Lorde Virgin
Lorde's Virgin opens as a bruised, bold reset that stakes a claim for both confessional clarity and club-minded grit. Across 17 professional reviews, critics consistently point to the record's candid focus on identity, bodily realism and family trauma, arguing that its strongest moments pair spare, sometimes corrosive production with sharply observed lyrics. The consensus score of 80.82/100 across 17 reviews signals broad critical approval for a record that prefers ambiguity to tidy closure.
Reviewers single out several standout tracks as the album's emotional and sonic anchors. “Clearblue” repeatedly emerges as a haunting centerpiece, praised for marrying vulnerability and production polish, while “Shapeshifter” is frequently named for its climactic power and theatrical sweep. Other repeatedly noted best songs on Virgin include “Hammer”, “What Was That?” and “Favourite Daughter”—cuts critics say distill Lorde's late-20s ambivalence into exacting pop moments. Many critics also highlight quieter revelations like “David” and “Broken Glass” for turning intimate specifics into universal ache.
Critical voices converge on a few key points: production often leans raw or intentionally undercooked to foreground lyrical honesty; the album tracks a personal reinvention that interrogates fame, gender and motherhood; and its roughly 35- to 40-minute runtime favors concentrated, sometimes abrupt sketches over fully resolved epics. While some reviews note uneven pacing or songs that feel truncated, the prevailing view in professional reviews is that Virgin's frankness, vocal dynamism and moments of pop catharsis make it a compelling, frequently essential step in Lorde's artistic evolution. Read on for detailed reviews that unpack why these best tracks define the record's rebirth and for critics' takes on whether Virgin is worth a deep listen.
Critics' Top Tracks
The standout songs that made critics take notice
If She Could See Me Now (noted as 'If She Could Only See Me Now')
1 mention
"On the startlingly abrasive ‘If She Could Only See Me Now’, she takes a new form – her most muscular and braggadocious:"— New Musical Express (NME)
Current Affairs (lyric context)
1 mention
"problematic viewing of a forbidden sex tape ("Current Affairs");"— The A.V. Club
Clearblue
15 mentions
"Take the affecting "Clearblue", which starts particular—"After the ecstasy, testing for pregnancy""— The A.V. Club
On the startlingly abrasive ‘If She Could Only See Me Now’, she takes a new form – her most muscular and braggadocious:
Track Ratings
How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.
Hammer
What Was That
Shapeshifter
Man Of The Year
Favourite Daughter
Current Affairs
Clearblue
GRWM
Broken Glass
If She Could See Me Now
David
What Critics Are Saying
Deep insights from 20 critics who reviewed this album
Critic's Take
Lorde returns with Virgin, an album that finds its strongest moments in intimate confession and taut production, especially on “What Was That” and “Man Of The Year”. Matthew Dwyer writes with a measured, analytical cadence, noting how tracks like “Hammer” and “Clear Blue” replay vulnerability as a compositional strength. The best songs on Virgin pair spare arrangements with emotional clarity, making “What Was That” a comeback single and “Clear Blue” a haunting centerpiece. This is a record of exposure, where the standout tracks force listeners to confront celebrity and self with equal parts tenderness and sting.
Key Points
-
The best song is the lead single “What Was That” because it signals a stylistic return and is called "a banger" by the reviewer.
-
The album's core strengths are intimate confession, thematic coherence about celebrity and exposure, and strong moments of sparse, emotional production.
Themes
Critic's Take
Lorde's Virgin feels like a course-correction, bringing the dancefloor back after an acoustic detour while still being deeply personal. The reviewer's voice praises the record's "sugary 35-minute rush" and its dark grooves, singling out “Shapeshifter” as the most robust and “If She Could See Me Now” as a late-album highlight. He admires the production's consistency and the daring textures on tracks like “Clearblue” and “Hammer”, even as several songs feel abruptly short or underdeveloped. Overall, the best songs on Virgin are framed as those that fully realize their ideas - chiefly “Shapeshifter” and “If She Could See Me Now” - because they deliver the album's promise more completely.
Key Points
-
The best song is "Shapeshifter" because it is the longest, most developed, and the reviewer calls it the most robust track.
