Madi Diaz Fatal Optimist

73

ChoruScore Critic consensus / 100

Released Oct 10, 2025 Anti/Epitaph

Consensus forming 4 professional reviews Updated Oct 16, 2025

Mostly positive consensus

Consensus is still forming across 4 professional reviews. Chorus currently scores this album at 73/100 across 4 professional reviews.

How ChoruScore works

Critics' Top Tracks

The songs critics returned to most

01

Feel Something

4 critic mentions

“In “Feel Something”, she sings, “I used to think I needed to read your mind / I’m only gonna find what I’m gonna find and then we’ll fuck and then we’ll fight.” — PopMatters

02

Heavy Metal

3 critic mentions

“I wouldn’t wanna be any different/My idealism makes me self-defensive/Don’t make me take off my gloves/I’ll show you what I’m made of,” — Dusted Magazine

03

If Time Does What It's Supposed To

2 critic mentions

“elsewhere she sings, "One day I'll wake up and I'll be over you/If time does what it's supposed to,” — AllMusic

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:

1

Hope Less

2 mentions

62

03:25

2

Ambivalence

2 mentions

40

04:32

3

Feel Something

4 mentions

100

03:20

"A rare floor tom appears on the relatively uptempo "Feel Something,""

— AllMusic

"In “Feel Something”, she wishes she had never known his middle name."

— PopMatters

"In “Feel Something”, she sings, “I used to think I needed to read your mind / I’m only gonna find what I’m gonna find and then we’ll fuck and then we’ll fight.”"

— PopMatters

"you could hardly ask for a more self-lacerating end-of-the-relationship song than “Feel Something,”"

— Dusted Magazine

"its anguished plea to “ feel something .”"

— Dusted Magazine

4

Good Liar

3 mentions

75

03:44

"occasional philosophical gems, like "Sometimes a good thing can break you/Sometimes a bad thing can save you" from "Good Lair,""

— AllMusic

"as on “Good Liar”."

— PopMatters

"There are moments of solace here—the pretty harmonies of “Good Liar,”"

— Dusted Magazine

5

Lone Wolf

2 mentions

—

03:10

6

Heavy Metal

3 mentions

90

03:55

"Occasionally, as on the beautiful “Heavy Metal”, she takes a long view"

— PopMatters

"“Heavy Metal” hints at intergenerational trauma, a fight-or-flight impulse burned in from childhood on,"

— Dusted Magazine

"“ I wouldn’t wanna be any different/My idealism makes me self-defensive/Don’t make me take off my gloves/I’ll show you what I’m made of, ”"

— Dusted Magazine

"“Heavy Metal,” meanwhile, is a stunner, Diaz unpacking the ways her resilience"

— Rolling Stone

7

If Time Does What It's Supposed To

2 mentions

77

03:09

8

Flirting

3 mentions

75

03:18

9

Why’d You Have To Bring Me Flowers

2 mentions

—

04:04

10

Time Difference

2 mentions

—

03:30

11

Fatal Optimist

4 mentions

61

03:05

"The album's closing title track breaks form with a full-band, effects-injected outing"

— AllMusic

"the self-admonishing admission "I hate being right.""

— AllMusic

"Not until the closing title track does Diaz infuse much energy."

— PopMatters

"On that number, she proves how she is on the level of a musician like Lucy Dacus"

— PopMatters

"On the closing title track, light begins to filter in even as Diaz keeps her emotions close."

— Rolling Stone

#1

Hope Less

62 /100

2 mentions

03:25

#2

Ambivalence

40 /100

2 mentions

04:32

#3

Feel Something

100 /100

4 mentions

03:20

#4

Good Liar

75 /100

3 mentions

03:44

#5

Lone Wolf

17 /100

2 mentions

03:10

#6

Heavy Metal

90 /100

3 mentions

03:55

#7

If Time Does What It's Supposed To

77 /100

2 mentions

03:09

#8

Flirting

75 /100

3 mentions

03:18

#9

Why’d You Have To Bring Me Flowers

10 /100

2 mentions

04:04

#10

Time Difference

10 /100

2 mentions

03:30

#11

Fatal Optimist

61 /100

4 mentions

03:05

Excellent (70+)

Good (40-69)

Fair (0-39)

No rating

Get the next albums worth your time.

Critic-backed picks in one clean digest. No clutter.

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 4 critics who reviewed this album

AllMusic

Unknown

Oct 10, 2025

80

Critic's Take

The best songs on Fatal Optimist highlight Madi Diaz's intimate songwriting and quiet arrangements; standout tracks include "Feel Something" and "Flirting," which showcase her emotional detail and restrained production. "Feel Something" is notable for its uptempo floor tom and vivid memory lyrics, while "Flirting" is a mournful piano piece that centers her fragile vocal delivery. The title track "Fatal Optimist" closes the album with a fuller-band payoff that frames the record's tentative hope. For listeners searching for the best tracks on Fatal Optimist, these songs best capture Diaz's balance of pain, reflection, and small consolations.

Key Points

"Feel Something" is the album's best song for its uptempo pulse and vivid, affecting memory lyrics.
Fatal Optimist's strengths are intimate, minimal arrangements and emotionally direct songwriting that balance melancholy and tentative hope.

Themes

introspection heartbreak recovery minimal production

Read full review

PopMatters

Patrick Gill

Oct 13, 2025

70

Critic's Take

The best songs on Fatal Optimist are spotlighted for their raw confessional power, notably "Feel Something" and "Heavy Metal," which showcase Diaz’s candid lyricism and emotional range. Overall, Fatal Optimist’s best tracks are those that lay bare heartbreak with striking, lingering observations, making them the standout moments on the album. Fans searching for the best songs on Fatal Optimist will find "Feel Something" and "Heavy Metal" among the most affecting cuts.

Key Points

“Feel Something” is best for its raw, candid lyricism and emotional immediacy.
The album’s core strengths are plainspoken confessions, vulnerability, and lingering, subtle observations about heartbreak.

Themes

heartbreak confession grief stages vulnerability melancholy

Read full review

Rolling Stone

Maura Johnston

Oct 10, 2025

70

Critic's Take

The best songs on Fatal Optimist highlight Madi Diaz’s gift for intimate, devastating songwriting, especially "Hope Less," "Feel Something," and "Heavy Metal." Critics praise the album’s stripped-down production that thrusts lyrics forward, making tracks like "Hope Less" and "Feel Something" stand out for emotional immediacy. "Heavy Metal" is noted as a stunner for its accumulating intensity, while the title track "Fatal Optimist" rewards patience with a full-band payoff.

Key Points

“Heavy Metal” is best for its intense buildup and emotional unpacking that culminates powerfully.
The album’s core strength is its stripped-down production that foregrounds Diaz’s incisive, intimate lyricism and emotional arc.

Themes

intimacy heartbreak acceptance stripped-down production

Read full review

Dusted Magazine

dustedmagazine

Oct 7, 2025

70

Critic's Take

The best songs on Fatal Optimist highlight Madi Diaz's knack for intimate, anthem-ready writing, with "Feel Something" and "Good Liar" standing out. "Feel Something" is singled out as the album's most searing moment for its urgent strumming and raw breakup plea, while "Good Liar" offers moments of solace through pretty harmonies. Fans searching for the best tracks on Fatal Optimist will find emotional intensity and melodic clarity concentrated in these songs.

Key Points

“Feel Something” is the album's emotional centerpiece because of its urgent strumming and anguished plea.
The album's core strengths are raw, stripped production and Diaz's intimate, anthem-capable songwriting.

Themes

heartbreak intimacy personal growth resilience minimal production

Read full review