Aerial by Kate Bush
83
ChoruScore Critic consensus / 100

Released Nov 7, 2005 Fish People

Established consensus 20 professional reviews Updated Aug 25, 2026

Broadly positive consensus

Kate Bush's Aerial returns after a long silence as a quietly ambitious, emotionally specific landmark that critics largely embraced.

How ChoruScore works

Critics' Top Tracks

The songs critics returned to most

01

Mrs. Bartolozzi (2018 Remaster)

7 critic mentions

“Mrs Bartolozzi, a song that contains the unbelievable chorus of "Slooshy sloshy slooshy sloshy get that dirty shirty clean” — No Ripcord
02

A Coral Room (2018 Remaster)

3 critic mentions

“Then, almost inevitably, Kate goes and finishes this first disc with the best song on the album - in fact, one of her best songs ever.” — Sputnik Music
03

Aerial (2018 Remaster)

7 critic mentions

“You catch a faint whiff of Pink Floyd and her old mentor Dave Gilmour on the title track” — The Guardian
Full critic consensus

Kate Bush's Aerial returns after a long silence as a quietly ambitious, emotionally specific landmark that critics largely embraced. Across 20 professional reviews the record earned an 82.7/100 consensus score, and reviewers repeatedly pointed to intimate, domestic vignettes and expansive second-disc soundscapes as the album's twin strengths. Those looking for an answer to "is Aerial good" will find the critical consensus leans positive: praise for songwriting craft, pastoral imagery, and patient arrangements outweighs occasional notes that parts of the record demand close listening rather than instant hooks.

Reviewers consistently singled out several standout tracks: “Mrs. Bartolozzi (2018 Remaster)” for its haunting domestic poetry, “Aerial (2018 Remaster)” as the euphoric centerpiece of the dawn-to-day suite, and “Prologue (2018 Remaster)” and “A Coral Room (2018 Remaster)” for their plain affect and emotional clarity. Critics praised the album's themes of family life, motherhood, grief and everyday epiphanies, while also noting Bush's taste for experimentation - the recited mathematics of “Pi” was repeatedly cited as an audacious highlight. Across reviews from The Guardian, Pitchfork, Slant and others, professional reviews emphasize that the second disc's conceptual arc - from evening to sunrise - repays patient listening and stands as one of Bush's most cohesive later-period statements.

While some critics wished for more immediate spark, most accounts frame Aerial as a richly detailed comeback that balances domestic mundanity with ambitious soundscapes and moments of genuine transcendence. For readers searching for the best songs on Aerial or what critics say about the record, the consensus points to the tracks above and to an album whose rewards deepen with repeat plays; the full reviews below unpack how those rewards are earned.

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

King of the Mountain (2018 Remaster)

6 mentions
82
04:52
2

Pi (2018 Remaster)

7 mentions
63
06:09
3

Bertie (2018 Remaster)

8 mentions
48
04:19
4

Mrs. Bartolozzi (2018 Remaster)

7 mentions
100
05:58
5

How To Be Invisible (2018 Remaster)

6 mentions
86
05:32
6

Joanni (2018 Remaster)

4 mentions
15
04:56
7

A Coral Room (2018 Remaster)

3 mentions
100
06:12
8

Prelude (2018 Remaster)

2 mentions
47
01:25
9

Prologue (2018 Remaster)

3 mentions
90
05:41
10

An Architect's Dream (2018 Remaster)

3 mentions
15
04:54
11

The Painter's Link (2018 Remaster)

2 mentions
37
01:35
12

Sunset (2018 Remaster)

5 mentions
66
05:58
13

Aerial Tal (2018 Remaster)

2 mentions
58
01:01
14

Somewhere In Between (2018 Remaster)

2 mentions
58
05:04
15

Nocturn (2018 Remaster)

3 mentions
19
08:29
16

Aerial (2018 Remaster)

7 mentions
93
07:54

Get the next albums worth your time.

Critic-backed picks in one clean digest. No clutter.

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 20 critics who reviewed this album

Critic's Take

In his genial, slightly wry way Alexis Petridis argues that Kate Bush's Aerial finds grandeur in small moments, and the best songs on Aerial - notably “Mrs. Bartolozzi (2018 Remaster)” and “Aerial (2018 Remaster)” - do most of that heavy lifting. He revels in Bush turning domestic detail into the extraordinary, praising the "lovely and moving piano ballad" of “Mrs. Bartolozzi (2018 Remaster)” while admiring the second CD's slow, beautiful sequence anchored by “Aerial (2018 Remaster)”. The result, he writes in his characteristically conversational and slightly amused tone, is an album that is sometimes dated but frequently sublime, the kind of return that feels like an event rather than a comeback.

Key Points

  • The best song, “Mrs. Bartolozzi (2018 Remaster)”, is praised for turning domestic detail into moving, erotic wonder.
  • Aerial's core strength is making commonplace events feel extraordinary through pastoral arrangements and intimate vignettes.

