Precipice by Indigo De Souza
77
ChoruScore
6 reviews
Jul 25, 2025
Release Date
Loma Vista Recordings
Label

Indigo De Souza's Precipice arrives as a confident pop pivot that trades some of her previous grit for widescreen synth-pop craft, and across six professional reviews the record earns a 77.17/100 consensus score. Critics consistently point to hook-forward moments - notably “Heartthrob”, “Crying Over Nothing” and the title track “Precipice” - as the album's clearest triumphs, songs where vocal power and emotional intensity meet irresistible melodic immediacy.

The critical consensus highlights recurring themes of impermanence, coming-of-age vulnerability and the juxtaposition of joy and pain. Reviewers praise De Souza's vocal highs and candid lyricism, and name additional standout tracks such as “Crush”, “Be My Love” and “Pass It By” when discussing the best songs on Precipice. Several reviews emphasize minimalist understatement and synth-pop production that foregrounds hooks and earnest confession, crediting the record with growth and resilience even as some critics find the production overly sanitised compared with her rawer past.

Perspectives split enough to be meaningful - while outlets like Clash and The Line of Best Fit celebrate the album's expansiveness and danceable highs, Pitchfork and The Skinny register ambivalence about a softer edge that mutes sustained risk-taking. Taken together across six professional reviews, the consensus suggests Precipice is worth listening to for its standout tracks and emotional clarity, a timely statement in Indigo De Souza's artistic trajectory that balances accessibility with authentic vulnerability.

Critics' Top Tracks

The standout songs that made critics take notice

1

Heartthrob

6 mentions

"‘Heartthrob’s sucker-punch narrative about how easy it is to be taken advantage of when you’re young and naive"
Clash Music
2

Crying Over Nothing

6 mentions

"‘Crying Over Nothing’ lets go in a whole different way, packing some of the albums’ simplest, saddest lyrics"
Clash Music
3

Precipice

6 mentions

"The latter, on the other hand, is an intimate lo-fi moment that draws everything in"
Clash Music
‘Heartthrob’s sucker-punch narrative about how easy it is to be taken advantage of when you’re young and naive
C
Clash Music
about "Heartthrob"
Read full review
6 mentions
87% sentiment

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

Be My Love

5 mentions
90
02:19
2

Crying Over Nothing

6 mentions
100
03:15
3

Crush

6 mentions
97
02:31
4

Not Afraid

4 mentions
77
03:15
5

Be Like the Water

6 mentions
96
03:28
6

Heartthrob

6 mentions
100
03:13
7

Dinner

4 mentions
60
02:01
8

Clean It Up

2 mentions
10
02:57
9

Heartbreaker

5 mentions
93
02:53
10

Pass It By

5 mentions
91
02:22
11

Precipice

6 mentions
100
03:25

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 7 critics who reviewed this album

Critic's Take

In a review that mourns some lost edge, Indigo De Souza's Precipice still yields clear best songs: “Heartthrob” and “Crying Over Nothing” emerge as the album's most compelling moments, their hooks and urgency cutting through the cleaner synth-pop production. The critic writes in a direct, slightly exasperated voice, praising De Souza's sky-high falsetto and grainy yelp while arguing the rest of the album often plays it safe. They highlight “Not Afraid” as another bright spot, but emphasize that great moments are isolated rather than sustained across the record. The narrative frames searches for "best tracks on Precipice" and "best songs on Precipice" around those three songs, presented as oasis moments amid a sluggish middle.

Key Points

  • “Heartthrob” is best for its lead-single energy, jubilant hook and vocal immediacy.
  • The album’s core strength is De Souza’s vocal power and occasional irresistible hooks amid a cleaner pop production.

Themes

vocal power pop pivot vulnerability production polish loss and upheaval

Critic's Take

On Indigo De Souza's Precipice, the best songs - notably “Be My Love” and “Heartthrob” - stake her claim as a pop songwriter with uncanny emotional heft. The record turns her pop instincts into widescreen arrangements, so “Be My Love” opens as a grand statement and “Heartthrob” rides nervy guitar and driving tempo. Elsewhere, intimate cuts like “Dinner” and the title track consolidate why listeners ask what the best tracks on Precipice are - they balance glittering hooks with devastating confessions. This is pop that keeps the jagged edges, making the best songs on Precipice feel both euphoric and painfully true.

