For Love of Grace & The Hereafter by Iceage

Iceage For Love of Grace & The Hereafter

83
ChoruScore
17 reviews
Established consensus
May 29, 2026
Release Date
Mexican Summer
Label
Established consensus Broadly positive consensus

Iceage's For Love of Grace & The Hereafter arrives as a bracing reclamation of immediacy and raucous joy, and the critical consensus suggests it mostly succeeds. Across 17 professional reviews the record earned an 82.94/100 consensus score, with critics repeatedly pointing to a return-to-roots energy that pairs bleak,

Reviews
17 reviews
Last Updated
Jun 2, 2026
Confidence
89%
Scale
0-100 critics
Primary Praise

Ember is best for its full-bore punk immediacy and role as a powerful opener.

Primary Criticism

“Ember” is the best song because it channels debut-era Strokes energy with effervescent drums and an irresistible vocal line.

Who It Fits

Best for listeners looking for artistic development and punk return, starting with Ember and mother-of-pearl.

Standout Tracks
Ember mother-of-pearl The Weak
Full consensus note: Iceage's For Love of Grace & The Hereafter arrives as a bracing reclamation of immediacy and raucous joy, and the critical consensus suggests it mostly succeeds. Across 17 professional reviews the record earned an 82.94/100 consensus score, with critics repeatedly pointing to a return-to-roots energy that pairs bleak, religious imagery with irresistible rock & roll hooks. The opener “Ember” is repeatedly cited as a volcanic beginning, while “The Weak”, “Star”, “mother-of-pearl” and “Match Head Girl” emerge as the album's clearest standouts.

Critics' Top Tracks

The standout songs that made critics take notice

1

Ember

7 mentions

"Crushing opener ‘Ember’ sets the tone, the jagged guitar line plunging headlong into the madness."
Clash Music
2

mother-of-pearl

5 mentions

"In contrast ‘mother-of-pearl’ is much more unified and linear, displaying a totally different side to the group."
Clash Music
3

The Weak

7 mentions

"In lieu of a guitar solo, The Weak throws up a burst of squeaking atonal recorder-playing"
The Guardian
Crushing opener ‘Ember’ sets the tone, the jagged guitar line plunging headlong into the madness.
C
Clash Music
about "Ember"
Read full review
7 mentions
93% sentiment

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

Ember

7 mentions
100
03:25
2

Match Head Girl

5 mentions
61
03:31
3

The Weak

7 mentions
80
03:15
4

No Fear

4 mentions
46
03:38
5

Salve for Every Sore

3 mentions
46
03:13
6

mother-of-pearl

5 mentions
100
03:43
7

Tender Blades

2 mentions
27
04:03
8

1835

2 mentions
20
03:04
9

Star

6 mentions
74
03:25
10

Lifetime

1 mention
5
03:43
11

Holy Water

4 mentions
43
02:51
12

True Blue

4 mentions
15
03:24

Get the next albums worth your time.

Critic-backed picks in one clean digest. No clutter.

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 17 critics who reviewed this album

Critic's Take

Iceage sound spry and focused on For Love of Grace & The Hereafter, and the best songs show why: opener “Ember” delivers full-bore punk immediacy, while “Match Head Girl” and “No Fear” reveal deft tempo shifts and melodic punch. The reviewer praises the band for corraling styles so the album flows, and singles out “Mother-of-Pearl” and “Holy Water” for marrying bleak lyrics with gleeful music. Read as recommendations for listeners seeking the best tracks on For Love of Grace & The Hereafter, these songs are highlighted for their energy, craft and surprising humour.

Key Points

  • Ember is best for its full-bore punk immediacy and role as a powerful opener.
  • The album’s core strength is tight, punchy songwriting that corals diverse styles into a cohesive, gleeful sound despite bleak lyrics.

Themes

artistic development punk return lyrical bleakness vs. gleeful music musical variety

Critic's Take

Iceage lean into immediacy on For Love of Grace & The Hereafter, and the best songs prove that instinct pays off. The opener “Ember” is a crushing introduction, jagged guitars and breathless vocals that set the album’s frantic tone. Elsewhere “The Weak” and “Star” show the band’s expanded palette - the former charging with a rockabilly gait, the latter offering shoegaze-adjacent melody. If you search for the best tracks on For Love of Grace & The Hereafter, those three capture why this feels like one of their most enjoyable records yet.

Key Points

  • “Ember” is the best song because it immediately establishes the album’s jagged, breathless energy and visceral impact.
  • The album’s core strengths are its immediacy, creative urgency, and the balance of aggression and melody.

Themes

urgency creative expansion post-punk revival melodic aggression

Critic's Take

Iceage make annihilation sound like a bacchanal on For Love of Grace & the Hereafter, and the best songs prove it. The opener “Ember” hits like a live adrenaline rush, tempo pushing and pulling with razor focus, while “mother-of-pearl” functions as the jaunty, double-time centerpiece that fuses post-punk swagger with Strokes-like sheen. Dark love songs such as “Star” amplify the album's dizzying, combustible climax, which is why listeners asking "best songs on For Love of Grace & the Hereafter" will find themselves returning to these tracks again and again.

