do Without You” is best for reconnecting the album to Caribou’s melodic past and provides satisfying callbacks.
  • The album’s core strengths are textured, dancefloor-focused production and inventive vocal manipulation, though it lacks deep emotional resonance.

Critic's Take

Caribou's Honey stakes its claim as a dancefloor-minded return, where the best songs - “Broke My Heart”, “Honey”, and “Volume” - sharpen vintage house into propulsive, economical pop. The reviewer writes in clipped, persuasive sentences that celebrate the album's directness and beats while noting the AI-treated vocals often serve the songs rather than dominate them. Praise leans heaviest toward the first half, calling those tracks accomplished and prêt-à-porter, whereas the second half loses momentum and reminds us of earlier, more human Caribou moments. This balances clear endorsement of the standout tracks with a measured caveat about inconsistency across the record.

Key Points

  • The opener "Broke My Heart" is the album's best song because it foregrounds the dancefloor energy and vocal modulation that define the record.
  • Honey's core strengths are its direct, economical beats, successful integration of AI-treated vocals, and a tight, accomplished first half rooted in club traditions.

Themes

AI vocal alteration club/house return retro electronica dancefloor focus contrast between album halves

Critic's Take

In his measured, conversational way Shaad D’Souza finds the best songs on Honey in the record’s big, physical moments - the barnstorming openers “Broke My Heart” and “Honey” and the ecstatic rise of “Climbing”. He writes with the same knack for cultural comparison throughout, framing Caribou as an artist ordering from the adult kids’ menu while still delivering glorious, eyeball-vibrating drops. The review’s praise centers on these tracks’ production highs and sheer dancefloor satisfactions, even as it flags ethical unease around AI usage and a troubling rap turn on “Campfire”.

Key Points

  • The best song excels through production spectacle and rising intensity, exemplified by the synth arc in "Climbing".
  • The album’s core strengths are Caribou’s detailed, fidgety production and knack for turning big dance moments into emotionally resonant pop.

Themes

dancefloor energy AI vocals and ethics nostalgia/adult kids' menu production craft

Critic's Take

Caribou’s Honey is a tight, 40-minute packet of dance magic that rarely puts a foot wrong, and the best tracks crystallize that feel. Opener “Broke My Heart” hits as an unstoppable force of nature, primed for early hours, while the title track “Honey” keeps the pulsating drum loops and electronic grooves coming. “Dear Life” emerges as a thunderous potential dance anthem, and “Over Now” smartly shifts toward a smoother ’80s vibe, giving the album breadth as well as euphoria. The result answers listeners asking for the best songs on Honey with vivid, club-ready moments and layered production that invites repeat plays.

Key Points

  • The best song is a high-energy opener, “Broke My Heart”, because it is called an unstoppable, irrepressible force primed for early hours.
  • The album’s core strengths are layered, joyful dance production and varied nods to club and ’80s sounds that yield consistent, feel-good moments.

Themes

dancefloor energy nostalgia electronic grooves joyful layers

Critic's Take

Caribou\'s Honey finds its strongest moments in tracks like “Honey” and “Climbing”, where meticulous builds and atmospheric layers collide to make the best songs on Honey. The reviewer's voice praises the title track\'s craft - an "excellent choice of vocal sample" and an infectious bassline that secures its place on global club setlists. Likewise, “Climbing” is singled out as a morale-boosting pivot of self-discovery, its atmospheric layers marking it among the best tracks on the record. Overall the album\'s combination of huge dancefloor moments and mellow panoramas explains why these songs stand out as highlights.

Key Points

  • The title track “Honey” is best for its meticulous build-up, standout vocal sample and infectious bassline tailored for clubs.
  • The album\'s core strengths are intricate production, dynamic contrasts between dancefloor energy and atmospheric introspection, and strong vocal layering for live performance.

Critic's Take

Caribou's Honey trades intimate autobiography for gleaming synthcraft, and the best songs here - notably “Come Find Me” and “Over Now” - reward that trade with undeniable hooks and warmth. Reid BG writes in a conversational, slightly wry voice, noting how the album services dance-floor giddiness while flirting with bittersweetness, and he singles out “Come Find Me” as the first true highlight at the album's midpoint. The review keeps returning to contrasts - youthful, pitched-up AI vocals against Snaith's familiar falsetto - which makes tracks like “Broke My Heart” and “Only You” feel caught between two identities. Overall, the critic frames the best tracks as those that balance Caribou's warmth with Daphni's exuberance, even if the record sometimes sacrifices narrative depth for bright, propulsive sound.

Key Points

  • The best song, "Come Find Me," is singled out for its pitched-up vocal charm and soaring synths that crystallize the album's warmth.
  • The album's core strength is its bright, dance-floor synthcraft that balances Caribou's warmth with Daphni's exuberant production, despite occasional lack of narrative depth.