Key Points

  • The best song, "Be My Love", is best because it opens as a grand, synth-drenched statement that crystallizes her pop pivot.
  • The album's core strengths are airtight pop songwriting, vulnerable lyricism, and balancing glittering production with raw emotional moments.

Themes

pop pivot vulnerability mortality resilience synth-pop production

Critic's Take

Indigo De Souza arrives on Precipice with a record that luxuriates in being suspended, and the best tracks show that gorgeous tension. The best songs on Precipice - “Be Like the Water” and “Crush” - capture both the drifting acceptance and fizzing exhilaration that define the album. “Be Like the Water” is a dreamy, irresistible stream of consciousness, while “Crush” brims with unrestrained excitement and earnestness. The opener “Be My Love” and the closer “Precipice” bookend the record, giving the album its expansive, intimate architecture.

Key Points

  • The best song, notably “Be Like the Water”, succeeds by marrying dreamy production with a stream-of-consciousness surrender.
  • The album's core strength is its juxtaposition of euphoric instrumentation and stark, vulnerable lyrics that create a feeling of suspension.

Themes

acceptance juxtaposition of joy and pain coming-of-age vulnerability suspended moment/reflection

Critic's Take

Indigo De Souza sounds newly direct on Precipice, and the review makes clear which are the best songs on Precipice: “Pass It By” and “Crying Over Nothing”. John Amen praises how the album turns De Souza's grungy past toward an uber-pop sensibility, noting that “Crying Over Nothing” launches with upbeat, clubby synths and that “Pass It By” is the project's sonic highpoint with dancey beats and summery synths. He also flags “Heartthrob” and the title track as standout moments, the former lodged in the listener's head and the latter delivering a breathtaking closing statement. The narrative frames these best tracks as proof that De Souza has arrived as a songwriter who balances vulnerability and irresistible hooks.

Key Points

  • “Pass It By” is the best song because it is called the sonic highpoint with dancey beats and summery synths.
  • The album’s core strengths are streamlined, pop-infused songwriting, irresistible hooks, and a clearer, more prominent vocal.

Themes

growth pop sensibility vulnerability impermanence hooks/earworms

Critic's Take

Alex McLevy charts how Indigo De Souza moves fully into pop on Precipice while refusing to abandon her signature edge. He singles out “Be My Love” for its precise falsetto and lingering vocal grit, and highlights “Crying Over Nothing” and “Crush” as the album’s immediate, danceable best tracks. The review praises how songs like “Heartthrob” and “Pass It By” marry exuberant pop hooks with real emotional teeth, and notes the quieter triumphs such as “Dinner” that show a less-is-more restraint. Overall, McLevy presents the best songs on Precipice as both radio-ready and defiantly individual, making the album a successful pop pivot without losing authenticity.

Key Points

  • The best song(s) like “Crying Over Nothing” pair immediate, danceable synth-pop with genuine heartbreak, making them standouts.
  • Precipice’s core strength is balancing radio-ready pop songwriting with De Souza’s persistent emotional rawness and oddball individuality.

Themes

pop pivot authenticity vs. accessibility emotional intensity synth-pop and ‘80s influences minimalist understatement

Critic's Take

Indigo De Souza arrives on Precipice with a record that flirts with megachurch-sized earnestness, and the reviewer's ambivalence lands squarely on songs like “Heartthrob”, “Heartbreaker” and the title track “Precipice”. The writing notes a retreat from the distinctive wailing falsetto into more sanitised instrumentals and broad emotional appeal, which makes the best tracks feel both familiar and oddly domesticated. For listeners asking which are the best songs on Precipice, the review signals “Heartthrob” and “Heartbreaker” as standout moments, even as the overall direction leaves the critic not completely sold. The tone remains protective of the artist's freedom to follow her north star, which frames the praise and reservation together.

Key Points

  • The reviewer singles out “Heartthrob” as a top track for listeners despite reservations about the record's direction.
  • The album's core strengths are sincere songwriting and emotional reach, though tempered by more sanitised production and subdued vocal extremes.

Themes

sincerity sanitised production vocals artistic trajectory