Japandroids Fate & Alcohol
Japandroids's Fate & Alcohol lands as a bruised, arena-sized valedictory that trades youthful abandon for rueful clarity, and across professional reviews the record mostly earns its keep. Critics coalesced around the album's theatrical, Springsteen-tinted storytelling and its tug-of-war between hedonism and self-awareness, with many calling out its farewell tone and arena-ready anthems. The consensus score sits at 71.58/100 across 12 professional reviews, reflecting praise for several high points alongside notes of unevenness.
Reviewers consistently point to a core group of standout tracks as the record's emotional and sonic fulcrums. “Chicago”, “Positively 34th Street” and “Fugitive Summer” recur as best songs on Fate & Alcohol, praised for marrying stomping drums, singalong choruses and bittersweet lyricism; critics also single out “Upon Sober Reflection” and the title track “Fate & Alcohol” for moments of clear-eyed intimacy. Across reviews from Pitchfork, The Guardian, NME, Paste and others, reviewers note the band preserves its punk intensity and gang-vocal catharsis even as songwriting favors maturity, sobriety and finality over youthful excess.
That said, opinions diverge on consistency and invention. Some critics celebrate the record as a fitting, euphoric send-off that sharpens Japandroids' strengths, while others find several cuts slip into familiar tropes or feel less ignited than past highs. Taken together, the critical consensus suggests Fate & Alcohol is worth listening to for its standout anthems and valedictory moments, a passionate if occasionally uneven final statement that frames celebration, exhaustion and reflection in equal measure.
Critics' Top Tracks
The standout songs that made critics take notice
Fate & Alcohol
1 mention
"‘Fate & Alcohol’ is to be the fourth and final record from the Canadian duo"— Clash Music
Fugitive Summer
7 mentions
"Urgency, innocence and, when it comes to fucking up, firsthand experience"— New Musical Express (NME)
Positively 34th Street
8 mentions
"Didn’t share a bed but we shared the same dreams"— Paste Magazine
‘Fate & Alcohol’ is to be the fourth and final record from the Canadian duo
Track Ratings
How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.
Eye Contact High
D&T
Alice
Chicago
Upon Sober Reflection
Fugitive Summer
A Gaslight Anthem
Positively 34th Street
One Without the Other
All Bets Are Off
What Critics Are Saying
Deep insights from 14 critics who reviewed this album
Critic's Take
In a wry, rueful tone the reviewer argues that Japandroids close their story with Fate & Alcohol by leaning into what they do best while acknowledging age and loss. The review elevates “Positively 34th Street” as the record's fitting kiss-off and names “Eye Contact High” and “A Gaslight Anthem” as the catchiest, most immediate moments. The voice is nostalgic and frank, crediting the band for aging gracefully even as many melodies recall earlier highs. Overall the piece answers what are the best tracks on Fate & Alcohol by spotlighting those three songs as the album's standout moments and emotional centrepieces.
Key Points
-
The best song is “Positively 34th Street” because it functions as the album's satisfying, narratively resonant kiss-off.
-
The album's core strength is balancing party-aged exuberance with more nuanced reflection on aging and aftermath.
Themes
In
Critic's Take
Japandroids make a last-stand statement on Fate & Alcohol, where the best songs - “Fugitive Summer” and “All Bets Are Off” - turn boozy memory into existential triumph. Ben Malkin’s voice finds Tom Petty pulsing through contemporary indie, with tracks like “D&T” and “Positively 34th Street” balancing manic drums and chirpier guitars that sell the record’s heartland nostalgia. The record’s closing moments in “All Bets Are Off” feel like the rightful standout finale, a climactic bustle that honours memory and love. This is a farewell album that wears its grit and sentiment proudly, offering the best tracks as distilled, loud elegies rather than tidy epilogues.
Key Points
-
The best song is the closing track “All Bets Are Off” because it provides a climactic, humanistic finale that encapsulates the album's themes.
-
The album’s core strengths are its heartland rock textures, dramatic guitar work, and honest, booze-tinged nostalgia.
