Fallujah Xenotaph
Consensus is still forming across 4 professional reviews. Fallujah's Xenotaph arrives as a widescreen statement that fuses technical death metal virtuosity with an unusual fondness for beauty and spacious melody. Across four professional reviews, critics point to the record's ability to pair virtuosic musicianship and prog metal dynamics with recurring motifs and atmospheric,
The best song, "Step Through the Portal and Breathe", is best for its devastating precision and a stunning closing solo.
Xenotaph's core strengths are layered guitar atmospherics and technical-but-melodic riffcraft despite modern production choices.
Best for listeners looking for technical death metal mastery and atmospheric progression, starting with The Crystalline Veil and In Stars We Drown.
Explore the full Chorus artist page, discography, and related genre paths.
See where this record sits inside the full critic-ranked discography.
Jump from this record into the broader critic-consensus lists for 2025.
Full consensus notes
Fallujah's Xenotaph arrives as a widescreen statement that fuses technical death metal virtuosity with an unusual fondness for beauty and spacious melody. Across four professional reviews, critics point to the record's ability to pair virtuosic musicianship and prog metal dynamics with recurring motifs and atmospheric, cosmic ambience, and the consensus score of 83.75/100 across four reviews underlines that critical regard.
Reviewers consistently praise standout tracks as proof of the album's ambitions: “The Crystalline Veil”, “In Stars We Drown” and “Kaleidoscopic Waves” emerge repeatedly as the best songs on Xenotaph, while “Labyrinth of Stone” and “Step Through the Portal and Breathe” are noted for their dramatic shifts and emotional weight. Critics highlight Scott Carstairs' shimmering, jazz-inflected guitar work and the contrast between clean singing and growls as central to the record's melodic/technical balance. Professional reviews praise the cohesive composition and choral bookends that give the collection a sense of narrative and recurring motifs.
While most writers celebrate the album's blend of brutality and melody and its production choices that emphasize guitar atmosphere and crystalline textures, a more measured voice notes that singular, unforgettable hooks can be elusive amid the record's dense arrangements. Taken together, the critical consensus suggests Xenotaph is both a milestone for Fallujah's technical death metal mastery and a richly produced, emotionally resonant prog metal collection - worth attention for fans seeking the best tracks on Xenotaph and for those curious whether the record balances progression with visceral punch. Read on for detailed reviews and track-by-track impressions below.
Critics' Top Tracks
The standout songs that made critics take notice
The Crystalline Veil
4 mentions
"the way in which The Crystalline Veil allows each component of the band’s makeup to shine is incredibly slick and the elaborate musicianship is quite simply, a joy to listen to"— Distored Sound Magazine
In Stars We Drown
4 mentions
"From sultry opener In Stars We Drown , that gives the first glimpse into the band’s new and expanded palette"— Distored Sound Magazine
Kaleidoscopic Waves
4 mentions
"Kaleidoscope Waves boasts a passage of play where guitarist – and sole original member – Scott Carstairs leads a jazz-fusion dance"— Distored Sound Magazine
the way in which The Crystalline Veil allows each component of the band’s makeup to shine is incredibly slick and the elaborate musicianship is quite simply, a joy to listen to
Track Ratings
How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.
In Stars We Drown
Kaleidoscopic Waves
Labyrinth of Stone
The Crystalline Veil
Step Through the Portal and Breathe
A Parasitic Dream
The Obsidian Architect
Xenotaph
Get the next albums worth your time.
Critic-backed picks in one clean digest. No clutter.
What Critics Are Saying
Deep insights from 5 critics who reviewed this album
Di
Critic's Take
In this review James Weaver argues that FALLUJAH's Xenotaph cements the band at the summit of technical death metal, with top moments like “In Stars We Drown” and “Step Through the Portal and Breathe” standing out as career-defining. The narrative keeps a measured, exaltant tone, noting how individual components coalesce into an exhilarating, cohesive listening experience that sets the benchmark for 2025.
Key Points
-
The best song, "Step Through the Portal and Breathe", is best for its devastating precision and a stunning closing solo.
-
The album's core strengths are virtuosic musicianship, expanded atmospherics, and cohesive songwriting that elevate technical death metal.
Themes
Me
Critic's Take
Fallujah continue to refine their sound on Xenotaph, balancing ferocious complexity with sumptuous, spacey melody in a way that feels both inevitable and exciting. The opener, “In Stars We Drown”, immediately signals this album's gifts with its gentle cosmic prelude and sing-along hooks, making it one of the best tracks on Xenotaph. Equally notable are “Kaleidoscopic Waves” and “The Crystalline Veil”, which display hyperactive jazz-fusion elegance while preserving the band’s violent core. This record is a tremendous accomplishment that rewards longtime fans and newcomers searching for the best songs on Xenotaph.
Key Points
-
“In Stars We Drown” is the best track due to its cosmic prelude, sing-along hooks, and spellbinding contrasts.
-
The album’s core strengths are its blend of vicious technicality with uplifting, spacey melodies and improved chemistry.
Themes
Bl
Critic's Take
In a triumph of scope and detail, Fallujah's Xenotaph finds its best songs in the expansive palette of “In Stars We Drown” and the closing title track “Xenotaph”. The reviewer's voice celebrates how “In Stars We Drown” erupts with '90s death metal majesty while threading angelic clean vocals through blistering leads, and praises the seven-minute “Xenotaph” as most impressive for its symphonic bombast and nimble ensemble work. Mid-album pieces like “Kaleidoscopic Waves” and “Labyrinth of Stone” are noted for length and enigmatic mood changes, while “The Crystalline Veil” and “Step Through the Portal and Breathe” are singled out for dynamics and poignancy. The result the reviewer names plainly is a transcendental tour-de-force that balances beauty and brutality, making these the best tracks on Xenotaph for listeners seeking both technicality and soul.
Key Points
-
The title track is best for its symphonic bombast and technical density.
-
The album's core strengths are its balance of beauty and brutality, meticulous production, and progressive compositional ambition.
Themes
An
Critic's Take
Measured and admiring, Fallujah on Xenotaph leans into sticky guitar candy and bright, extended-range shimmer, making tracks like “Labyrinth of Stone” and “The Crystalline Veil” the record's clearest high points. Fans hunting the best tracks on Xenotaph will find reward in the record's recurring motifs and choral bookends, even if discerning a single, unforgettable hook can be tricky.
Key Points
-
The best song(s) stand out where lush, recurring guitar motifs meet chewy melodic choruses.
-
Xenotaph's core strengths are layered guitar atmospherics and technical-but-melodic riffcraft despite modern production choices.
Themes
