Joyce Manor I Used to Go To This Bar
Joyce Manor's I Used to Go To This Bar compacts nostalgia, melancholy and sharp pop-punk hooks into a short, irresistible set that critics call both matured and distinctly Joyce Manor. Across nine professional reviews the record earned a 76.33/100 consensus score, with reviewers repeatedly pointing to concise songwriting, sonic versatility and an uneasy blend of humour and grief as its defining features. If you want a quick verdict on whether I Used to Go To This Bar is good, the critical consensus lands on broadly favorable: many praise its economy and emotional punch even as some note uneven tones in a few tracks.
Reviewers consistently single out a core group of standout songs as the best tracks on I Used to Go To This Bar. “Falling Into It”, “Grey Guitar” and “I Know Where Mark Chen Lives” recur in critics' lists for marrying infectiously catchy hooks to more adult themes like mortality, depression and friendship. The title-track, along with “All My Friends Are So Depressed” and the rollicking pair “Well, Whatever It Was” and “Well, Don’t It Seem Like You’ve Been Here Before”, receive praise for turning small humiliations and everyday indignities into elegiac, immediate vignettes.
Taken together the professional reviews emphasize growth without abandonment of the band's short-form pop-punk identity: songs are shorter, production sometimes slicker, and the mood more reflective. Some critics flag occasional tonal wobble, yet most agree that tight arrangements and memorable choruses make the album a rewarding stop in Joyce Manor's catalog. Below you'll find the full reviews that flesh out why critics name these tracks as the best on the record and how the album fits into the band's evolution.
Critics' Top Tracks
The standout songs that made critics take notice
The Opposum
1 mention
"The Opposum and Grey Guitar are both so extraordinary"— Sputnikmusic
Well, Don’t It Seem Like You’ve Been Here Before
1 mention
"The latter is a storm of thunderous, maximum overdrive classic-rock-punk that Fucked Up would be proud of"— The Line of Best Fit
Falling Into It
5 mentions
"With the new wave synths on the tremendous "Falling Into It," they pick up where 2022’s excellent 40 oz. to Fresno’s left off."— The A.V. Club
The Opposum and Grey Guitar are both so extraordinary
Track Ratings
How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.
I Used To Go To This Bar
I Know Where Mark Chen Lives
Well, Whatever It Was
All My Friends Are So Depressed
What Critics Are Saying
Deep insights from 9 critics who reviewed this album
Critic's Take
The Los Angeles trio’s I Used to Go to This Bar finds its strongest moments in songs that turn petty humiliations into aching hooks, with “Well, Whatever It Was” and “Grey Guitar” standing out. Grace Robins-Somerville writes in a sharp, slightly sardonic register, noting how a comic misfortune becomes a gut-punch and how memory flattens the dead, which makes the best tracks feel both immediate and elegiac. The review frames the best songs on I Used to Go to This Bar as concise, emotionally precise vignettes rather than grand statements, so searching for the best tracks on the album leads you straight to those character pieces. Overall, the record’s strength is Joyce Manor’s songcraft and their knack for turning small humiliations into pop-punk gold.
Key Points
-
“Well, Whatever It Was” is the best song because a comic mishap is transformed into a gut-punching emotional payoff.
-
The album’s core strengths are concise songcraft and turning small, everyday indignities into resonant pop-punk moments.
Themes
Fa
Critic's Take
The reviewer notes on Joyce Manor's I Used To Go To This Bar that the best tracks shine through their pop-leaning melodies and crisp production, with “Grey Guitar” singled out as a five-star ending and “Falling Into It” praised for its eclectic instrumentation. The piece emphasizes sonic versatility and catchy soundbites as the album's chief strengths, while admitting that some songs - like “After All You Put Me Through” - wobble in tone. Overall, the critic frames the record as self-assured and snappy, recommending these standout tracks for listeners seeking the best songs on I Used To Go To This Bar.
Key Points
-
The best song, "Grey Guitar", is the album’s standout for its moody, brooding guitars and five-star ending.
-
The album's core strengths are its pop-leaning melodies, sonic versatility, and concise, snappy songwriting.
Themes
No
Critic's Take
In Blake Correll's wry, conversational voice the best songs on I Used to Go To This Bar feel immediate and sharply observed. He singles out “I Used To Go To This Bar” and “All My Friends Are So Depressed” as the album's clearest moments, praising their directness and emotional bite. The review's tone is appreciative without fawning, noting tight songwriting and a lucid, lived-in perspective that makes those tracks the best songs on the record. Correll's sentences are plainspoken and exact, which makes his case for the album's top tracks feel persuasive and earned.
Key Points
-
The standout tracks are praised for their directness and emotional clarity.
-
The album's core strength is concise songwriting that feels lived-in and immediate.
