Florence + the Machine Everybody Scream

Critic's Take

Few records claim a title as apt as Everybody Scream, and the best songs on Everybody Scream — notably One Of The Greats and Music By Men — make that case with laser focus. Daisy Carter’s voice registers both fury and theatrical tenderness: ‘One Of The Greats’ is a quietly furious, acerbic rumination that lands as one of the album’s clearest high points, while ‘Music By Men’ is a brittle, self-flagellating ditty saved by measured vitriol. The penultimate ‘You Can Have It All’ stitches the record together as a string-led cinematic epic, giving the album its most cathartic moment. Listeners searching for the best tracks on Everybody Scream will find them where Florence marries theatricality to grievance, transforming personal horror into commanding pop.

Key Points

• One Of The Greats is the best song because it channels quiet fury into precise industry critique with memorable lyrics.
• The album’s core strengths are theatricality, raw grief transformed into cathartic grandeur, and incisive commentary on fame.

Themes

Critic's Take

Johnston writes that the best songs on Everybody Scream are sprawling, cathartic centrepieces: the jaggedly anthemic title track and the astonishing nearly-seven-minute "One of the Greats". She leans into Florence Welch’s voice as a tool of survival, praising how "Everybody Scream" lets her scream and how "One of the Greats" gathers trilling strings and spectral choirs as grievances unspool. Johnston also singles out darker cuts like "Kraken," "Witch Dance" and "Drink Deep" for their body-horror urgency, arguing these tracks make the album’s thesis about grief and letting go feel visceral and earned.

Key Points

• “One of the Greats” is the best song because its seven-minute build, strings and choirs crystallize Welch’s grievances into catharsis.
• The album’s core strengths are Welch’s commanding voice and a consistent embrace of grief-to-catharsis themes across gothic, urgent arrangements.

Themes

Critic's Take

Jaeden Pinder admires Everybody Scream’s horizon-spanning anthems while privileging its moments of uncertainty; the review repeatedly elevates “One of the Greats” and “Drink Deep” as the best tracks for ambition and ritualistic force. Pinder writes in a vivid, image-rich register—the six-and-half-minute “One of the Greats” builds and finally bursts, and the clearest example “Drink Deep” drives a drill into the earth’s core. In identifying the best songs on Everybody Scream, he points to these tracks as where Welch’s fury and vulnerability most fully cohere, even as the title track’s scream feels overly polished.

Key Points

• “One of the Greats” is the best song because its sustained build, emotional purge, and final burst crystallize the album’s ambition and vulnerability.
• The album’s core strengths are Florence’s theatrical voice, arena-ready arrangements, and thematic focus on trauma, resilience, and corporeal unease.

Themes

Critic's Take

Molloy singles out the album’s most vivid moments as the best songs on Everybody Scream: ‘Witch Dance’ and ‘Drink Deep’ feel like ritual pieces, alive with ululations and medieval chorals, while ‘And Love’ closes as a tender, surprising exhale. The best tracks on Everybody Scream turn Welch’s near-death urgency into communal catharsis, mixing folk mysticism with blunt, timely anger about womanhood. It’s these arresting, atmospheric songs that make the album’s standout moments feel both ancient and urgent.

Key Points

• ‘Witch Dance’ is the best song for its vivid, communal, and ritualistic vocal performance.
• The album’s core strengths are its urgent vocal intensity, thematic focus on female trauma and solidarity, and striking blend of folk mysticism with modern concerns.

Themes

Critic's Take

Welch’s Everybody Scream feels like a deliberate, cathartic breakthrough — the best tracks, notably the chugging title track “Everybody Scream” and the haunting “You Can Have It All,” balance raw vulnerability with art-pop grandeur. The record trades bombast for sparse production, letting songs like “Perfume and Milk” and “Kraken” reveal her lyrical detail and emotional stakes. If you’re searching for the best songs on Everybody Scream, it’s those moments where Welch’s voice and narrative crack wide open that stand tallest, turning private turmoil into anthemic, intimate pop.

Key Points

• The title track is best for its chugging anthemic production and central emotional thrust.
• The album’s core strengths are Welch’s candid lyricism, cathartic themes, and sparse production that foregrounds her voice.

