Luster by Maria Somerville
83
ChoruScore
5 reviews
Apr 25, 2025
Release Date
4AD
Label

Maria Somerville's Luster maps a haunted Connemara twilight where folk-tinged shoegaze and electronic experiment converge, and the consensus suggests it mostly succeeds. Across five professional reviews, critics praise immersive, textural songwriting and world-building that turns solitude and landscape into vivid song-places; the record earned an 83/100 consensus score from five reviews, a sign of broad critical approval for its careful, patient rewards.

Reviewers consistently single out several standout tracks as the best songs on Luster. Critics name “Garden” and “Spring” repeatedly for their combination of gossamer synths, rural imagery and surprising rhythmic heft, while “Réalt” and “Projections” are praised for opening immersive vistas and blending dream pop intimacy with uncanny electronic detail. Across reviews from The Quietus, Clash Music, Pitchfork, The Guardian and The Skinny, commentators note how Somerville braids field recordings, treated vocals and textural production to make songs that feel both ancient and immediate.

While many reviews hail Luster as an evolutionary leap in Somerville's sound - updating dreampop, shoegaze and even hyperpop touches into a coherent record - some critics point to moments of alienation in the vocal processing or occasional overreach in production choices. Still, the critical consensus emphasizes the album's strongest attribute: immersive, place-rooted vignettes that reward repeated listening. For readers searching for an authoritative Luster review or wondering what the best songs on Luster are, the critics agree that “Garden”, “Spring”, “Réalt” and “Projections” emerge as the record's most compelling moments, making the collection a worthwhile, haunting addition to Somerville's catalog.

Critics' Top Tracks

The standout songs that made critics take notice

1

Spring

3 mentions

"the eerie, clattering neo-industrial aspects that frame 'Spring'"
Clash Music
2

Garden

4 mentions

"'Garden' is anchored in place by the barbed electronic production"
Clash Music
3

Halo

3 mentions

"the symphonic 'Halo' offers heavenly perfection"
Clash Music
the eerie, clattering neo-industrial aspects that frame 'Spring'
C
Clash Music
about "Spring"
Read full review
3 mentions
87% sentiment

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

Réalt

4 mentions
88
01:52
2

Projections

3 mentions
51
03:40
3

Garden

4 mentions
100
04:03
4

Corrib

2 mentions
58
02:01
5

Halo

3 mentions
89
03:49
6

Spring

3 mentions
100
03:34
7

Stonefly

3 mentions
36
03:37
8

Flutter

3 mentions
51
01:30
9

Trip

4 mentions
15
02:46
10

Violet

5 mentions
55
03:43
11

Up

2 mentions
24
03:58
12

October Moon

3 mentions
51
03:47

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 6 critics who reviewed this album

Critic's Take

Maria Somerville's Luster luxuriates in coastal quiet while delivering its best moments as shimmering, textural songs - the opener “Réalt” plants you in dawn birdsong and sets the tone, while “Projections” and “Garden” show how Somerville turns vintage shoegaze gestures into vivid, modern landscapes. The record's finest tracks braid tradition and electronics, so when “Corrib” feels like a fragment of a pop song arriving in a dream, and “Spring” extends that into a fully formed piece, you realise those are the best songs on Luster. The voice, occasionally throaty or auto-tuned, flits between hymn and whisper, and on songs like “Stonefly” the lyricism and atmosphere make them standouts rather than mere pastiches. Overall the album does one thing and does it well, offering its best tracks as immersive, place-rooted vignettes rather than checklist exercises.

Key Points

  • The best song is the opener “Réalt” because its dawn birdsong and atmosphere set the album's tonal benchmark.
  • The album's core strength is immersive, place-rooted soundscapes that blend shoegaze textures with Irish landscape and collaborative modern touches.

Themes

Connemara landscape shoegaze and dream pop textures collaboration and tradition vs modernity

Critic's Take

Maria Somerville's Luster reads as a unified, sensually stunning record where the best tracks - “Réalt”, “Halo” and “Spring” - crystallise her vertiginous creative growth. Murray writes with a palpable awe, calling opener “Réalt” audio perfume and praising the symphonic sweep of “Halo”, while “Spring” channels neo-industrial crunch into a Massive Attack worthy beat. This is an album whose best songs build world after world, mixing bucolic imagery with uncanny electronics to dramatic, haunting effect.

Key Points

  • The best song(s) like 'Réalt' combine fragrant, formless opening textures with precise emotional focus to arrest the listener.
  • The album's core strengths are world-building, mixing bucolic rural imagery with uncanny electronic production and dreamlike atmospheres.

Themes

rural landscapes uncanny world-building electronic production dreamlike atmospheres

Critic's Take

Maria Somerville's Luster makes its strongest impression in moments like “Projections” and “Garden”, where dream pop's gossamer textures meet shivering, mythic intimacy. The reviewer's voice lingers over the hush of “Projections” - "Projections of you/In my head" - and praises the way “Garden” lets her "swim through time itself," marking those as the album's best tracks. Sparse production and subtle collaboration give these songs room to feel both ancient and immediate, which is why listeners asking for the best songs on Luster will find themselves returning to “Projections” and “Garden” again and again. Overall, the record is celebrated as an evolutionary leap, a sublime surveying of dream pop that rewards patient listening.

Key Points

  • The best song is "Garden" because it is described as "breathtaking" and lets Somerville "swim through time itself," making it emotionally expansive.
  • The album's core strengths are its mythic, landscape-infused dream pop textures and subtle collaborations that expand Somerville's sound.

Themes

dream pop Connemara and landscape time and memory isolation and return collaboration

Critic's Take

Maria Somerville's Luster finds its strongest moments in intimate, textured songs like “Trip” and “Violet”, where hushed vocals and chilly production turn small ideas into vivid panoramas. The reviewer hears a distinctive, slightly alienating but sexy sound - harps that twinkle like broken glass and baggy breakbeats that reverberate through a bedroom wall, making tracks such as “Trip” linger as the best songs on Luster. These are the best tracks on Luster because they balance evocative lyrics with immersive, experimental details, transforming solitude into a kind of exhilarating, beautiful chaos.

Key Points

  • The best song is “Trip” because its curious, circular lyric and hushed delivery crystallize the album's evocative strengths.
  • The album's core strength is its textured, intimate production that blends folk, shoegaze and experimental elements into evocative solitude.

Themes

solitude textural production folk-tinged shoegaze evocative field recordings blend of pop and experimental elements

Critic's Take

Maria Somerville's Luster feels made for that liminal hour just before sunrise, and its best songs prove it: “Garden”, “Spring” and “Violet” map a soundworld where gossamer synths and slowcore rhythms coexist. Inglis revels in the album's canny updates to dreampop and shoegaze, noting how “Spring” turns breakbeats and autotune into something strangely majestic. The review highlights “Garden” and “Violet” as listen-to moments while praising the abstract interlude “Flutter” for its processed-violin surge. Overall, the record's mix of homage and fresh color makes the best tracks on Luster feel both familiar and newly luminous.

Key Points

  • Spring is the best song for its inventive fusion of breakbeats, autotune and slowcore, called the album's apotheosis.
  • The album's core strengths are its textured dreampop/shoegaze ambience and inventive updates that make homage feel fresh.

Themes

dreampop shoegaze ambient hyperpop elements experimentation