Constellations For The Lonely by Doves

Doves Constellations For The Lonely

67
ChoruScore
10 reviews
Feb 28, 2025
Release Date
EMI North
Label

Doves' Constellations For The Lonely reintroduces the band with a record that trades some of their earlier propulsive charge for cinematic, melancholic sweep, and critics largely agree that its strongest moments vindicate the comeback. Across ten professional reviews the album earned a 66.7/100 consensus score, with reviewers consistently pointing to crafted high points even as they note moments of uneven pacing and a front-loaded tracklist.

Reviewers consistently praise the opening powerhouse “Renegade” as the album's emotional and sonic fulcrum, while “A Drop In The Ocean”, “Stupid Schemes”, “Southern Bell” and “Cold Dreaming” recur as standout tracks that balance theatrical grandeur with intimate vulnerability. Critics highlight the Williams brothers' elevated vocal presence alongside Jimi Goodwin's intermittent returns, framing vocal contrasts and a lineup shift as central to the record's tension. Themes of estrangement, perseverance and melancholic landscapes thread through the reviews, with many noting cinematic scale, psych-tinged textures and an appetite for sonic experimentation even when catharsis proves partial.

Taken together, the critical consensus paints Constellations For The Lonely as a resilient, occasionally uneven collection whose best songs - chiefly “Renegade” and the mid-album highlights - remind listeners why Doves command such theatrical sweep. Some critics find the album less immediately anthemic than past peaks, while others call it a quietly triumphant return; either way, the record supplies enough standout tracks and emotional heft to merit attention, and sets up fertile ground for closer listening and the detailed reviews that follow.

Critics' Top Tracks

The standout songs that made critics take notice

1

The Butterfly House

1 mention

"The Butterfly House continues with the Williams and Jimi combining vocals with ease"
Louder Than War
2

Renegade

10 mentions

"offers a vulnerable starting point"
Clash Music
3

Southern Bell

8 mentions

"‘Southern Bell’ brings echoes of early Fleet Foxes autumnal folk"
Clash Music
The Butterfly House continues with the Williams and Jimi combining vocals with ease
L
Louder Than War
about "The Butterfly House"
Read full review
1 mention
90% sentiment

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

Renegade

10 mentions
100
05:11
2

Cold Dreaming

10 mentions
89
05:02
3

In The Butterfly House

6 mentions
71
04:10
4

Strange Weather

7 mentions
100
04:41
5

A Drop In The Ocean

6 mentions
100
04:26
6

Last Year's Man

9 mentions
100
04:26
7

Stupid Schemes

7 mentions
100
04:46
8

Saint Teresa

8 mentions
35
04:56
9

Orlando

7 mentions
42
03:26
10

Southern Bell

8 mentions
100
03:46

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 12 critics who reviewed this album

Critic's Take

The reviewer notes that on Constellations for the Lonely the Williams brothers' vocals come to the fore while Jimi Goodwin is less present, and that the record is preoccupied with finding poetry in misery. In the same voice that praises their "prog-tinged productions" the critic singles out “Renegade” and “Saint Teresa” as the most typically Doves moments - impeccably constructed but a bit gloomy. Praise for Goodwin's emotional heft frames “Orlando” as a highlight when he sings, even if his croon is "not at its strongest". The review ultimately suggests the album lacks the propulsive energy of past peaks, making the best tracks notable for craft rather than catharsis.

Key Points

  • Orlando stands out for Goodwin's emotional heft and feels like the best song because his voice lifts the material.
  • The album's core strengths are intricate, prog-tinged production and carefully constructed songs, though often overshadowed by gloom and lack of propulsion.

Themes

misery and poetry vocals and lineup change nostalgia vs momentum intricate production

Critic's Take

Doves return on Constellations For The Lonely with a record that feels both cathartic and quietly triumphant, and the best songs - notably “Renegade” and “A Drop In The Ocean” - stake that claim emphatically. The reviewer revels in the album's melancholic charm, praising “Renegade” as an "awe-inspiring" opening and celebrating “A Drop In The Ocean” as a dizzying highlight. Mid-album cuts like “Strange Weather” and “Last Year’s Man” sustain the quality with lush atmospherics and impassioned balladry, while brighter moments such as “Stupid Schemes” and “Saint Teresa” provide rousing payoffs. This is framed as one of the band's best works, familiar yet adventurous, and therefore the review naturally answers queries about the best tracks on the album in the critic's exact tonal register.

