PinkPantheress Fancy That
Released May 9, 2025 Warner Records
Consensus forming 3 professional reviews Updated Oct 1, 2026
Mostly positive consensus
Consensus is still forming across 3 professional reviews. PinkPantheress's Fancy That condenses a whirlwind of 2000s revival and millennial-dance nostalgia into a playful, bite-sized statement that divides critics.
How ChoruScore worksCritics' Top Tracks
The songs critics returned to most
Tonight
1 critic mention
“She samples Panic!AtTheDisco’s Do You Know What I’m Seeing? in Tonight” — The Line of Best Fit
Stars
1 critic mention
“we can decipher the Starz In Their Eyes chorus (by Just Jack) meshed with Basement Jaxx’s Oh My Gosh in Stars” — The Line of Best Fit
Noises
1 critic mention
“the paranoia of being home alone in Noises ( "But my parents said they would be returning soon" )” — The Line of Best Fit
Full critic consensus
PinkPantheress's Fancy That condenses a whirlwind of 2000s revival and millennial-dance nostalgia into a playful, bite-sized statement that divides critics. Across three professional reviews the record earned a 66.67/100 consensus score, with praise for its referential production and criticism for its brevity and occasional filler. The strongest moments turn sampling into hooks: critics singled out “Tonight” and “Stars” as the collection's most vivid sketches, noting how “Tonight” leans on a Panic! At The Disco sample and “Stars” stitches early-2000s touchstones into compact, irresistible vignettes.
Reviewers consistently point to the mixtape's ephemeral pop textures and playful melancholy - short-form songs that flicker between charm and underdevelopment. The Line of Best Fit celebrates the record's gleeful, frantic energy and ranks “Tonight” and “Stars” among the best songs on Fancy That, while The Arts Desk finds the 20-minute runtime too insubstantial, arguing tracks such as “Romeo” and others feel stylish but unmoored. Critics agree that sampling and nostalgic references are central themes, but they diverge on whether those elements result in memorable hooks or merely polished background music.
Taken together the critical consensus frames Fancy That as a vivid experiment in compressed pop: rewarding for listeners drawn to wistful, referential production and quick pleasures, less so for those seeking sustained songwriting depth. Below, professional reviews unpack where the mixtape's highlights - including “Tonight”, “Stars”, “Noises” and “Nice to Know You” - succeed and where the format leaves ideas wanting.
Track Ratings
How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.
Illegal
Girl Like Me
Tonight
Stars
Intermission
Noises
Nice to Know You
Stateside
Romeo
Get the next albums worth your time.
Critic-backed picks in one clean digest. No clutter.
What Critics Are Saying
Deep insights from 3 critics who reviewed this album
Critic's Take
Here, PinkPantheress turns Fancy That into a gleeful, frantic 20-minute race where the best tracks, like “Tonight” and “Stars”, feel like deliberate, wink-filled homages. The reviewer’s voice keeps the pace breathless, noting how “Tonight” samples Panic! At The Disco and how “Stars” stitches together other early-2000s touchstones, which makes them two of the best songs on Fancy That. There is a constant, affectionate energy - short songs that refuse to slow down and that turn mundane moments into exhilarating vignettes. Ultimately, the mixtape’s playful nostalgia and knack for merging influences make these standout tracks feel both familiar and freshly irresistible.
Key Points
-
The best song(s) like "Tonight" stand out for their clever sampling and nods to her emo/pop-punk past.
-
The album’s core strength is playful nostalgia rendered through short, vividly narrated vignettes and inventive sampling.
Themes
Sp
Th
Critic's Take
PinkPantheress keeps things fleeting on Fancy That, a 20-minute mixtape that fluffs by rather than demands you listen. The reviewer finds that even tracks like “Romeo” - which tips its hat to Basement Jaxx - and the general millennial-dance nods fail to anchor the record. Described as a tentative 4/4 plod, the best songs here are memorable more for their production references than for hooks that linger. In short, searches for the best songs on Fancy That will point you to “Romeo” as notable, but the collection largely reads as stylish background music rather than lasting pop.
Key Points
-
The best song mention, “Romeo”, stands out for referencing Basement Jaxx rather than for a memorable hook.
-
The album’s core strengths are its stylish nods to millennial dance sounds and short, sleek production moments, but it often feels like forgettable background music.