Apples For Isaac by Echo & The Bunnymen

Echo & The Bunnymen Apples For Isaac

79
ChoruScore Critic consensus / 100

Released Sep 18, 2026 BMG Rights Management (UK) Ltd.

Consensus forming 4 professional reviews Updated Nov 1, 2026

Broadly positive consensus

Consensus is still forming across 4 professional reviews. Echo & The Bunnymen's Apples For Isaac turns a deep well of memory into a persuasive late-career spark, pairing familiar grandeur with enough urgency to feel renewed rather than merely nostalgic.

How ChoruScore works

Critics' Top Tracks

The songs critics returned to most

01

Brussels Is Haunted

4 critic mentions

“lead single ‘Brussels Is Haunted’, complete with ‘sha-la-la’ backing vocals, is one of the catchiest things they’ve ever recorded” — Hot Press
02

An Unstoppable Force

3 critic mentions

“The first time the tone of the album genuinely shifts, however, is with ‘An Unstoppable Force” — Clash Music
03

The Honey

3 critic mentions

“the chiming guitars of ‘The Honey’ are combined with backing vocals straight from the ‘60s psych-pop songbook, producing a genuine earworm” — Hot Press
Full critic consensus

Echo & The Bunnymen's Apples For Isaac turns a deep well of memory into a persuasive late-career spark, pairing familiar grandeur with enough urgency to feel renewed rather than merely nostalgic. Its 78.75/100 consensus score across four professional reviews reflects a warmly positive critical reception: reviewers praise the band's revived energy, melodic confidence, and ability to make its history a creative resource instead of a substitute for new ideas.

The best songs on Apples For Isaac show that balance at its sharpest. “Brussels Is Haunted,” praised across all four reviews, layers irresistible vocal hooks and psychedelic color over darker subject matter. “Take Me By The Hand” is another consistent highlight, its immediate chorus giving the record stadium-sized lift, while “An Unstoppable Force” supplies a fragile, elegiac emotional center. Critics also single out “The Honey” for its atmosphere and urgency, and point to the closing “We Prayed In The Dark” as a resonant final statement. Across the record, bright, sometimes Bowie-leaning grooves and stately, orchestral textures meet lyrics shaded by memory, mortality, and unease.

There is little division in the reviews, though their emphasis varies: some celebrate punchy, punk-inflected choruses and the band's combustible rock return, while others focus on its darker emotional weight and cathedral-sized balladry. The shared verdict is that Apples For Isaac makes seasoned songwriting feel vivid again, with standout tracks that honor Echo & The Bunnymen's legacy while reaching beyond it. The full review roundup offers a closer look at the critics' consensus and the songs that make this return worth hearing.

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

Take Me By The Hand

4 mentions
76
03:33
2

Can't Be Sold

2 mentions
49
03:08
3

Brussels Is Haunted

4 mentions
100
03:22
4

I'll Be Your Sunshine

0 mentions
—
03:33
5

Hijacked

1 mention
39
03:25
6

The Honey

3 mentions
88
03:50
7

An Unstoppable Force

3 mentions
100
03:13
8

The Light That Surrounds You

3 mentions
54
03:39
9

Lab Rats Ran

2 mentions
49
03:15
10

Asimov

1 mention
5
03:10
11

We Prayed In the Dark

2 mentions
62
03:13

Get the next albums worth your time.

Critic-backed picks in one clean digest. No clutter.

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 5 critics who reviewed this album

Critic's Take

Echo & The Bunnymen's Apples For Isaac arrives heavy with history, yet it still sparks in moments such as “Take Me By The Hand” and “The Honey”. The reviewer hears flashes of 1980s magic without wholesale nostalgia, noting funk-inflected rhythms and Will Sergeant's familiar guitar textures that let the best tracks stand apart. The album's strongest moments - particularly “Brussels Is Haunted” and “The Honey” - balance atmosphere and urgency, reminding listeners why the band matters. That balance makes the question of the best songs on Apples For Isaac an argument for these assured highlights rather than a rewrite of past glories.