Key Points

  • “Renegade” is the best song because its vulnerable, Blade Runner-inspired opening and Jimi’s raw vocals make it an awe-inspiring statement.
  • The album’s core strengths are melancholic, cathartic songwriting and lush sonic exploration that balance familiarity with adventurous textures.

Themes

melancholy catharsis resilience nostalgia sonic exploration

Critic's Take

Doves sound reinvigorated on Constellations For The Lonely, and the best songs - notably “Renegade” and “Cold Dreaming” - show why. Kyle Mullin relishes the clash of Goodwin’s rugged vulnerability with Jez and Andy Williams’ higher registers, praising the album’s atmospheric sweep and arty touches. He highlights “Last Year’s Man” as a surprising tonal shift that underscores the group’s range. The review reads as measured enthusiasm, pointing to accomplished songwriting and a yearning for Goodwin’s full return to the stage.

Key Points

  • The best song is "Renegade" because its opening drama and Goodwin’s vulnerable delivery make it an immediate standout.
  • The album’s core strengths are atmospheric production, vocal contrasts among band members, and stylistic range.

Themes

vocal contrasts atmospheric indie rock stylistic range resilience

Critic's Take

Doves’s Constellations For The Lonely reads as a delicate yet explosive return, where the best songs - like “A Drop In The Ocean” and “Stupid Schemes” - crystallise the record's newfound tenderness and daring. Kelly Murphy writes with that measured admiration that finds beauty in imperfect starts, noting how tracks lean into vulnerability then erupt into signature anthemic flames. The review emphasises that the album sparkles with strength and fervour, and it is these standout moments that answer the question of the best songs on Constellations For The Lonely without sounding like a staged comeback. Overall, the record feels authentic in its flaws, giving listeners clear reasons to mark “A Drop In The Ocean” and “Stupid Schemes” among the best tracks on the album.

Key Points

  • “A Drop In The Ocean” is best because it is singled out as one of Doves’ most accomplished, with considered pacing and atmosphere.
  • The album’s core strengths are its vulnerability, melodic anthemic moments, and successful sonic experimentation.

Themes

vulnerability melancholy redemption sonic experimentation authenticity

Critic's Take

Doves’s Constellations For The Lonely feels like a triumphant return, the review savoring robust, cinematic moments while dwelling on themes of isolation. The writer singles out “Renegade” for its Blade Runner-inflected lyric - “If you walk out that door then you’re walking out forever,” - and praises “Cold Dreaming” and “In The Butterfly House” for their expansive, Radiohead-like textures. Jez Williams’s lead on “Last Year’s Man” is called a gorgeous, Smiths-referencing highlight, and the bombastic closer “Southern Bell” is noted for its unlikely Queen influence. Overall, the tone is admiring and measured, pointing to an album that soars despite difficult circumstances, making clear which are the best tracks on Constellations For The Lonely.

Key Points

  • Last Year’s Man is the best song because Jez Williams’s lead yields a gorgeous, Smiths-referencing highlight.
  • The album’s core strengths are its cinematic scope, resilient performance despite adversity, and vivid influences.

Themes

isolation estrangement cinematic scale band resilience musical influences

Critic's Take

In this review of Doves and Constellations For The Lonely, the critic argues the best tracks - notably “Renegade”, “Stupid Schemes” and “Saint Teresa” - reveal why the band still conjures grandeur. The voice notes that “Renegade” is an exhilarating opener, all crashing drums and shimmering guitars, while “Stupid Schemes” feels like a return to form when Goodwin is back at the mic. “Saint Teresa” is praised as one of the most lyrically intriguing songs, a mandolin-led ballad that lingers. Collectively these songs anchor an album that is uneven in parts but often stirring enough to guide the band forward.

Key Points

  • “Renegade” is the best song because it restores the band’s anthemic grandeur and showcases Goodwin’s brooding delivery.
  • The album’s core strengths are cinematic, melancholic landscapes and dynamic crescendos, despite uneven vocal distribution.

