All Washed Up by Cheap Trick

Cheap Trick All Washed Up

75
ChoruScore
4 reviews
Consensus forming
Nov 14, 2025
Release Date
BMG Rights Management (US) LLC
Label
Consensus forming Broadly positive consensus

Consensus is still forming across 4 professional reviews. Cheap Trick's All Washed Up returns with a knowing burst of evergreen rock and power-pop that reaffirms the band's late-career vitality. Across four professional reviews the record earned a 75/100 consensus score, and critics consistently point to a blend of bracing rockers and warm balladry as the collection's chief s

Reviews
4 reviews
Last Updated
Mar 23, 2026
Confidence
85%
Scale
0-100 critics
Primary Praise

The best song is “Twelve Gates” because the reviewer calls it a "home run single" and praises its Beatles-like harmonies and explosive payoff.

Primary Criticism

The Best Thing stands out as the album's most charming, heartfelt ballad with huge hooks and a sincere vocal.

Who It Fits

Best for listeners looking for evergreen rock and power pop revival, starting with All Washed Up and Twelve Gates.

Standout Tracks
All Washed Up Twelve Gates The Best Thing

Full consensus notes

Cheap Trick's All Washed Up returns with a knowing burst of evergreen rock and power-pop that reaffirms the band's late-career vitality. Across four professional reviews the record earned a 75/100 consensus score, and critics consistently point to a blend of bracing rockers and warm balladry as the collection's chief strengths. The title track “All Washed Up”, the punchy “Twelve Gates” and the persistent groove of “The Riff That Won't Quit” are singled out by multiple reviewers as standout songs, while “The Best Thing” and “All Wrong Long Gone” supply the album's softer, harmony-rich moments.

Professional reviews praise the songwriting craft and playful nostalgia threaded through the record. Reviewers note tight hooks, stacked harmonies and Randy/Robin-era musicianship that leans into familiarity rather than reinvention - a deliberate power-pop revival that favors feel and immediacy. Critics from Classic Rock and Record Collector emphasize the album's fizz and classic-rock electricity, with “Twelve Gates” described as a home-run single and “The Riff That Won't Quit” as emblematic of the record's relentless riffing. AllMusic and The Line of Best Fit highlight balladry and vocal strength, pointing to “The Best Thing” and “All Wrong Long Gone” as evidence the band still masters mainstream Cheap Trick songcraft.

The consensus balances praise with small caveats - a few reviewers flag the occasional filler - but overall the critical reception frames All Washed Up as a well-crafted, spirited addition to Cheap Trick's catalog that showcases enduring musicianship, self-aware humour and youthful energy. For listeners asking whether All Washed Up is worth hearing, the critical consensus suggests it ranks as a satisfying, often essential set of songs for fans and newcomers attracted to tight hooks and unapologetic rock vitality.

Critics' Top Tracks

The standout songs that made critics take notice

1

All Washed Up

3 mentions

"a strident opener in the title track - a pugilistic rock'n'roller and one of the most exciting songs the band have written"
Record Collector
2

Twelve Gates

2 mentions

"Home run single Twelve Gates flirts with The Beatles ’ Rain"
Classic Rock Magazine
3

The Best Thing

2 mentions

"The Best Thing is one of those dreamy, sunny ballads the band excel at"
Record Collector
a strident opener in the title track - a pugilistic rock'n'roller and one of the most exciting songs the band have written
R
Record Collector
about "All Washed Up"
Read full review
3 mentions
89% sentiment

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

All Washed Up

3 mentions
100
03:35
2

All Wrong Long Gone

2 mentions
71
04:08
3

The Riff That Won't Quit

3 mentions
89
02:48
4

Bet It All

1 mention
44
02:35
5

The Best Thing

2 mentions
99
04:01
6

Twelve Gates

2 mentions
100
03:59
7

Bad Blood

2 mentions
54
04:53
8

Dancing With The Band

2 mentions
10
03:43
9

Love Gone

2 mentions
77
02:54
10

A Long Way to Worcester

3 mentions
56
04:57
11

Wham Boom Bang

2 mentions
43
02:23

Get the next albums worth your time.