Themes
Critic's Take
The reviewer’s voice is bruised and clear: on Fate & Alcohol Japandroids still hit the barroom sweet spot but the keg’s run dry, and the best tracks — notably "Fugitive Summer" and "A Gaslight Anthem" — are the only moments that muster real, lived-in exuberance. Arielle Gordon writes with rueful specificity, praising the guitars that make "Fugitive Summer" feel like Celebration Rock-era transcendence while calling out songs like "Positively 34th Street" and "D&T" for lazy tropes. The result is a final album that recalls their strengths without reinventing them, so searches for the best songs on Fate & Alcohol should point to those few transcendent high points rather than the record as a whole.
Key Points
-
"Fugitive Summer" is best because it recalls the band’s earlier, transcendent Celebration Rock energy.
-
The album’s core strengths are its occasional bursts of guitar-driven exuberance and nostalgic barroom anthems, but these are uneven and undermined by lazy lyrics.
Themes
mu
Critic's Take
Japandroids write like a band waving last-call confessions from the barstool, and on Fate & Alcohol the best songs - notably “Positively 34th Street” and “Chicago” - catch that bittersweet balance between riotous joy and weary resignation. The reviewer’s voice stays revelatory and rueful, praising “Positively 34th Street” as the album’s most lyrical and passionate moment while celebrating “Chicago” for sounding like the Japandroids of old. There is tenderness in the slower closing of “All Bets Are Off” and surgical clarity in “Fugitive Summer”, making the best tracks here feel like a fond, bruised farewell. This record answers searches for best songs on Fate & Alcohol by pointing to those high-emotion, high-velocity moments that still land with cathartic force.
Key Points
-
The best song is "Positively 34th Street" for its lyrical passion and tempered sadness.
-
The album’s core strengths are cathartic live energy translated into bittersweet, reflective songwriting and fierce instrumental peaks.
Themes
Critic's Take
Japandroids's Fate & Alcohol reads like a bruised romcom, where the best songs - notably “Eye Contact High” and “Alice” - feel cinematic and breathless while tracing the record's hedonistic heart. Katie Hawthorne's voice stays sharp and wistful, praising the urgent drumming and soaring gang vocals on “Eye Contact High” and calling “Alice” a bluesy epic that shimmers with anticipation. She balances that admiration with a wary eye toward tracks like “Chicago” and “One Without the Other” which turn the romance sour, making the album a passionate, bittersweet farewell. This framing answers the familiar query about the best tracks on Fate & Alcohol by pointing listeners straight to those cinematic highs and their stakes.
Key Points
-
The best song is “Eye Contact High” for its cinematic urgency and soaring gang vocals.
-
The album's core strength is its blend of Springsteen-style storytelling and punk-fueled, bittersweet romance.
Themes
Critic's Take
Japandroids’s Fate & Alcohol reads like a summation, a farewell record that still bangs with the band’s old, euphoric energy. Craig Howieson moves from the opening catharsis of “Eye Contact High” to the barnstorming raucousness of “Chicago”, making those two songs the clearest standouts on the record. He writes with affection and rue, noting that these ten tracks celebrate the highs and lows of life on the road while carrying a poignant sense of finality. The result answers searches for the best tracks on Fate & Alcohol by pointing to “Eye Contact High” and “Chicago” as the album’s greatest moments.
Key Points
-
The best song is the opener “Eye Contact High” because it restores the band’s euphoric, high-of-being-alive energy right away.
-
The album’s core strength is its ability to pair raucous garage-rock catharsis with a poignant sense of finality and grown-up perspective.
Themes
Critic's Take
Japandroids don’t so much mellow as sharpen on Fate & Alcohol, and the record’s best songs - notably “Upon Sober Reflection” and “Positively 34th Street” - show King’s lyrics moving from bacchanal slogans to something more reflective. The review’s voice stays celebratory but rueful, noting how the guitars and drums still crackle while the words search for deeper meaning. There’s a valedictory purity here: the band knows this is their last ride, and songs like “Eye Contact High” and “D&T” deliver the catharsis of a finale without softening the blast. The result answers queries about the best tracks on Fate & Alcohol by pointing to those emotionally weighty, shout-along moments that land hardest.
Key Points
-
“Upon Sober Reflection” is the best song because its lyrics and jagged tone crystallize the album’s reflective catharsis.
-
The album’s core strengths are concentrated guitars, pounding drums, and a valedictory sense that blends celebration with sober reflection.