Themes

duality between Caribou and Daphni use of AI/manipulated vocals dance-floor euphoria vs bittersweetness experimentation vs songwriting depth

Critic's Take

In his typically measured and slightly mordant voice, Caribou’s Honey is praised and panned in equal measure: Ben Beaumont-Thomas admires the wit on “Broke My Heart” and especially lauds “Come Find Me” as Honey’s strongest track with an earworming vocal hook, while he finds the AI vocal experiments often hollow. He singles out “Over Now” as proof that Snaith’s own shaky, naive human voice has more melancholy and expressive potential than the simulated singers. The review frames the album as club-savvy and technically adept but diminished by weak melodies and questionable appropriation, making the question of the best songs on Honey a split between clever production and genuine human feeling.

Key Points

  • Come Find Me is the best song for its earworming rhythmic vocal hook and witty AI usage.
  • The album’s core strengths are its club influences and production wit, undermined by weak melodies and problematic AI appropriation.

Themes

AI vocals club music influences melody loss appropriation concerns production vs human expression

Critic's Take

Caribou's Honey feels like a shimmering, summer-infused record that wants to make you move, and the reviewer's affection for tracks like “Campfire” and “Broke My Heart” is clear. The voice is celebratory yet precise, praising minimal instrumentation and subtle change as engines that keep songs like “Over Now” and “Climbing” vibrant. It reads as a love letter to electronic restraint and dance-floor joy, recommending the best tracks for anyone asking "best tracks on Honey" or "best songs on Honey" without ever overstating the case.

Key Points

  • The best song, "Campfire", is the album's most affecting moment due to its stripped-back arrangement and emotive delivery.
  • The album's core strengths are minimal, careful production and subtle variation that keep a cohesive, danceable mood from growing repetitive.

Themes

danceable electronics subtle production minimal instrumentation cohesive variety nostalgic synths

Critic's Take

On Caribou’s Honey Ryan Dillon zeroes in on the record’s best tracks as moments where Dan Snaith lets go and the songs breathe. He points to “Do Without You” and the title track “Honey” as early flirtations with club energy, then highlights “Campfire” and “Climbing” as the album’s most rewarding turns, marrying soaring vocals and disco-inflected grooves. Dillon writes with relish about how these best songs on Honey balance nimble pop hooks with sprawling soundscapes, making them both intimate and ecstatic. The narrative rewards listening front-to-back, arguing the true strengths of the best tracks reveal themselves across the album’s arc.

Key Points

  • The best song, "Campfire," is best because of its soaring vocals and ballad-like emotional center that refreshes Caribou's nostalgia.
  • The album's core strength is balancing nimble pop hooks with sprawling, experimental dance soundscapes to make intimate rave music.

Themes

experimentation dance vs. pop fusion intimacy within rave aesthetics creative freedom nostalgia

Critic's Take

There is a studied curiosity throughout Honey, where Caribou tests AI-manipulated vocals against dancefloor craftsmanship. Lewis Wade’s ear is drawn to the tactile club elements - the crisp drum programming of “Broke My Heart” and the wobbly dubstep textures of “Honey” - even as he argues the robotic vocals sometimes dilute emotional warmth. The review points listeners toward the immediate pleasures and the best tracks on Honey, notably “Over Now” and “Honey”, as examples of where Snaith’s arrangements still land with force. Wade ultimately frames the album as an interesting experiment that occasionally waters down feeling, but remains worth hearing for its production and moments of real impact.

Key Points

  • The best song is best for marrying club-forward production with emotional resonance, exemplified by "Over Now".
  • The album’s core strengths are its detailed arrangements and dancefloor textures, even when AI vocals reduce warmth.

Themes

AI manipulation dance/club production vocals versus synths emotional impact

Critic's Take

In a typically enthusiastic register Dylan Barnabe crowns Caribou's Honey as a buffet of bangers, pointing to opener “Broke My Heart” and title track “Honey” as immediate heavy hitters. He writes in energetic, measured praise, noting how the collision of Caribou and Daphni funnels emotive swells and club-ready beats into songs like “Do Without You” and “Come Find Me”. The review frames these best tracks as evidence of Snaith's manic curiosity and sonic ambition, even as he flags the album's more troubling AI detour on “Campfire”. Overall, Barnabe presents the best songs on Honey as both provocative and danceable, a success that pushes the artist's long-running duality forward.

Key Points

  • The best song(s) — notably "Broke My Heart" and "Honey" — stand out as immediate, club-ready heavy hitters that announce the album's direction.
  • The album's core strengths are its duality between emotive Caribou textures and Daphni dance-floor instincts, plus adventurous, sometimes controversial, use of AI.

Themes

duality dance vs emotion AI experimentation curiosity and evolution
Sputnikmusic logo

Sputnikmusic

Unknown
Unknown date
60

Critic's Take

Caribou's Honey is presented as a relentless electronic rush, and the review lands on the best tracks by pointing to their rare melodic payoff. The critic singles out “Honey”, “Climbing” and “Got to Change” as the strongest moments, praising their ability to lift the album above its otherwise uniform, frantic pace. The voice remains measured and slightly disappointed, noting that while those songs emerge as the best tracks on Honey, the record often sacrifices the surprising turns that made earlier Caribou albums memorable.

Key Points

  • The best song is the title track “Honey” because it perfects the opener's frantic elements into a satisfying drop.
  • The album's core strength is relentless forward momentum and cohesive electronic texture, but it sacrifices melodic surprises from earlier records.

Themes

repetition vs. variation frantic tempo electronic production loss of previous charm