Send A Prayer My Way by Julien Baker & TORRES

Julien Baker & TORRES Send A Prayer My Way

78
ChoruScore
17 reviews
Apr 18, 2025
Release Date
Matador
Label

Julien Baker and TORRES' Send A Prayer My Way stakes a quietly daring claim: a queer-inflected, alt-country record that balances tenderness and defiance while mining Southern songwriting for fresh, intimate narratives. Across 17 professional reviews the critical consensus recognizes the duo's vocal chemistry and plainspoken storytelling as the album's strengths, with critics repeatedly pointing to the record's best songs such as “Tuesday”, “Sugar in the Tank”, “Dirt” and “Bottom of a Bottle”.

Reviewers praise the album's intimacy and restraint, noting sparse instrumentation - banjo, fiddle and pedal steel - that foregrounds harmonies and lyrical specificity. Pitchfork, The Guardian and PopMatters highlight “Tuesday” for its tender, confrontational queer narrative, while Paste, Rolling Stone and Slant single out “Sugar in the Tank” as an anthemic centerpiece. Tracks like “Dirt” and “Bottom of a Bottle” are repeatedly cited as standout tracks for their ache, hospitality to country conventions, and humor-tinged melancholy. The record earned a 78.09/100 consensus score across 17 professional reviews, a signal that critics generally admire the work even when they note occasional pastiche or genre play that undercuts authenticity.

Taken together the reviews frame Send A Prayer My Way as a rewarding collaboration - a lover's quarrel with country tradition that leans into queer reclamation, mortality, addiction and resilience. Some critics found a few moments too reverent to be revolutionary, while others celebrate it as a heartfelt reinvention; either way the consensus suggests the album is worth hearing for its best songs and the honest duetcraft that anchors them. Read on for full reviews and track-by-track reactions.

Critics' Top Tracks

The standout songs that made critics take notice

1

Sugar in the Tank

14 mentions

"especially on "Sugar in the Tank," a joyful, romantic paeon"
Slant Magazine
2

Dirt

11 mentions

""Dirt", the opener, matches the genre’s sparse acoustics with the qualifying awareness of mortality."
PopMatters
3

The Title Track

1 mention

"powerful and soaring in the bold, anthemic choruses of the title track"
Indie Is Not A Genre
especially on "Sugar in the Tank," a joyful, romantic paeon
S
Slant Magazine
about "Sugar in the Tank"
Read full review
14 mentions
87% sentiment

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

Dirt

11 mentions
100
04:37
2

The Only Marble I've Got Left

11 mentions
75
02:45
3

Sugar in the Tank

14 mentions
100
03:42
4

Bottom of a Bottle

12 mentions
100
03:56
5

Downhill Both Ways

8 mentions
48
03:21
6

No Desert Flower

12 mentions
53
03:18
7

Tape Runs Out

12 mentions
86
03:21
8

Off the Wagon

9 mentions
66
03:35
9

Tuesday

17 mentions
100
03:36
10

Showdown

7 mentions
35
02:53
11

Sylvia

11 mentions
99
02:20
12

Goodbye Baby

9 mentions
41
02:13

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 20 critics who reviewed this album

Critic's Take

In his measured, context-rich voice Rick Quinn argues that Julien Baker and Torres craft a true country record with Send a Prayer My Way, where the best tracks - notably “The Only Marble I’ve Got Left” and “Tuesday” - reveal the album’s gifts. He leans into the earthy narrative core of country music, praising the duo’s knack for sad, plainspoken storytelling and the sly humor that makes “The Only Marble I’ve Got Left” a standout. Quinn highlights “Tuesday” as the most creative example, a ballad that moves from sparse acoustics to lush walls of sound as shame blooms into self-possession. Throughout, his tone is appreciative yet analytical, positioning these songs as the best tracks on the album because they marry lyrical specificity with evocative arrangements.

