Maroon 5 Love Is Like
Maroon 5's Love Is Like lands as a nostalgic, uneven entry that nods at the band's rock influences but often falls short of genuine momentum. Across professional reviews, critics note a mix of tidy production and lyrical shallowness, with moments of real spark kept to a minimum; the record earned a 50/100 consensus score from 1 professional review.
Critics consistently point to two standout tracks as evidence the band can still write hooks that bite: “Yes I Did” and “My Love”. Reviewers praised “Yes I Did” for its shimmery hook, falsetto and a notable guitar solo, while “My Love” drew attention for slick riffs and a cool melody. Other songs such as “Jealousy Problems”, “Middle Ground” and “All Night” register as competent but less inspired, reinforcing a recurring theme of instrumentation and production outpacing lyrical depth.
While some moments suggest a welcome return to rock-leaning textures, the overall critical consensus frames Love Is Like as a limp return that trades in nostalgia more than reinvention. For readers searching for an answer to whether Love Is Like is worth a listen, the short verdict from reviewers is guarded: pick the highlights “Yes I Did” and “My Love” for the record's best rewards, while the remainder will likely satisfy devoted fans more than convert new ones.
Critics' Top Tracks
The standout songs that made critics take notice
Yes I Did
1 mention
""Yes I Did" might easily run away with being the best song on the album"— Sputnikmusic
My Love
1 mention
"There are some nice moments here, like "My Love", which features slick riffs"— Sputnikmusic
Middle Ground
1 mention
""Middle Ground," which marked the first serious return of guitars"— Sputnikmusic
"Yes I Did" might easily run away with being the best song on the album
Track Ratings
How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.
Hideaway
Love Is Like (feat. Lil Wayne)
All Night
Yes I Did
Priceless (feat. LISA)
I Like It (feat. Sexyy Red)
Burn Burn Burn
Jealousy Problems
My Love
California
What Critics Are Saying
Deep insights from 5 critics who reviewed this album
Critic's Take
Maroon 5's Love Is Like trades in nostalgia while rarely delivering real thrills, yet a few songs poke through the fog. The reviewer singles out “Yes I Did” as possibly the album's best, praising its shimmery hook, falsetto and a rad guitar solo, and names “My Love” as another nice moment because of its slick riffs and cool melody. For listeners asking what the best songs on Love Is Like are, the short answer in this voice is “Yes I Did” and “My Love” - they show the band leaning into rock in the only ways that work. The rest of the record is competent but painfully average, a limp return that rarely convinces.
Key Points
-
The best song is "Yes I Did" because it reunites falsetto, a shimmery hook, and a genuine guitar solo.
-
The album's core strength is its occasional successful return to guitar-forward rock moments amid otherwise competent but uninspired pop.