Themes

fragmentation longing isolation vocal transition melancholic landscapes

Critic's Take

Doves’s Constellations for the Lonely feels like a familiar, atmospheric tapestry that still yields a few clear highlights. The reviewer's voice lingers on “Renegade” as an intense opener and singles out “Southern Bell” as a standout for its stark, courageous lines. He notes that songs such as “Stupid Schemes” and “Cold Dreaming” register distinct moods, even if the album contains fewer immediate standouts than past records. In short, the best tracks on Constellations for the Lonely are those that marry Doves’ drama and soul - chiefly “Southern Bell” and “Renegade” - while the record as a whole rewards patient listening.

Key Points

  • “Southern Bell” is best for its stark, courageous lyrics and being explicitly called a standout.
  • The album’s core strengths are its atmospheric, dramatic compositions and evocative cosmic/Dark Manchester imagery.

Themes

darkness mental health aging band dynamics cosmic imagery Manchester
Louder Than War logo

Louder Than War

Unknown
Feb 23, 2025
92

Critic's Take

Doves return with Constellations For The Lonely, and Wayne Carey is unequivocal in placing songs like “Renegade” and “Cold Dreaming” among the best tracks on the record. He praises “Renegade” as a massive new anthem that "hits the heartstrings," and calls “Cold Dreaming” "majestic stuff," noting its trip-hop psych that climbs the walls. The review keeps returning to the band’s signature soaring vocals and theatrical sweep, explaining why these are the best songs on Constellations For The Lonely and why the album feels like a long-awaited masterpiece. This is a warm, visceral recommendation to anyone asking what the best tracks on the new Doves album are - start with “Renegade” and “Cold Dreaming”.

Key Points

  • The best song is "Renegade" because it functions as a massive, heart-hitting anthem and perfect reintroduction to the band.
  • The album’s core strengths are soaring vocals, theatrical arrangements, and psych-tinged textures that balance melody with emotional heft.

Themes

nostalgia Manchester decline psych/mystic textures soaring vocals theatrical grandeur

Re

Record Collector

Unknown
Jan 23, 2025
80

Critic's Take

Doves' sixth album, Constellations For The Lonely, finds its best tracks in the bruised, atmospheric middle reaches - notably “Cold Dreaming” and “Southern Bell” - because they balance the band’s signature melancholy with moments of uplift. The reviewer lingers on “Cold Dreaming” as a "dizzying psych-tinged swirl" that embodies forgiveness and resilience, while “Southern Bell” supplies the album’s rare pure joyful release when Goodwin takes the vocal and the song turns defiant. Less anthemic than past peaks, the record trades stadium sweep for claustrophobic detail, and it is those songs that best answer the question of the best tracks on Constellations For The Lonely.

Key Points

  • The best song is "Cold Dreaming" because it combines psychedelic sweep with themes of forgiveness and resilience.
  • The album’s core strengths are textured melancholy, atmospheric production, and moments of uplift that underscore perseverance.

Themes

resilience melancholy recovery loss perseverance
Sputnikmusic logo

Sputnikmusic

Unknown
Unknown date
80

Critic's Take

Doves return with Constellations For The Lonely, an album that, in the reviewer's view, keeps pace with their best work while trading some of the old atmospherics for brighter, rock-leaning songs. The best tracks on the record - “Cold Dreaming”, “In The Butterfly House”, “Strange Weather” and “Last Year's Man” - are singled out as the four or five highlights that sit up with the band's previous standouts. The voice here is pragmatic and admiring: these songs provide the album's grabbiest moments even as the running order feels front-loaded. Overall the record is praised for achievement under difficult circumstances, and those top songs are offered as proof that the comeback succeeds on its own terms.

Key Points

  • The best song(s) like "Cold Dreaming" and "In The Butterfly House" stand out because of unique melodies, shared vocals, and otherworldly character.
  • The album's core strength is delivering several standout, bright rock songs despite lineup difficulties, though the tracklist feels front-loaded.

Themes

comeback line-up change bright rocking sound front-loaded tracklist standout highlights