Key Points

  • The best song is "Tuesday" because it transforms personal trauma into a powerful, evolving ballad that bridges sparse acoustics and lush arrangements.
  • The album’s core strengths are intimate, narrative songwriting and tasteful country arrangements that foreground queer identity and emotional specificity.

Themes

country revival queer identity shame and redemption mortality introspection

Critic's Take

Julien Baker and TORRES’ Send A Prayer My Way finds its best tracks in intimate, surprising places: “Sugar in the Tank” lands like a collision of two of our best singer-songwriters, while “Sylvia” and “Dirt” supply the album’s most honest, affecting moments. The record often skews conventional, but the chemistry on “Sugar in the Tank” and the quiet ache of “Sylvia” give you the best songs on Send A Prayer My Way, songs that feel lived-in rather than calculated. Even when the duo treads familiar ground, their vocal interplay and Tudzin’s punchy production elevate these tracks into memorable highlights.

Key Points

  • The best song is "Sugar in the Tank" because of its chemistry, fiddle, and comparison to great singer-songwriter collaborations.
  • The album’s core strengths are emotional honesty, vocal chemistry, and punchy production that sometimes elevates otherwise conventional country-pop.

Themes

country pivot queerness religion working-class South substance abuse

Critic's Take

Julien Baker and TORRES have made a surprising, aching country record with Send A Prayer My Way, and the best songs here - notably “Dirt” and “Bottom of a Bottle” - show why. The opener “Dirt” pairs acoustic picking with shared vocals in a way that immediately stakes the album's emotional claim. “Bottom of a Bottle” lands as a classic drinking-to-forget song, fiddle and honky-tonk piano wrapping pristine harmonies around visceral lyrics. Elsewhere, “Sylvia” and the closer “Goodbye Baby” reaffirm the record's strengths: smart lyrics, collaborative singing, and a proudly queer outlaw-country sensibility.

Key Points

  • The best song is "Bottom of a Bottle" for its classic drinking-song construction, instrumentation, and visceral harmonies.
  • The album's core strengths are smart lyrics, collaborative vocals, and a proudly queer outlaw-country reinterpretation of familiar themes.

Themes

heartache loneliness working-class empathy queer country touring and distance

Critic's Take

Julien Baker and Torres reconceive Send A Prayer My Way as a warm, inclusive outlaw-country record that foregrounds its best tracks, notably “Sugar in the Tank” and “Off the Wagon”. The reviewer's voice delights in the duo's vocal blend and the giddy joy of “Sugar in the Tank”, while lingering on the fragile, tentative confession of “Off the Wagon” where Baker sings about "threading the needle, changing the dose". There is also praise for “Tuesday” as Scott unpacks a suppressed queer coming-of-age story, each song using country rules to invite new conversations. The result is an album whose strongest songs pair melodic resolution with frank, modern takes on old country cliches.

Key Points

  • The best song is "Sugar in the Tank" because its giddy joy and sweet strum showcase the duo's perfect vocal blend.
  • The album's core strengths are its warm, inclusive queer storytelling and the skillful use of country traditions to reframe modern narratives.

Themes

queer identity country tradition vs. reinvention addiction and recovery sisterhood/camaraderie storytelling/nostalgia

Critic's Take

On Julien Baker & TORRES's Send A Prayer My Way the best tracks are obvious and irresistible: “Sugar In The Tank” stands out for its blend of Americana, country, pop and indie and an anthemic chorus, while “Bottom Of A Bottle” ups the stakes with an even better chorus and electrifying vocals. The record leans into banjo, pedal steel and fiddle in ways that make songs like “Downhill Both Ways” and “Off The Wagon” feel cathartic and euphoric. TORRES and Baker's vocal chemistry propels quieter moments such as “Tuesday” and the sweet “Sylvia” into genuinely affecting territory. If you search for the best songs on Send A Prayer My Way, start with “Sugar In The Tank” and “Bottom Of A Bottle” and let the harmonies sell you on the rest.

