Tha Carter VI by Lil Wayne

Lil Wayne Tha Carter VI

43
ChoruScore
6 reviews
Jun 6, 2025
Release Date
Lil Wayne PD
Label

Lil Wayne's Tha Carter VI arrives as a sprawling, often frustrating chapter in a career defined by peak inventiveness and mercurial highs. Critics agree the record rarely captures the fire of earlier Carter albums, yet across six professional reviews a handful of tracks - notably “Rari (feat. Kameron Carter)”, “Hip-Hop (feat. BigXthaPlug, Jay Jones)”, “Bein Myself (feat. Mannie Fresh)”, “Welcome to Tha Carter” and “Written History” - emerge as clear highlights amid uneven execution. The album earned a 42.83/100 consensus score across six reviews, signaling a broadly lukewarm critical reception that nevertheless flags sporadic competence and moments of nostalgia-driven pleasure.

The critical consensus stresses recurring problems: heavy reliance on star-studded guest collaborations, occasional commercial overreach, and production choices that critics call misguided or recycled. Pitchfork and RapReviews emphasize diminished artistry and a blockbuster-by-committee feel, arguing technical skill too often substitutes for inspiration. Conversely Clash and Rolling Stone praise the record's eclecticism and point to tracks like “Hip-Hop” and “Bein Myself” as proof Wayne can still deliver stadium-ready energy and playful lyricism. Reviewers consistently identify nostalgia and self-mythologising as thematic through-lines - the album looks back to the Carter legacy even as it struggles to make a convincing present-day statement.

Taken together, professional reviews present Tha Carter VI as a pick-and-choose record: not a return to form but not without salvageable moments. For anyone searching for a clear verdict on whether Tha Carter VI is good, the consensus suggests tempered expectations - listen for the standout tracks named above, and approach the full collection as a career-curated playlist rather than a cohesive artistic rebound. Detailed reviews below unpack where the project succeeds and where it falters in Wayne's discography.

Critics' Top Tracks

The standout songs that made critics take notice

1

Rari (feat. Kameron Carter)

1 mention

""Rari," which is handled jointly by Wheezy and Bobby Raps, is a gummy, playful cut with a thunderous low end;"
Pitchfork
2

Hip-Hop (feat. BigXthaPlug, Jay Jones)

2 mentions

"‘Hip-Hop’ is an ode to the art;"
Clash Music
3

Bein Myself (feat. Mannie Fresh)

2 mentions

"‘Bein Myself’ is worthy of stadiums,"
Clash Music
"Rari," which is handled jointly by Wheezy and Bobby Raps, is a gummy, playful cut with a thunderous low end;
P
Pitchfork
about "Rari (feat. Kameron Carter)"
Read full review
1 mention
80% sentiment

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

King Carter

1 mention
31
01:48
2

Welcome to Tha Carter

4 mentions
84
03:35
3

Bells

4 mentions
03:24
4

Hip-Hop (feat. BigXthaPlug, Jay Jones)

2 mentions
100
04:01
5

Sharks (feat. Jelly Roll, Big Sean)

2 mentions
47
03:49
6

Banned From NO

4 mentions
03:38
7

The Days (feat. Bono)

3 mentions
51
04:21
8

Cotton Candy (feat. 2 Chainz)

2 mentions
03:26
9

Flex Up

3 mentions
48
02:50
10

Island Holiday

4 mentions
43
04:17
11

Loki’s Theme

2 mentions
04:10
12

If I Played Guitar

3 mentions
44
02:52
13

Peanuts 2 N Elephant

3 mentions
48
03:12
14

Rari (feat. Kameron Carter)

1 mention
100
02:50
15

Maria (feat. Andrea Bocelli, Wyclef Jean)

1 mention
8
03:23
16

Bein Myself (feat. Mannie Fresh)

2 mentions
100
04:39
17

Mula Komin In (feat. Lil Novi)

1 mention
5
03:51
18

Alone In The Studio With My Gun (feat. mgk, Kodak Black)

0 mentions
02:52
19

Written History

3 mentions
04:42

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 7 critics who reviewed this album

Critic's Take

Lil Wayne sounds deeply diminished on Tha Carter VI, and the review’s blunt verdict is that the best songs here emerge despite Wayne rather than because of him. The author singles out “Sharks (feat. Jelly Roll, Big Sean)” as the album’s unexpected high point, a track dominated by Jelly Roll’s hook and Big Sean’s verse that still oddly lands. Other mentions like “Bells” and “The Days” are offered as evidence of an unfocused record, highlighting confused beats and uninspired samples. The overall tone is one of disappointment, situating this release as another step down from the heights of earlier Carter records.