Critic's Take
Caleb Campbell writes with fond, seasoned authority that Joyce Manor still excel at concise, irresistible hooks on I Used to Go to This Bar. He singles out “I Used to Go to This Bar” as a burst of nervy energy and wistful nostalgia and praises “Falling Into It” for its ascendant guitars and massive sing-along hook, making both clear candidates for the best songs on I Used to Go to This Bar. The review frames the album as all killer and no filler, emphasizing brevity, sharp harmonies, and punchy choruses as why these tracks stand out. In short, the best tracks on I Used to Go to This Bar are the ones that pair tight pop songwriting with high-octane delivery, notably “I Used to Go to This Bar” and “Falling Into It”.
Key Points
-
“I Used to Go to This Bar” is best for its nervy energy, wistful hook, and Johnson’s jittery vocal performance.
-
The album’s core strengths are concise, impeccable pop songwriting, punchy choruses, and relentless short-form energy.
Themes
Critic's Take
Joyce Manor’s I Used To Go To This Bar lives and breathes in the songs that balance hooks with mortality, and the review points most insistently to “I Know Where Mark Chen Lives”, “Falling Into It”, and the title-track as the best songs. Ethan Beck writes with wry authority about how those tracks glide between pop immediacy and grown-up worry, praising the incisive hook on “I Know Where Mark Chen Lives” and the new-wave synth lift of “Falling Into It”. He also frames the title-track as a wrenching, breathless centerpiece where Johnson’s voice finds a deflated strength. The review makes clear that these are the best tracks on I Used To Go To This Bar because they marry Joyce Manor’s melodic instincts to sharper, more existential lyrical concerns.
Key Points
-
The best song is "I Know Where Mark Chen Lives" for its incisive hook and propulsive, bouncy power-chord verse.
-
The album’s core strengths are melodic pop instincts married to frank meditations on aging and loss.
Themes
Critic's Take
Joyce Manor have perfected a kind of rueful, hooky brevity on I Used to Go To This Bar, and the best songs - chief among them “I Know Where Mark Chen Lives” and “All My Friends Are So Depressed” - show why. Sam Law's voice here is amused and affectionate, noting the record's good humour and massive hooks while admitting nothing lingers for long. He highlights the hazy, surging bittersweetness of the title-track and the sprawling, breezy indie-rock sweep of “All My Friends Are So Depressed” as the album's emotional centers. The result is a short, sweet set where compact songs yield outsized feeling, which makes these tracks the best on I Used to Go To This Bar for listeners seeking quick, resonant hits.
Key Points
-
The best song is “I Know Where Mark Chen Lives” for its massive hooks and encapsulation of the album's laid-back humour.
-
The album's core strengths are concise, hook-filled songs that trade longevity for immediate, bittersweet feeling.
Themes
Critic's Take
Joshua Mills writes with wry affection about Joyce Manor and their new LP I Used to Go To This Bar, arguing the best songs are the anthemic pair “Well, Whatever It Was” and “Well, Don’t It Seem Like You’ve Been Here Before”. He praises the sheer hugeness and pop hooks of “Well, Whatever It Was”, and lauds the thunderous, classic-rock-punk charge of “Well, Don’t It Seem Like You’ve Been Here Before”, naming them the standout best tracks on the album. Those songs, alongside jagged opener “I Know Where Mark Chen Lives” and twangy “All My Friends Are So Depressed”, show how the band balances nostalgia with forward motion.
Key Points
-
The anthemic pair “Well, Whatever It Was” and “Well, Don’t It Seem Like You’ve Been Here Before” are the album’s best songs due to huge hooks and thunderous energy.
-
The album’s strengths are its wistful lyrical reflection and a varied sound palette that balances nostalgia and forward momentum.
Themes
Critic's Take
Joyce Manor’s I Used to Go To This Bar finds its best songs in moments that balance grief and hooks, especially the title track and “I Know Where Mark Chen Lives”. The reviewer returns again and again to the record’s elegiac preoccupations - songs like “Grey Guitar” and “Falling Into It” revel in discomfort while still sounding irresistibly pop. If you want to know the best tracks on I Used to Go To This Bar, start with the title-track and “I Know Where Mark Chen Lives” for their incisive hooks and emotional weight. The album splits grown-up reflection and punk energy in a way that makes those songs stand out.
Key Points
-
The title track is best for its wrenching chorus and emotional directness.
-
The album’s core strength is pairing pop hooks with elegiac themes of death and aging.
Themes
Critic's Take
Joyce Manor have delivered on I Used to Go To This Bar with a collection that proves brevity can be brilliant, and the best songs - like “The Opposum” and “Grey Guitar” - feel epic despite their short runtimes. The reviewer keeps returning to the album's editorial precision, praising how tracks such as “I Know Where Mark Chen Lives” and “All My Friends Are So Depressed” avoid filler and land with immediate impact. There is genuine surprise in the tone, a sense that this is not just a return to form but a career highlight that might rival their debut. This reads like a recommendation for anyone asking what the best tracks on I Used to Go To This Bar are, because each standout earns its place without waste.
Key Points
-
The Opposum stands out as best because it is called extraordinary yet frustratingly brief.
-
The album's core strength is concise, varied songwriting that maximizes impact without filler.