Key Points

  • “Sugar In The Tank” is the best song for its genre-blending, anthemic chorus, and standout instrumentation.
  • The album's core strengths are Baker and TORRES' vocal chemistry, emotive songwriting, and tasteful country instrumentation.

Themes

country shift vocal harmonies banjo and fiddle instrumentation emotional honesty collaboration chemistry

Critic's Take

On Julien Baker and Torres's Send A Prayer My Way, the review hones in on the record's best tracks like “Sugar in the Tank” and “Tuesday” as the moments that most successfully marry country tropes with frank queer feeling. The writer's voice treats “Sugar in the Tank” as confidently rollicking, its repeated "I love you" lines building to an earnest chorus, while “Tuesday” is noted for tender adoration that turns sharp when confronting homophobia. At its strongest, the album reimagines Southern signifiers with genuine emotional payoff; at its weakest, jokes and pastiche undercut authenticity, but the core songs still land with warmth and clarity.

Key Points

  • “Sugar in the Tank” is the best track because its confident duet, repeated 'I love you' lines, and rollicking chorus deliver the album’s clearest emotional payoff.
  • The album’s core strengths are its heartfelt queer storytelling and Southern-rooted instrumentation, even when humor or pastiche undercuts authenticity.

Critic's Take

In plain, affectionate terms Ray Finlayson hears Julien Baker & TORRES making a homey, earnest record with Send A Prayer My Way, and the best tracks - notably “Dirt” and “Tuesday” - show why this tender country experiment works. He praises how “Dirt” sets the stage with mellow pedal steel and a timeless ache, and how “Tuesday” stakes out queer specificity that lands with real honesty. The review balances warmth for the duo's comfort in the genre with the verdict that few songs truly astonish, yet several cuts - like “Showdown” and “Sylvia” - would sit nicely in each artist's catalogue. Overall, it reads as an enjoyable, modest triumph rather than a game-changing one.

Key Points

  • “Dirt” is the best song for its opening, timeless ache and strong country instrumentation.
  • The album's core strengths are its honest queer perspective applied to country traditions and the duo's comfortable interplay.

Themes

queer identity country influence drinking despondency reclaiming heritage

Critic's Take

Alexis Petridis hears, with characteristic cool generosity, an album that privileges intimacy and reclamation: on Send a Prayer My Way the pairing of Julien Baker and Torres makes for quietly devastating moments, especially on “The Only Marble I’ve Got Left” and “Tuesday”. Petridis praises the tastefully arranged alt-country production and the pair's harmonies, and singles out the sweetly upbeat “Sugar in the Tank” as an effective outlier. The review frames the best songs as those that marry low-key musical delights to lyrical sucker punches, explaining why these tracks are the best songs on Send a Prayer My Way without indulging in showy Nashville gloss.

Key Points

  • The best song(s) pair Baker and Torres’ harmonies with sharp, personal lyrics that reclaim country tropes.
  • The album’s core strengths are tasteful alt-country arrangements, intimate production, and emotionally direct songwriting.

Themes

queer country reclaiming personal reclamation religious doubt alt-country aesthetics intimacy and restraint

Critic's Take

Julien Baker and TORRES’ Send A Prayer My Way finds its best tracks in the intimate, bruised storytelling of “Dirt” and the furious, cathartic “Tuesday”. The reviewer lingers on “Dirt” for its tight harmonies and raw honesty, and praises “Tuesday” as the record’s hardest-hitting narrative, reclaiming voice with scathing final lines. The rollicking jukebox energy of “The Only Marble I’ve Got Left” and the sing-along immediacy of “Sugar In The Tank” also mark them as standout moments. Overall, the album is lauded for vocal synergy, emotional authenticity, and a compelling fusion of country and indie rawness.

Key Points

  • The best song is "Tuesday" for its raw narrative, catharsis, and scathing final reclaiming line.
  • The album’s core strengths are vocal synergy, candid lyricism, and a fusion of country intimacy with indie emotional intensity.