Key Points

  • The reviewer names "Sharks" as the best track because its guest-driven hook and verse oddly make it the album's lone high point.
  • The album's core strengths are limited to occasional improved syllable structure and rhyme schemes, but these are overwhelmed by poor production and misguided song choices.

Themes

decline from peak misguided production choices collaboration mismatch nostalgia for earlier Carter albums

Critic's Take

Paul A. Thompson finds Tha Carter VI almost entirely bereft of genuinely good songs. He frames the record as a blockbuster-by-committee that substitutes slick production and guest names for real inspiration. When the album does briefly land, it is late in the sequence—specifically on "Rari", which Thompson calls Wayne's best performance here. Elsewhere, tracks like "Flex Up" and "Banned From NO" expose technical rigor as cold arithmetic rather than personality or spark.

Key Points

  • The best song is "Rari" because Wayne delivers his strongest, inspired performance over muscular production.
  • The album's core strengths are technical precision and high production value, but these are undermined by lack of inspiration and excessive commercial grandstanding.

Themes

grandiosity technical virtuosity vs. inspiration commercial overreach collaboration excess diminished artistry

Critic's Take

Hi, everyone. This review calls out the best tracks on Tha Carter VI largely by contrast - the record is a mess but a few moments stick. “Bells” emerges as one of the better songs because Wayne sounds awake and the late '80s B-boy beat actually works. “Peanuts 2 N Elephant” feels like an old-school Wayne highlight, playful and confident amid sloppy missteps. Even so, most songs - from “Welcome to Tha Carter” to “Island Holiday” - are marred by bad ideas and lazy execution, which makes the handful of decent cuts feel like consolation prizes.

Key Points

  • Peanuts 2 N Elephant is best because it channels playful, old-school Wayne energy and production that lets him rap confidently.
  • The album's core strengths are intermittent moments of classic Wayne performance, but they are overwhelmed by poor ideas, lazy execution, and ill-fitting collaborations.

Themes

decline of an artist poor execution nostalgia vs present-day relevance misguided collaborations

Critic's Take

Lil Wayne sounds contentedly playful on Tha Carter VI, and the review points to the best songs as bright spots rather than reinventions. The critic singles out “Cotton Candy” and “Hip-Hop” as moments where Wayne still delights, and grants a charitable nod to “Written History” for its closing ambition. The tone is measured and a little rueful, noting that these best tracks sparkle but do not salvage the album as a whole. The narrative answers queries about the best tracks on Tha Carter VI in the reviewer’s exact voice, emphasizing playfulness, references, and Wayne’s enduring punchlines.

Key Points

  • “Cotton Candy” is best because its playfulness and 2 Chainz cameo let Wayne still entertain effectively.
  • The album’s core strengths are Wayne’s punchlines, cultural references, and playful interpolations, even when there is little at stake.

Themes

nostalgia self-identity celebrity collaborations sport metaphors interpolation/nostalgia production

Critic's Take

In his blunt, unsentimental voice Paul Attard sees few redeeming moments on Tha Carter VI, and he names songs like “Welcome to Tha Carter” and “Banned from NO” as the album’s modest highlights. He writes with a weary precision, noting that “Welcome to Tha Carter” shows "nimble wordplay" even as the rest of the record "putters about with little purpose." The review frames the best tracks as reminders of Wayne’s baseline competence rather than true evolution, which answers the search for the best songs on Tha Carter VI with a resigned, specific thumbs-up for those few lively moments.

Key Points

  • The best song, "Welcome to Tha Carter," is the best because it showcases nimble wordplay and snappy verve amid pervasive listlessness.
  • The album’s core strengths are sporadic moments of Wayne’s former competence, but they are overwhelmed by indifference and recycled ideas.

Themes

staleness indifference unevenness recycling past ideas sporadic competence

Critic's Take

Lil Wayne’s Tha Carter VI is a pleasingly broad return, a buffet of 19 tracks that rewards pick-and-choose listening. The review leans on the best songs when arguing the album’s strength - “Hip-Hop” as an ode to the art, “Bein Myself” as stadium-ready, and “Cotton Candy” for raunchy club energy. Robin Murray’s voice is celebratory and measured, noting that while it does not eclipse 'III', this instalment likely crests 'V' and reasserts Wayne’s worth. The narrative frames these standout tracks as proof that Weezy remains vital and willing to surprise his audience.

Key Points

  • The best song choices like 'Hip-Hop' and 'Bein Myself' showcase Wayne’s artistic conviction and crowd-sized ambition.
  • The album’s core strengths are its eclectic genre-mixing, self-mythologising themes, and surprising guest turns.

Themes

eclecticism self-mythologising career retrospection genre-blending guest collaborations