Critic-backed picks in one clean digest. No clutter.

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 4 critics who reviewed this album

Critic's Take

Cheap Trick sound as urgent and gleeful as ever on All Washed Up, driven by the turbocharged punch of “Twelve Gates” and the relentless crunch of “The Riff That Won't Quit”. Chris Roberts writes with affectionate relish, noting the band’s knack for classic-rock electricity and pop harmonies while refusing reinvention, which is precisely the album’s charm. He frames “Twelve Gates” as a home run single and treats “The Riff That Won't Quit” as emblematic of the record’s fizz, so fans searching for the best songs on All Washed Up will find those two repeatedly rewarded. The review keeps a brisk, approving voice throughout, celebrating evergreen thrills rather than novelty.

Key Points

  • The best song is “Twelve Gates” because the reviewer calls it a "home run single" and praises its Beatles-like harmonies and explosive payoff.
  • The album’s core strength is its evergreen, turbocharged power pop that prizes classic-rock electricity over reinvention.

Themes

evergreen rock power pop revival youthful energy nostalgia

Re

Record Collector

Unknown
Nov 12, 2025
80

Critic's Take

Cheap Trick’s All Washed Up is a sprightly, diverse celebration of why the band still matters, with the title track and The Riff That Won't Quit emerging as clear highlights. The reviewer calls the opener a "pugilistic rock'n'roller" and one of the most exciting songs the band have written, and praises The Riff That Won't Quit as a funky foot-tapper guaranteed to blow away the blues. Also singled out are the dreamy, sunny ballad The Best Thing and the Bowie-esque Love Gone, which together showcase Randy Zander’s voice and Nielsen’s inventive guitar work. Overall the tone is admiring and upbeat, framing the album as balanced, well-crafted, and far from washed up.

Key Points

  • The title track is best for its pugilistic energy and status as a showstopping opener.
  • The album’s core strengths are its sprightliness, strong hooks, and the band’s playful, well-crafted songwriting.

Themes

vitality in late career playful nostalgia songcraft and hooks
AllMusic logo

AllMusic

Unknown
Nov 17, 2025
70

Critic's Take

Cheap Trick deliver with All Washed Up, leaning into bruising power pop and big-hearted balladry while sounding defiantly undiminished. The reviewer highlights the title track “All Washed Up” as a driving power-pop example and singles out “The Best Thing” for its breathless, heartfelt charm. He praises jangling, harmony-stacked numbers like “Twelve Gates” and the heartbreak of “Love Gone” as evidence the band still master mainstream Cheap Trick songwriting. Even the surprising closer “Wham Boom Bang” is noted as a jaunty, unexpected coda that underlines the album's playful confidence.

Key Points

  • The Best Thing stands out as the album's most charming, heartfelt ballad with huge hooks and a sincere vocal.
  • All Washed Up's core strengths are diverse power-pop songwriting, layered harmonies, and sustained rock energy across styles.

Themes

power pop rock longevity harmonies balladry songcraft

Critic's Take

Cheap Trick sound revitalised on All Washed Up, with the title cut and All Wrong Long Gone standing out as best tracks on the record. The reviewer’s tone is affectionate and wry, noting the energised power-pop of All Washed Up and Robin Zander’s “supernaturally intact” vocals on All Wrong Long Gone. There is room for the odd bit of filler - the record trims its sails neatly and even reserves the Beatlesque charm of A Long Way to Worcester for the end. Overall, the album reiterates Cheap Trick’s brash, noisy brilliance without overstaying its welcome, making these the best songs on All Washed Up for fans of their prime-era sound.

Key Points

  • The title track is best for its energised power-pop riffing and self-referential charm.
  • The album’s core strength is its ability to recapture Cheap Trick’s classic noisy, brash power-pop with assured vocals and concise songwriting.

Themes

legacy power-pop revival self-aware humour enduring musicianship