Themes

heartbreak addiction shame defiance survival

Critic's Take

Julien Baker and Torres lean into classic country tropes on Send A Prayer My Way, privileging warmth and duet harmonies over immediate pop hooks. El Hunt highlights how tracks like “Tuesday” and “Tape Runs Out” show the duo's sharp lyricism even when the genre's structures sometimes constrain them. The review prizes the playful, dark-humoured moments - “Tape Run Out” and “Goodbye Baby” - as the album's brightest spots, while noting the closer can feel overburdened. Overall, the record is praised as a refreshing, authentically rooted collaboration that rewards listeners who appreciate classic country songwriting.

Key Points

  • The best song, “Tape Runs Out”, stands out for its dark humour and quotable lyric that showcases strong duet lyricism.
  • The album’s core strengths are warm vintage arrangements, duetting vocals, and a reverence for classic country songwriting.

Themes

country tradition duetting vocals Southern upbringing religion and queerness lyricism versus convention
Sputnikmusic logo

Sputnikmusic

Unknown
Apr 17, 2025
72

Critic's Take

In a sunburnt, slyly affectionate tone the reviewer frames Julien Baker & TORRES as two veterans having a lark on Send A Prayer My Way, and the best songs - notably “Sugar in the Tank” and “Sylvia” - are cited as the album's bright spots. The voice is wry and conversational, praising “Sugar in the Tank” for its soaring power-pop chorus and naming “Sylvia” as proof there is gold here, while also celebrating the cinematic slow burn of “Tape Runs Out”. The reviewer keeps it grounded - admiring the yeehaw gambit without pretending it revolutionizes either artist - and points to a comfortable uptick in quality that should make these best tracks someone’s summer soundtrack.

Key Points

  • “Sylvia” is best for its emotionally specific lyricism and proof of genuine gold in the country experiment.
  • The album’s core strengths are evocative storytelling, successful country instrumentation, and playful chemistry between the two artists.

Themes

country pastiche sapphic/queer longing nostalgia and touring life religious trauma

Critic's Take

Julien Baker and TORRES make Send A Prayer My Way feel like an uncluttered, left-of-center country record where the best tracks - “Dirt”, “Sugar in the Tank”, and “Tape Runs Out” - prove the duo are writing damn good songs. The writing is direct and road-weary, and tracks such as “Dirt” and “Showdown” marry moody guitar with cold, hard truth in the reviewer’s favored register. Lead single “Sugar in the Tank” is the unabashed weak-in-the-knees moment here, while “Tape Runs Out” sounds built to thrill live. Overall, the album succeeds because the pair commit fully to storytelling, not costume, and it delivers memorable best songs on Send A Prayer My Way without irony.

Key Points

  • “Dirt” is the album’s best song because it sets the record’s ethos with traditional instrumentation and Baker’s strong lyrics.
  • The album’s core strengths are direct storytelling, committed outlaw perspective, and strong songwriting from both artists.

Themes

outlaw country queer identity survival love and regret storytelling

Critic's Take

Julien Baker and TORRES’s Send A Prayer My Way feels earned, intimate and often brilliant, with clear best tracks that define its emotional core. The heady rush of “Sugar in the Tank” is a joyous highlight, pairing longing and sadness into a chorus that refuses to let go. Opener “Dirt” sets a bleak, understated tone with spare fingerpicked guitar and fiddle, while “Tape Runs Out” darkens the record with a spiralling, howling climax. These songs make clear why listeners searching for the best tracks on Send A Prayer My Way will find themselves returning to those moments again and again.

Key Points

  • “Sugar in the Tank” is the standout for its joyous, longing chorus and vocal interplay.
  • The album’s core strengths are its tasteful country inflections, sparse arrangements, and evocative, specific lyricism.