-
The album’s core strengths are consistent, daring production and Lorde’s confident vocal performances, even when songs feel underdeveloped.
Themes
Critic's Take
Lorde’s Virgin feels like a reset, its best songs hitting immediately and refusing layers - the opener “Hammer” sets the tone while “If She Could See Me Now” and “Favourite Daughter” linger as undeniable highlights. Sean Kerwick writes with a measured relish for the album’s raw arrangements and intimate moments, noting how sparse production and candid lines give these best tracks their punch. The reviewer argues that the best tracks on Virgin are those that marry vivid, inexpensive language with exhilarating production, making songs like “Shapeshifter” and “Clearblue” stand out in the record’s triumphant comeback. Overall, the narrative frames Virgin as a thrilling return that puts Lorde’s trajectory back on course, led by those immediate, unforgettable songs.
Key Points
-
The best song(s) stand out because sparse production and candid, inexpensive lyrics make them immediate and memorable.
-
The album’s core strengths are its raw arrangements, vivid mundane detail, and a confident reset that restores Lorde’s distinctiveness.
Themes
Critic's Take
In acute, conversational prose the reviewer argues that Lorde\'s Virgin finds its clearest victories in intimate moments like “David” and the plaintive “Clearblue”, tracks where bluntness and pathos sit together. The record often privileges ambiguity over resolution, letting lines land with comic and tragic force rather than tidy answers. Production is frequently called out as minimal and occasionally undercooked, yet the voice — visceral and hurricane-like — makes songs such as “Shapeshifter” and “David” the best tracks on Virgin. Overall the best songs on Virgin are those that trade in stark writing and emotional exposure rather than maximalist sonics.
Key Points
-
The best song is "David" because it crystallizes intimacy and wise engagement with obscurity.
-
The album's core strengths are stark, blunt songwriting and intimate vocal performances despite minimalist production flaws.
Themes
mu
Critic's Take
Lorde’s Virgin is most alive when it leans into emotional ambiguity, and the best songs - notably “What Was That?” and “Favourite Daughter” - prove it. The review voice lingers on Lorde’s knack for acute observation, praising the incisive lyrics of “Favourite Daughter” while noting that production sometimes mutes impact. There is admiration for vocal range that resurfaces from Melodrama, especially on “Man of the Year” and “Shapeshifter”, where phrasing and texture reclaim urgency. Ultimately, the album’s strength is its willingness to sit in the gray areas rather than resolve them, which makes these tracks the best on Virgin for listeners searching the best songs on the album.
Key Points
-
“Favourite Daughter” is best for its incisive, moving lyrics and emotional clarity.
-
The album’s core strength is Lorde’s vocal dynamism and willingness to inhabit emotional uncertainty.
Themes
Critic's Take
Lorde treats Virgin as a study in unfinished identity, and the best songs - notably “Hammer” and “Clearblue” - capture that restless, rueful honesty with surgical precision. The review’s voice leans into plainspoken marvel, praising how tracks like “Current Affairs” and “David” turn intimate specificity into universal ache. There is a roughness here that the critic finds vital - not tidy closure but continued becoming, which makes the best tracks on Virgin feel alive and necessary.
Key Points
-
The best song, "Clearblue", is best because it turns specific reproductive anxiety into universally affecting emotion.
-
The album’s core strength is its frank, visceral specificity that opens into broader human truths.
Themes
Critic's Take
Lorde returns with Virgin, a record that reconvenes her muscular pop instincts and bodily frankness. The review privileges physically charged moments like “Hammer” and “Clearblue” as the album's best songs, because they make the body the site of revelation and risk. The reviewer praises how tracks marry programmed drums and synthetic sparks with candid lyricism, refusing nostalgic pastiche while still echoing Melodrama. In that voice, the best tracks on Virgin feel both gritty and transcendent, intimate depictions of appetite and transformation rather than mere posturing.
Key Points
-
The best song, exemplified by "Hammer," is best because it makes the body and gender aloud, visceral and revelatory.
-
The album's core strengths are its candid bodily lyricism, programmed-pop textures, and a recurring focus on freedom and transformation.