Themes

domestic contentment motherhood everyday beauty pastoral imagery
Mojo logo

Mojo

Unknown
Unknown date
100

Critic's Take

Kate Bush's Aerial rewards close listening, and the best tracks on Aerial are the plainly affecting “A Coral Room” and the audacious, peculiar “Pi” - both reveal Bush's mix of literariness and raw emotion. The second disc's arc - from “Prelude” through “Sunset” and “Aerial” - is praised for its consistent sumptuous keys and narrative arrangements, even if it lacks the first disc's standout moments. Overall Hayward presents Aerial as lavish, eccentric and intelligent, a work equal to Bush's best aside from Hounds of Love.

Key Points

  • The album's core strengths are its lavish arrangements, eccentric ambition, and consistent narrative on the second disc.

Themes

family life grief fans and fame nature and birdsong domestic mundanity

Critic's Take

In a graceful return Kate Bush fashions Aerial into an intimate, timeless triumph, and the best tracks on Aerial are unmistakable. The second disc's opener “Prologue” and the propulsive title track “Aerial” are the album's emotional peaks, the former a gentle dawn and the latter a euphoric, maniacal burst of birdsong and laughter. The result is a patient, organic work that often feels dateless, rewarding anyone who comes looking for the best songs on Aerial with vivid, singular moments.

Key Points

  • The best song is the title track's closing euphoria and the second-disc opener “Prologue” because they frame the album's emotional arc with birdsong and ecstatic moments.
  • Aerial's core strengths are its organic patience, domestic intimacy, and timeless eccentricities that make even saccharine moments feel genuine.

Themes

motherhood domestic life nature and birdsong return/comeback timelessness

Critic's Take

The reviewer’s tone is admiring and exacting, noting that CD1 is "virtually flawless, inventive contemporary pop" while CD2 is a more ambitious soundscape suite. Praise sits alongside measured critique - "It doesn't work all the time, but when it does it's a triumph of warmth, depth and clarity" - which explains why those standout songs matter. This reads as both affirmation that the best songs on Aerial repay the wait and a reminder that Bush’s regained voice is most potent in her daring sequences.

Key Points

  • The best song is praised for exemplifying CD1's inventive, mystifying pop and showing Bush still entices listeners.
  • The album’s core strengths are ambitious soundscapes, lyrical maternal memoir, and inventive contemporary pop.

Themes

return from hiatus maternal memoir ambitious soundscapes light and day motifs
80

Critic's Take

Bartolozzi” revives obsessive eroticism through ordinary acts. The result is an album rooted in Bush's oeuvre, graceful and obsessive, with these standout songs best embodying its domestic magic and romantic sweep.

Key Points

  • The title track is the album's most surprising and intense moment, delivering dawn's fury and vocal fireworks.
  • Aerial's core strengths are its detailed domestic vignettes, lush romanticism, and obsessive attention to sonic and lyrical detail.

Themes

domesticity romance nature time of day obsession
Sputnik Music logo

Sputnik Music

Unknown
Unknown date
80

Critic's Take

The critic frames the second disc, A Sky Of Honey, as the album's emotional and musical apex, calling it musically amazing and conceptually powerful.

Key Points

  • The album's core strength is the ambitious, musically varied conceptual second disc, A Sky Of Honey, which the reviewer calls musically amazing and conceptually powerful.

Themes

comeback mourning and loss conceptual song cycle experimentation nature and birdsong

Critic's Take

Kate Bush returns with Aerial, and the review clearly points to best songs like “Mrs. Bartolozzi” and “Pi” as highlights, praised for their evocative imagery and daring conceits. The reviewer lingers on “Mrs. Bartolozzi” for its blend of erotic and poignant domestic detail, and on “Pi” for transforming a recitation of numbers into something nearly sensual. Overall the critic frames the best tracks as patient, nuanced compositions that reward full listens rather than instant hits.

Key Points

  • The best song, "Mrs. Bartolozzi", stands out for its erotic and poignant domestic imagery and is called one of the album's strongest tracks.
  • The album's core strength is patient, nuanced songwriting that favors cohesion, atmosphere, and detailed arrangements over instant pop hits.

Themes

domestic life mathematics and mystery nature and birdsong evening to dawn narrative artistic craftsmanship

Critic's Take

Kate Bush returns with Aerial, a record where the best tracks are quieter revelations rather than fireworks - the hypnotic recitation in “Pi (2018 Remaster)” and the domestic poetry of “Mrs. Bartolozzi (2018 Remaster)” stand out. Dominique Leone writes in a patient, slightly rueful register, appreciating the album's low-key backdrops and lush vocal palette while admitting they seldom leap out. The second disc's gentle arc gives moments of effortless euphoria, though Leone still wishes for a bit more spark. In short, the best songs on Aerial reward close listening rather than instant devotion.

Key Points

  • The best song is "Pi (2018 Remaster)" for its expressive recitation and vocal invention.
  • The album's core strengths are intimate songwriting, lush vocal textures, and understated arrangements that reward close listening.

Themes

motherhood everyday epiphanies nature and seasons understated arrangements