Hannah Cohen Earthstar Mountain
Consensus is still forming across 3 professional reviews. Hannah Cohen's Earthstar Mountain opens like a weathered postcard from the Catskills, folding nostalgic synth-pop into songs that oscillate between grief and wry humour. Across professional reviews, critics point to a record rooted in place and community where vintage influences and dance-pop electronica collide, produ
The title track "Earthstar" is the best song for its hypnotic synths and status as the album’s centerpiece.
Not all coverage is exhaustive - one outlet offered a more informational take rather than track-by-track praise - but the critical consensus emphasizes collaboration, place-based i
Best for listeners looking for Catskills and place and nature and cycles, starting with Earthstar and Mountain.
Full consensus notes
Hannah Cohen's Earthstar Mountain opens like a weathered postcard from the Catskills, folding nostalgic synth-pop into songs that oscillate between grief and wry humour. Across professional reviews, critics point to a record rooted in place and community where vintage influences and dance-pop electronica collide, producing both ecstatic, Madonna-tinged grooves and quieter, elegiac moments. The collection earned a 80.67/100 consensus score across 3 professional reviews, a signal that critics generally praise its ambition and emotional range.
Reviewers consistently single out the title tracks as anchors: “Earthstar” emerges as a hypnotic, synthy stunner while “Mountain” registers as the album's devastating centerpiece - artists and critics alike name them among the best songs on Earthstar Mountain. Other standout tracks noted across reviews include “Good Riddance” and “Math Equation”, praised for sharp lyricism and punchy melodies, plus the tender opener “Amnesia” which provides the record's more elegiac textures. Critics agree the album balances bittersweet irony and sincere mourning, turning heartbreak into catharsis without sacrificing pop immediacy.
Not all coverage is exhaustive - one outlet offered a more informational take rather than track-by-track praise - but the critical consensus emphasizes collaboration, place-based imagery of the Catskills, and Cohen's knack for marrying vintage tropes with modern production. For readers asking whether Earthstar Mountain is worth listening to, professional reviews suggest it is a rewarding, often moving entry in Cohen's catalog that rewards repeated plays and attention to its standout songs.
Critics' Top Tracks
The standout songs that made critics take notice
Earthstar
1 mention
"the hypnotic, synthy stunner " Earthstar"— Rolling Stone
Good Riddance
1 mention
"she manages a perky as well as gorgeously floaty, cathartic, if still bittersweet final track - Good Riddance"— Song Bar
Mountain
1 mention
"the devastating highlight "Mountain," which Cohen wrote following the death of a friend."— Rolling Stone
she manages a perky as well as gorgeously floaty, cathartic, if still bittersweet final track - Good Riddance
Track Ratings
How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.
Dusty
Draggin'
Mountain
Earthstar
Rag
Una Spiaggia
Summer Sweat
Shoe
Baby You're Lying
Dog Years
Get occasional highlights
New releases and the best tracks, based on real critic reviews. No spam.
By signing up, you agree to receive occasional emails from Chorus. Unsubscribe anytime.
What Critics Are Saying
Deep insights from 3 critics who reviewed this album
Critic's Take
In her warm, conversational way Angie Martoccio frames Hannah Cohen’s Earthstar Mountain around specific standouts - notably “Earthstar” and “Mountain” - as the songs that crystallize the album’s mood. Martoccio praises “Earthstar” as a "hypnotic, synthy stunner," and calls "Mountain" devastating, an exorcism of grief with Fleetwood Mac vibes, which makes them the best tracks on Earthstar Mountain. The review highlights the blissful opener “Dusty” as an immediate introduction to Cohen’s universe, cementing these songs as the best tracks on the album by virtue of melody, emotion, and collaboration.
Key Points
-
The title track "Earthstar" is the best song for its hypnotic synths and status as the album’s centerpiece.
-
The album’s core strengths are its sense of place in the Catskills, collaborative warmth, and poignant songwriting about cycles and loss.
Themes