Themes
Critic's Take
Lorde approaches Virgin with a newfound nakedness, and the best tracks - notably “Current Affairs” and “Hammer” - are the album's clearest revelations. Megan LaPierre's voice privileges messy honesty over prettified pain, so songs like “Favourite Daughter” and “GRWM” function as emotional anchor points that make the record's rebirth convincing. Where earlier albums kept a distance, here Lorde pulls the curtain back and lets the sharp edges and awkward lines land, which is precisely why listeners asking for the best songs on Virgin will point to those intimate, combustible moments.
Key Points
-
The best song is "Current Affairs" because it is called the "undeniable mid-album highlight" with breath-stealing delivery and a satisfying climax.
-
The album's core strength is its raw, unapologetic honesty and thematic focus on embodiment, motherhood, and rebirth.
Themes
Critic's Take
Lorde lets herself be vulnerable and volatile on Virgin, and the best songs - notably “Broken Glass” and “Man Of The Year” - lay that bare with wincing honesty and bruised triumph. The record’s most powerful moments are personal confessions rendered into triumphant choruses and daring textures, so that tracks like “Broken Glass” and “If She Could See Me Now” feel like centrepieces. Even when production choices wobble on songs such as “What Was That”, the album’s candour and inventive sonic swings make it among her keenest work yet.
Key Points
-
“Broken Glass” is the best song because it converts personal trauma into a triumphant chorus and emotional catharsis.
-
The album’s core strengths are candid lyrics, bold sonic experimentation, and a balance of intimacy and ambition.
Themes
Critic's Take
Lorde’s Virgin finds its best songs in the album's taut emotional pivots, especially “Current Affairs”, “Broken Glass” and the closer “David”. Rhys Morgan writes with a clipped admiration, noting the record pares back lushness to reveal mordant textures and playful audacity — the jagged vitality of “Hammer” and “GRWM” sits alongside the hooky pop of “Favourite Daughter” and “Broken Glass”. The review recommends listeners seek out “Current Affairs” for its warmer standout lines, while the restrained warmth of “David” cements the album as quietly brilliant.
Key Points
-
The best song is "Current Affairs" for its sonically warmer standout lines and memorable warmer moments.
-
The album's core strengths are Lorde's pared-back lyricism, mordant textures, and tasteful, hook-forward production.
Themes
Critic's Take
Lorde returns with Virgin, an intimate, often messy record that rewards patience and close listening; the best songs on Virgin - notably “What Was That” and “Clearblue” - feel like the album's clearest statements. Matt Mitchell's tone is candid and observant, aching with the album's contradictions as he praises the vivid moments where Lorde's voice and songwriting cut through. He calls “What Was That” a pop highlight while elevating “Clearblue” as a great exception to the album's more diffuse production, and he repeatedly returns to the emotional center in “David” and “Favourite Daughter” as evidence of Lorde's honesty. The review frames these best tracks as the points where restraint becomes revelation, arguing that Virgin's flaws are part of its potency and making clear recommendations about the album's standout moments.
Key Points
-
The best song, "What Was That," combines pop ambition with flawed but memorable lyrics, making it the album's most talked-about moment.
-
Virgin's core strength is Lorde's unflinching transparency and intimate songwriting, even when production choices dampen hooky payoffs.
Themes
Critic's Take
Lorde arrives bruised and brilliant on Virgin, and the best tracks - notably “Shapeshifter” and “Current Affairs” - prove why. Hague is drawn to the rawness: “Shapeshifter” sets the tone with garage snare and humming synths as Lorde reels off the identities she’s embodied, while “Current Affairs” feeds into the album’s house-party distortion with processed piano and stomach-dropping guitar. The record’s reclamation themes mean the best songs on Virgin double as both confessionals and anthems, balancing vulnerability with production bravado. Ultimately the standout tracks show Lorde reclaiming voice and form, making Virgin feel like a reinvention rather than a retreat.
Key Points
-
Shapeshifter is best for setting the album’s tone with direct lyrics and vivacious production.
-
The album’s core strengths are candid songwriting and successful sonic reinvention balancing vulnerability and bold production.