Themes

country inflections heartbreak and longing LGBTQ narrative sparse instrumentation humour and melancholy

Critic's Take

On Julien Baker & TORRES's Send A Prayer My Way the best songs are those that turn pain into plainspoken grace - opener “Dirt” and lead single “Sugar In The Tank” stand out. The record is a meeting of minds, a masterclass in devastating vulnerability where duet harmonies make the ache feel communal. Their reworking of country tropes gives songs like “No Desert Flower” and “Off the Wagon” fresh queer resonance, while “Sugar In The Tank” delivers an understatedly euphoric centerpiece. This is an album that trades in scars and hope, and those songs are why listeners will call it the album's best tracks.

Key Points

  • The best song is 'Sugar In The Tank' because its euphoric, understated celebration of LGBTQ+ identity functions as the album's emotional centerpiece.
  • The album's core strengths are its candid vulnerability, deft duet harmonies, and recontextualisation of country tropes into queer, contemporary narratives.

Themes

vulnerability queer identity country recontextualisation addiction resilience

Critic's Take

Julien Baker and Torres make a tender, defiant country record on Send a Prayer My Way, and the best songs - notably “Sugar in the Tank” and “Tuesday” - show why. Dolan's ear loves the vocal chemistry on “Sugar in the Tank”, which could be a roots-rock anthem or a country radio hit, while the centerpiece “Tuesday” delivers the album's emotional heft and queer reclamation. He points to the humble, Lucinda-like beauty of “Bottom of a Bottle” and the downcast gorgeousness of “Off the Wagon” as further proofs that these songs rewrite and honor country conventions. The review reads as admiration with sharp detail - a tribute that also nudges the genre forward.

Key Points

  • The best song is "Tuesday" for its narrative power, emotional depth, and role as the album's centerpiece.
  • The album's core strengths are vocal chemistry, lyrical reclamation of country motifs, and blending tradition with personal identity.

Themes

country revival addiction and misery queer reclamation traditional songwriting

Critic's Take

In a voice that folds tenderness into grit, TORRES and Julien Baker make Send A Prayer My Way feel like a lived-in country record, where the best tracks - “Sylvia”, “Bottom of a Bottle” and “Tuesday” - trade in small, devastating stories. The duo's twinning harmonies and plucky instrumentals turn these songs into quiet, immediate centerpieces, and the album's handful of standouts earn their weight by nailing the ache of booze-soaked heartache and recovery. It's intimate, homespun and unflashy, which is exactly why listeners hunting for the best songs on Send A Prayer My Way will keep returning to those torchlike moments.

Key Points

  • The best song, "Sylvia", stands out by crystallizing the album's open-road storytelling and harmonies into a memorable centerpiece.
  • The album's core strengths are intimate storytelling, twinning harmonies, and a seamless blend of indie sensibilities with country instrumentation.

Themes

country revival queer experience addiction heartache storytelling

Critic's Take

Julien Baker and Mackenzie Scott arrive on Send A Prayer My Way sounding both reverent and mischievous, a queer country record that wears pedal steel and banjo as badges of feeling. The reviewer repeatedly singles out “Sugar in the Tank” and “Bottom of a Bottle” as the album's aching centerpieces, and places special emphasis on “Off the Wagon” and “Tuesday” for their lyrical sting. This is praise rooted in specificity - Baker's bell of a voice and Scott's husky alto make the best tracks resonate as true country songs with contemporary bite. For listeners asking what the best songs on Send A Prayer My Way are, the answer comes through the record's yearning catharsis and vocal chemistry, especially on “Sugar in the Tank” and “Bottom of a Bottle”.

Key Points

  • The best song is "Sugar in the Tank" because it combines joyful romance with passion and sincerity, exemplifying the album’s strengths.
  • The album's core strength is its authentic queer country voice, driven by vocal chemistry, traditional instrumentation, and candid songwriting.

Themes

queer country honky-tonk revival heartbreak and drinking sincerity and subversion