Key Points

  • “Ember” is the best song because it captures live adrenaline, tight rhythmic interplay, and propulsive tempo shifts.
  • The album’s core strength is fusing gritty early-punk aggression with sunny melodies and danceable, syncopated rhythms.

Themes

return to roots danceable post-punk dark love songs retro energy

Critic's Take

In this review Fred Thomas hears Iceage moving toward a sunnier racket on For Love of Grace & The Hereafter, finding glee inside the racket while keeping the amps turned up. He foregrounds “mother-of-pearl” as a storm of wild-eyed riffs and classic vocal performance, and points to “The Weak” as a punky, upbeat moment that leans Replacements-style, making those two among the best songs on the album. Thomas also singles out “1835” and “Star” for marrying lawless guitars to ‘90s college-rock yearning, which is why listeners asking "best tracks on For Love of Grace & The Hereafter" will often land on these standout cuts. The review keeps the band’s signature severity intact while noting a newfound lightness that lifts several of the album’s top moments.

Key Points

  • The best song is "mother-of-pearl" because it condenses wild guitar storms and a classic vocal performance into a celebratory, feral moment.
  • The album’s core strength is balancing Iceage’s traditional severity with newfound lightness and minimal, immediate production.

Themes

rock & roll revivalism joy amid chaos minimal production influence of classic rock and Madchester

Critic's Take

Iceage sound irrepressible on For Love of Grace & The Hereafter, and the best songs on the album are those that channel that fizzing, raucous energy. Lauren Hunter singles out “Ember” as a standout, a jangling opener that is endearingly loose and charismatically charming, and tracks like “Match Head Girl” and “The Weak” keep the momentum with playful studio abandon. The record’s rough-around-the-edges production and moments of sonic childishness hide a darker heart, which is why the best tracks land so memorably. Listen loud and let songs such as “Ember” and “Lifetime” do the thawing of your morals for you.

Key Points

  • Ember is the best song because it is the jangling, charismatically charming opener that hooks the listener immediately.
  • The album’s core strengths are its fizzing energy and playful, rough-around-the-edges production that mask a darker lyrical heart.

Themes

raw energy playful chaos dark lyrics punkish spontaneity

Critic's Take

Iceage‘s For Love of Grace & the Hereafter feels like a seasoned band surveying its own territory, and the best songs on the album make that reflection thrilling rather than nostalgic. The reviewer's ear lands on “Ember” as an excellent, pop-tinged opener and “The Weak” for its swaggering blues, while “Tender Blades” astonishes with a dissonant chorus that wrong-foots you. These standout tracks showcase how the album blends past evolutions into cohesive, fizzing pieces that still surprise. The result answers searches for the best tracks on For Love of Grace & the Hereafter with songs that are both immediate and gloriously unsettled.

Key Points

  • The best song, “Ember”, is praised for its pop-tinged optimism and strong opener role.
  • The album’s core strength is melding past stylistic evolutions into a cohesive, fizzing record that still surprises.

Themes

retrospection career-spanning synthesis frenetic energy unexpected turns
Mojo logo

Mojo

Unknown
Unknown date
80

Critic's Take

Iceage return to earth on For Love of Grace & the Hereafter, where the best songs, like “Ember” and “Star”, condense love into raw, elemental experience. The opener “Ember” captures love's mayhem with galloping snare and buckling lead guitar, while “Star” is a bombastic, pop-driven sprint that turns love into omnipresence. Elsewhere, the narrative clarity of “mother-of-pearl” and the shimmering, apocryphal tenor of “No Fear” show how theological conviction and grim realism coexist on the record. This is plainly their most refined work yet, immediate and urgent, yielding several standout tracks that answer the question of the best songs on For Love of Grace & the Hereafter with visceral force.

Key Points

  • The best song, "Ember", is best because it compresses love's mayhem into urgent instrumentation and striking lyricism.
  • The album's core strengths are immediacy, theological depth, and a refined balance of beauty and grit.

Themes

love grace religiosity annihilation immediacy

Critic's Take

Iceage sound reinvigorated on For Love of Grace & The Hereafter, and the best tracks prove it: “Ember” bristles with debut-era Strokes joie de vivre, while “Match Head Girl” balances staccato drive with an uplifting bridge. The jangly “The Weak” and the tense love song “Star” show how the band folds twang, rockabilly, and emotion into a relaxed, cathartic record. Across these highlights the band keep a mischievous, garage-y swagger yet retain dynamic tensions that make these songs the best tracks on For Love of Grace & The Hereafter.

Key Points

  • “Ember” is the best song because it channels debut-era Strokes energy with effervescent drums and an irresistible vocal line.
  • The album’s core strength is its relaxed, cathartic return to basics that balances garage-y swagger with dynamic, mature songwriting.

Themes

return to basics beginner's mind garage-rock rejuvenation mature reflection on love and responsibility raw vitality vs. production polish