Themes
Critic's Take
Lorde’s Virgin is, in Jem Aswad’s exact register, a louder, brasher reset - she swaps pastoral hush for busy electronics and confronts messy autobiography head-on. The review nominates “Shapeshifter” as possibly the most powerful song on the album, praising its climactic final minute and swelling production. From the first-minute punch of “Hammer” to intimate moments like “Clearblue”, Aswad frames the best tracks as where vulnerability and production collide to maximal effect. This is an album of revelation and scale, and those searching for the best songs on Virgin will find them where the lyrics and noisy arrangements meet.
Key Points
-
The best song is "Shapeshifter" for its climactic build, overdubbed vocals and string-backed finale.
-
The album’s core strengths are bold production, candid autobiographical lyrics, and a newfound loudness and scale.
Themes
Critic's Take
Lorde returns with Virgin, an album where the best songs - notably “What Was That” and “Man Of The Year” - pair big choruses with corrosive, unsettling electronics. Alexis Petridis writes with clinical admiration, noting that “What Was That” lands with impressive gusto and that “Man Of The Year” builds to a panic-inducing climax rather than a balm. The reviewer emphasises how the record feels closer to Melodrama than to Solar Power, consolidating Lorde's gift for sharp-eyed party-girl observation while exploring late-20s angst. Overall, the best tracks on Virgin are the ones that balance stadium-ready hooks with jagged production and wry lyrical intelligence.
Key Points
-
The best song is “What Was That” because it combines stadium-ready hooks with visceral live performance energy and vivid party-girl imagery.
-
The album’s core strengths are incisive, witty songwriting and bold, corroded electronic production that turns choruses into jolting, emotional moments.
Themes
Critic's Take
Lorde’s Virgin is a lean, jagged return that finds its best tracks in songs like “Favourite Daughter” and “Clearblue”, which fuse raw confession with propulsive synth-pop. The record spares no interiority - on “GRWM” and “Man Of The Year” she excavates family trauma and expanding gender identity with startling candor. There are nearly 40 minutes of undeniable pop bangers where Lorde wipes parts of her past clean and makes room for the adult she has crystallized into. For listeners asking about the best songs on Virgin, the album’s highlights sit squarely on those vivid, emotionally volcanic tracks that pair intimate lyricism with club-ready production.
Key Points
-
The best song is "Clearblue" because it is described as the album's rawest, most visceral, and cathartic moment.
-
The album’s core strengths are candid exploration of identity and family trauma paired with propulsive synth-pop production.
Themes
Critic's Take
Lorde keeps her confessional instincts intact on Virgin, and the best songs - notably “Broken Glass” and “Girl, so confusing” as referenced - are where her sharp, self-interrogating lines land hardest. The record often trades Melodrama's operatic abandon for quieter, pointed observations, and the moments that stick do so because they couple candid lyricism with taut production. For listeners asking "best tracks on Virgin," pay attention to “Broken Glass” for its immediate opening confession and the remix-referenced material that deepens her investigations. The album's brevity sharpens its focus, making the standout songs feel concentrated and exacting rather than diffuse.
Key Points
-
The best song, "Broken Glass," is best because it opens with a blunt confession that sets the album's emotional tone.
-
The album's strengths are candid lyricism and focused, concise songwriting that probe recovery, body image, and adult relationships.
Themes
Critic's Take
Lorde presents a record of rebirth on Virgin, where the best tracks - notably “What Was That” and “Hammer” - balance confession with fizzy electro-pop. Helen Brown writes in a conversational, observant tone, admiring how “What Was That” carries the catchiest melody while “Hammer” bristles with a tingly pulse and blunt lyrics. She praises the album's intimacy and late-night mood even as she notes that melody does not always follow the propulsion. Overall, the review frames the best songs as those that marry sharp lyricism to charged production, pointing to a promising direction for Lorde.
Key Points
-
The best song is "What Was That" because it carries the record’s catchiest melody and commercial momentum.
-
The album’s core strengths are blunt, confessional lyrics and intimate, late-night electro-pop production that suggest a creative rebirth.