Alfredo 2 by Freddie Gibbs & The Alchemist
82
ChoruScore
5 reviews
Jul 25, 2025
Release Date
Freddie Gibbs and Alchemist
Label

Freddie Gibbs's Alfredo 2 arrives as a confident sequel that doubles down on cinematic crime narratives and production craftsmanship, earning praise for both partnership chemistry and tightly sequenced storytelling. Across five professional reviews the record has secured an 82.2/100 consensus score, with critics repeatedly pointing to a mix of opulence, paranoia and moral ambiguity that gives the album its charged atmosphere.

Critics consistently highlight “1995” and “Ensalada (feat. Anderson .Paak)” as standout tracks, while “Lemon Pepper Steppers”, “Jean Claude” and “A Thousand Mountains” emerge as among the best songs on Alfredo 2. Reviewers praise The Alchemist's cinematic, jazz-tinged production - woodwinds, moody piano and sunlit fusion textures recur in notes from RapReviews.com, Beats Per Minute and Clash - and credit Gibbs' technical rapping, vivid wordplay and autobiographical crime storytelling for keeping sequel momentum from feeling rote. Across professional reviews, the album's concision and three-act sequencing are seen as strengths that allow both atmospheric interludes and propulsive highs to breathe.

That consensus is not without caveats. Pitchfork and other critics point to occasional lull moments - songs like “Feeling” and “Shangri La” receive mixed mention - arguing the record reaches its peak when Gibbs shakes off sequelly autopilot and leans into formal intensity. Even so, the prevailing impression frames Alfredo 2 as a return-to-roots collaboration that balances melancholia with warmth, offering craft-forward production and several must-listen tracks that reaffirm Freddie Gibbs and The Alchemist's creative rapport. For readers searching for an Alfredo 2 review or wondering what the best songs are, the critical consensus signals a largely favorable, thoughtfully produced sequel worth exploring.

Critics' Top Tracks

The standout songs that made critics take notice

1

Ensalada (feat. Anderson .Paak)

4 mentions

"The album features three guest appearances and the first of which is Anderson .Paak on “Ensalada”"
RapReviews.com
2

A Thousand Mountains

3 mentions

"is the most cinematic, incorporating woodwind samples and moody piano keys"
RapReviews.com
3

Lemon Pepper Steppers

4 mentions

"The penchant for designer fashion ... is shown on “Lemon Pepper Steppers”"
RapReviews.com
The album features three guest appearances and the first of which is Anderson .Paak on “Ensalada”
R
RapReviews.com
about "Ensalada (feat. Anderson .Paak)"
Read full review
4 mentions
87% sentiment

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

1995

5 mentions
96
04:49
2

Mar-a-Lago

4 mentions
90
02:59
3

Lemon Pepper Steppers

4 mentions
100
02:46
4

Ensalada (feat. Anderson .Paak)

4 mentions
100
03:46
5

Empanadas

3 mentions
91
03:08
6

Skinny Suge II

5 mentions
92
03:11
7

Feeling (feat. Larry June)

3 mentions
15
03:55
8

I Still Love H.E.R.

4 mentions
66
02:52
9

Shangri La

5 mentions
72
03:02
10

Gas Station Sushi

4 mentions
67
03:29
11

Lavish Habits

3 mentions
77
02:57
12

Gold Feet (feat. J.I.D.)

4 mentions
22
03:41
13

Jean Claude

5 mentions
100
03:04
14

A Thousand Mountains

3 mentions
100
04:05

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 6 critics who reviewed this album

Critic's Take

Freddie Gibbs & The Alchemist return with Alfredo 2, and the best songs - notably “1995” and “A Thousand Mountains” - crystallize the album's Tokyo-set crime cinema and narcotic swagger. The opener “1995” sets the tone with cinematic soundscapes and picturesque lyrics, while the closing “A Thousand Mountains” is the most cinematic, its woodwinds and moody piano making the sequel feel like a film. Tracks like “Mar-a-Lago” and “Lemon Pepper Steppers” supply the swagger and designer-brag detail that keep Gibbs’ cocaine-era narratives fresh. This follow-up keeps the original's grit but expands into three acts, giving several standout moments room to breathe and menace.