Themes

Critic's Take

Three tracks in and you can already vision them on the dimly lit stage; the best songs on Everybody Scream—notably “One of the Greats” and “Sympathy Magic”—wear their fury and ritual like battle armour, with Welch screaming what’s left of her pain. The record’s strength is its live-minded theatricality: drums stomp, guitars blare and a minimal synth palette makes the standout tracks feel like coven rites rather than polished singles. Yet songs such as “Buckle” and “Music by Men” expose the album’s limits offstage, reminding anyone searching for the best tracks on Everybody Scream that this is music designed to be witnessed, not merely streamed.

Key Points

• “One of the Greats” is best for its visceral, stage-ready fury and quoted chorus that crystallizes the album’s catharsis.
• The album’s core strength is its theatrical, live-first production that turns songs into ritualistic performances.

Themes

Critic's Take

Roisin O'Connor finds the best tracks on Everybody Scream — notably the title track and “Sympathy Magic” — to be ferocious and vividly imagined, the album’s ritualistic power borne from Welch’s near-death experience. The reviewer’s voice is swept along by organ flurries and pounding drums, deeming “Everybody Scream” a coven-like opener and “Sympathy Magic” an unleashing as wild as Cathy on the moors. She highlights how “One of the Greats” channels bubbling fury in a Patti Smith drawl and singles out quieter spells like “And Love” for its hopeful, harp-laced peace. Altogether, O'Connor argues these best songs make Everybody Scream Florence’s most focused record, a concentrated confrontation with fame, femininity and survival.

Key Points

• The title track is best for its ritualistic opener, powerful vocals and cinematic instrumentation.
• The album’s core strengths are focused songwriting about womanhood, trauma and fame delivered with mythic, ritualized imagery.

Themes

Critic's Take

Rosenberg writes with brisk analytical relish that Everybody Scream’s best songs — notably “One of the Greats” and the immediate standout “Witch Dance” — capture Welch’s rage, ritual and theatricality with striking clarity. He praises how “One of the Greats” spills out like a raw stream-of-consciousness rant confronting gendered power, while “Witch Dance” surprises with gripping vocal breathing and a rapturous beat switch. The reviewer frames the record as a guttural, flinty rock statement steeped in folk-horror and collaboration, applauding its moments of liberating catharsis even as he flags uneven second-half moments.

Key Points

• “One of the Greats” is best for its raw, confrontational narrative and single-take intensity.
• The album’s core strengths are its cathartic embrace of witchcraft themes, commanding vocals, and bold collaborations.

Themes

Critic's Take

Rachel Kelly finds the best tracks on Everybody Scream to be the vividly imaginative centrepieces: "One of the Greats," "Kraken" and the penultimate "You Can Have It All" stand out for their furious storytelling and theatrical heft. In Kelly's voice the record is praised not for novelty but for sharpened craft — choral swells, harps and cathedral reverb that let Welch's anger and grief land with weight. These best songs on Everybody Scream crystallize the album's themes of vengeance and mourning, where mythmaking and raw emotion make the strongest impressions.

Key Points

• "You Can Have It All" is best for its raw, bone-chilling delivery and emotional clarity.
• The album's strengths are its vivid mythic storytelling, textured arrangements, and candid feminine anger.

Themes

Critic's Take

Petridis singles out the best songs on Everybody Scream with characteristic analytic relish: the title track’s horror‑theme organ and stomping glam beat make it an immediate standout, while One of the Greats mixes Velvet Underground‑ish guitar and smart, spiky humour to interrogate fame and criticism. Drink Deep and You Can Have It All supply the album’s most cathartic crescendos, set off to greater effect by the pared‑back Music by Men, which lets Welch’s melodic gifts breathe. Overall, the best tracks on Everybody Scream show Florence balancing wilfully OTT theatricality with surprising moments of intimacy and hard‑won emotional clarity.

Key Points

• The title track is best for its striking horror‑organ opening and thematic foregrounding of fame.
• The album’s core strength is balancing OTT theatrical crescendos with moments of intimacy that highlight Welch’s melodic gifts.

Themes