Key Points

  • The Honey is the album's standout for its atmosphere, urgency and comparability to the band's finest material.
  • The album's core strength is blending legacy Bunnymen textures with new, assured songwriting that avoids mere pastiche.

Themes

legacy and continuity maturity and experience atmospheric guitar-led rock nostalgia vs progression

Critic's Take

In his upbeat, considered voice Henry Swales finds the best tracks on Apples For Isaac in moments like “Take Me By The Hand” and “Can’t Be Sold”, where the Bowie-leaning grooves and bright production make the record’s optimism palpable. He highlights “Brussels Is Haunted” for its joyful background vocal hooks that mask grim lyrical material, and singles out “An Unstoppable Force” as the emotional pivot with a tearful string section. Swales frames the closer “We Prayed In The Dark” as a powerful final statement, its hopeful sound belying darker lines, and ultimately calls Apples For Isaac a resounding success for the Liverpool greats.

Key Points

  • The best song moments are those that pair bright, Bowie-tinged production with strong vocal lines, notably on the opening pair and the emotive centerpiece.
  • The album’s core strength is its balance of optimism in sound with darker lyrical themes, supported by smart orchestral arrangements.

Themes

optimism vs darkness nostalgia and Bowie influence orchestral arrangements contrast between upbeat sound and bleak lyrics

Critic's Take

Echo & The Bunnymen have, on Apples For Isaac, rummaged successfully in their memory palace to reclaim a wilder, more unruly spirit. Stephen Troussé writes with affectionate forensic detail that the best tracks, notably “Brussels Is Haunted” and “An Unstoppable Force”, tap into glittering nightclub reminiscence and Leonard Cohen-like gravitas respectively. The record is concise and fleet, eleven brisk songs that refuse to outstay their welcome while letting McCulloch’s singular sense-memory guide the band back toward danger and grandeur. Listeners searching for the best songs on Apples For Isaac will find them where the album balances gutter and stars, pogoing between nervy funk and swooning, cathedral-sized balladry.

Key Points

  • The best song is "Brussels Is Haunted" for its roaring nostalgia and vivid sense-memory.
  • The album’s strength is reclaiming a wilder, memory-laden Bunnymen sound while staying concise and emotionally potent.

Themes

nostalgia late-career reinvention memory and place mortality
75

Critic's Take

Echo & The Bunnymen sound reinvigorated on Apples For Isaac, balancing stadium-ready choruses with a wistful edge. The review savours the immediacy of “Take Me By The Hand” and the irresistible hook of “Brussels Is Haunted”, noting how those best tracks on Apples For Isaac marry singalong heft with melodic craft. McCulloch’s fragile delivery on “An Unstoppable Force” is singled out as a genuine emotional centre, giving the album depth beyond its rock gestures. Overall, the record is praised for rolling back the years without trading on past glories, delivering both earworms and a stately closer.

Key Points

  • The best song is "Brussels Is Haunted" for its irresistible hook and status as one of the catchiest things they’ve recorded.
  • The album’s core strengths are singalong, stadium-ready songs paired with fragile vocal moments and retro-tinged arrangements.

Themes

reinvigoration stadium-friendly singalongs nostalgic psych-pop touches stately, cathedral sound
Louder Than War logo

Louder Than War

Unknown
Sep 16, 2026

Critic's Take

Echo & The Bunnymen sound improbably revitalised on Apples For Isaac, and Sam Lambeth writes with relish about the record's best songs. He singles out “Take Me By The Hand” and “Can’t Be Sold” as the roaring openers that bristle with punky posturing and irresistible choruses. The emotional centrepiece “An Unstoppable Force” is described in spare, elegiac terms, giving the album its moral weight. Elsewhere tracks like “Brussels Is Haunted” and “The Light That Surrounds You” supply psychedelic flourishes and otherworldly magic, making clear why listeners ask, best tracks on Apples For Isaac? These are them, and they make a near-50-year career feel freshly combustible.

Key Points

  • The best song is the opening trio led by "Take Me By The Hand", which sets the album's irresistible, punky tone.
  • The album's core strengths are renewed energy, emotional centrepieces, and tasteful psychedelic flourishes.

Themes

renewal mortality nostalgia rock resurgence