Key Points

  • The opener "1995" is the best song because it establishes cinematic soundscapes and picturesque lyrics that set the album's tone.
  • The album's core strengths are its cinematic production, cohesive Tokyo/crime theme, and Gibbs' vivid crime narratives delivered with narcotic swagger.

Themes

crime narratives food motifs Tokyo/Japanese imagery opulence and paranoia cinematic production

Critic's Take

Freddie Gibbs & The Alchemist return with Alfredo 2, and the best tracks show Gibbs animated and authoritative rather than complacent. The review singles out “Mar-a-Lago” and “Lemon Pepper Steppers” as standouts where Gibbs raps agitatedly yet with total control, while “Jean Claude” is praised for tension and release in a deceptively simple opening verse. The critic balances praise for those highs with notes about lull moments like “Feeling” and “Shangri La”, arguing that the record’s pleasures come when Gibbs overcomes sequelly autopilot and reasserts his formalist technique.

Key Points

  • The best song moments are where Gibbs sounds animated and controlled, notably on "Lemon Pepper Steppers" and "Mar-a-Lago".
  • The album’s core strengths are Gibbs's formalist technique and moments of renewed urgency that overcome sequelly complacency.

Themes

craftsmanship self-reference technical rapping collaboration autopilot vs vitality

Critic's Take

The best songs on Alfredo 2 stake out a brighter, breezier terrain than its predecessor, and you hear it most clearly on “1995”, “Ensalada” and “Jean Claude”. John Wohlmacher’s voice admires how The Alchemist trades nocturnal smoke for jazzy fusion sunshine, celebrating tunes like “Ensalada” as a near radio hit while praising the eerie noir of “Skinny Suge II”. Gibbs is lauded for razor-sharp delivery and tear-worn empathy, which makes tracks such as “I Still Love H.E.R.” and “Gas Station Sushi” feel both romantic and cinematic. Ultimately, the review positions these best tracks as evidence that Freddie Gibbs and Alc have made a sequel that is different, richly textured and very much worth seeking out.

Key Points

  • “Ensalada” is the best song because it pairs a sticky instrumental hook with Anderson .Paak and broad listenability.
  • The album’s core strengths are The Alchemist’s warm, jazzy production and Gibbs’ precise, emotionally textured delivery.

Themes

nostalgia daytime vs nocturnal aesthetics melancholia tempered by warmth collaboration and listenability crime and autobiographical storytelling

Critic's Take

In a register both celebratory and precise Robin Murray finds Freddie Gibbs & The Alchemist returning to form on Alfredo 2, where the best tracks - notably “1995” and “Ensalada” - showcase a magical partnership and Alchemist’s textural production. The opener “1995” is praised as a crunchy, reflective introduction with Freddie on superb form, while “Ensalada” is lit up by Anderson .Paak and gives the record distinct extrovert energy. Murray singles out the humour of “Empanadas” and Larry June’s chemistry on “Feeling” as key moments, arguing the 14-song, 48-minute sequence feels taut and finessed. Overall the review reads as an enthusiastic endorsement, calling the record a celebration of the art and a platform of excellence.

Key Points

  • The best song is the opener “1995” because it establishes Freddie in superb form over Alchemist’s production.
  • The album’s core strengths are the duo’s chemistry and Alchemist’s textured, cinematic production that make a taut 14-track sequence feel finessed.

Themes

partnership chemistry return-to-roots production craft wordplay concise sequencing
Consequence logo

Consequence

Unknown
Jul 25, 2025
83

Critic's Take

On Freddie Gibbs's Alfredo 2 the best songs are the ones where Gibbs and The Alchemist lock into a hushed, uncanny chemistry - notably “1995” and “Skinny Suge II”. The reviewer's ear latches onto the production as much as the bars, praising how Alchemist's earworm samples make tracks like “Lemon Pepper Steppers” and “Shangri-La” "smooth as fuck" while “Empanadas” lets Gibbs flit through open spaces. This is an album of moral grayness and weary introspection, where the standout songs pair simmering beats with Gibbs' hardened confessions, making them the best tracks on Alfredo 2 for listeners searching for depth and craftsmanship.

Key Points

  • The best song(s) pair Gibbs' weary, introspective verses with Alchemist's evocative, "smooth" production.
  • The album's core strengths are Alchemist's sample work and cohesive production that underscore Gibbs' moral grayness and survival narratives.

Themes

introspection moral ambiguity production craftsmanship trauma and survival