Themes
Critic's Take
Japandroids take stock on Fate & Alcohol, and the best songs here - particularly “Chicago”, “Upon Sober Reflection” and “Fugitive Summer” - are where the album really sings. The reviewer’s voice celebrates the band’s arena-ready riffs and stomping drums while noting that the opening trio only flicker rather than ignite, and that the middle tracks achieve the emotional lift the record chases. There is admiration for how these songs mix maturity and raw emotion, even as a few cuts feel overthought or jumbled. The result reads like a valiant send-off, with those three tracks standing out as the best songs on Fate & Alcohol by dint of scale, melody and conviction.
Key Points
-
The best song is "Chicago" for its massive arena-ready guitars and confident, soaring delivery.
-
The album’s core strengths are its anthemic middle trio, mixing mature themes with big, emotive rock arrangements.
Themes
Critic's Take
In Huw Baines's frank, melodic reckoning, Japandroids's Fate & Alcohol finds its best tracks in the rousing one-two of “Chicago” and “Upon Sober Reflection” and the fizzing tenderness of “Positively 34th Street”. He writes with that lived-in, slightly rueful authority that made earlier Japandroids so compelling, noting how the record marries Celebration Rock-style bluster with introspection - the result is songs that still feel like a do-over, even as they accept change. The review foregrounds those three songs as the album's emotional fulcrums, praising their ability to make you forget the lights are about to go out while acknowledging a bittersweet fracture at the heart of the record.
Key Points
-
The best song moments are the rousing, blissfully noisy pairing of 'Chicago' and 'Upon Sober Reflection' that restore the band's live-anthem juice.
-
The album's core strength is balancing Celebration Rock-style guitar bluster with sober, bittersweet reflection on change and adulthood.
Themes
Critic's Take
Japandroids close their career with a record that revisits familiar revelry while practicing a new, rueful restraint on Fate & Alcohol. The review praises “Chicago” for ringing out with nostalgia and names “D&T” and “Fugitive Summer” as key moments where melody and restraint coexist, so readers searching for the best tracks on Fate & Alcohol will find those songs rewarded. Joe Goggins writes in measured, observant sentences that balance admiration for past exuberance with recognition of grown-up reflection, making clear why these are the best songs on the album. The closing storm of “All Bets Are Off” is framed as a farewell, giving the record emotional weight as well as its high points.
Key Points
-
‘Chicago’ is best for its nostalgia and reflective tone, making it the album’s standout.
-
The album’s core strength is balancing their old exuberant garage rock with grown-up self-awareness.
Themes
Critic's Take
Japandroids’s Fate & Alcohol reads like a bruised but defiant goodbye, and the review makes clear the best songs - “Eye Contact High”, “One Without the Other” and “All Bets Are Off” - carry the album. Tony Inglis writes with weary affection, pointing out that the band’s full-throttle guitars and howling vowels remain pleasures even if they were nailed better before. He frames the record as a back-to-basics ode to sobering up and getting out, and elevates the closer as an all-timer that leaves things on a cliffhanger. The result is praise laced with regret: these songs are the standout moments on Fate & Alcohol because they distill the band’s earnest, familiar power into something nearly transcendent.
Key Points
-
The best song is the closer, "All Bets Are Off", because it functions as an emotional all-timer that leaves the record on a cliffhanger.
-
The album’s core strengths are its earnest familiarity, full-throttle guitars and howling vocals that capture sobering-up reflection.
Themes
Critic's Take
In his characteristic measured-yet-wry tone, Ian Gormely argues that Japandroids' Fate & Alcohol finds its strength in songs like “Upon Sober Reflection” and “A Gaslight Anthem”, which crystallize the record's trade-off between stadium-sized anthems and quieter, more considered songwriting. He frames the album as a fitting, if slightly diminished, capstone to a career built on loud chords and gang-vocal choruses, noting that the wanderlust has given way to domestic urgency. The review highlights the best tracks as those that marry King’s newfound specificity with the band’s old sonic punch, making clear which songs work as the album’s emotional center. Overall, Gormely presents the best songs on Fate & Alcohol as proof that Japandroids still know how to write a rousing chorus even while closing a chapter.
Key Points
-
The best song, "Upon Sober Reflection", crystallizes King's newfound clarity and anchors the album emotionally.
-
The album's core strengths are its anthemic guitars, gang-vocal choruses, and the lyrical shift toward domesticity and accountability.