Soccer Mommy Evergreen
Soccer Mommy's Evergreen opens as a quietly devastating study of grief and growth, where spare arrangements and crystalline songwriting put Sophie Allison's voice and lines at the center of the record. Across 13 professional reviews the consensus score sits at 78.81/100, and critics repeatedly point to songs like “M”, “Lost”, “Abigail” and the title track “Evergreen” as the collection's clearest, most affecting moments.
Reviewers consistently praise the album's restraint - stripped-back production, organic instrumentation and pastoral imagery that translate private mourning into accessible, hooky melodies. Critics name “M” and “Lost” most often for their emotional punch, with many noting “M”'s flute and string outro and “Lost”'s orchestral sweep as moments where grief becomes almost cinematic. At the same time “Driver”, “Changes” and “Abigail” are frequently cited as standout tracks that add muscular guitars, 80s-tinged playfulness or pure pop craft, supplying contrast to the album's quieter pieces.
While most reviews lean positive about Allison's songwriting growth and the record's intimacy, some critics register caution about occasional sentimentality and conservative production choices that trade experimentation for safety. The critical consensus suggests Evergreen is a mature, coherent step forward in Soccer Mommy's catalog: a record where mourning, memory and present awareness coexist with small consolations and resilient melodies. For readers searching for an Evergreen review or the best songs on Evergreen, start with “M”, “Lost” and “Abigail” before working through the album's more reflective center.
Critics' Top Tracks
The standout songs that made critics take notice
M
11 mentions
"The gut punches hit like a boxer’s quick-fire combinations – M examines absence and emptiness;"— The Skinny
Lost
8 mentions
"Opener Lost sets the pensive tone, her silk-soft vocals yearning for meaning and closure; ‘Lost in a way that doesn’t make sense, lost in a way that never ends’."— The Skinny
Abigail
10 mentions
"or the escapism of Abigail, dedicated to Allison's wife in Stardew Valley ."— The Skinny
The gut punches hit like a boxer’s quick-fire combinations – M examines absence and emptiness;
Track Ratings
How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.
Lost
M
Driver
Some Sunny Day
Changes
Abigail
Thinking Of You
Dreaming Of Falling
Salt In Wound
Anchor
Evergreen
What Critics Are Saying
Deep insights from 14 critics who reviewed this album
Critic's Take
In a quiet, elegiac voice Nina Corcoran frames Soccer Mommy’s Evergreen as an album where the best tracks — notably “Lost” and “M” — translate private grief into pastoral calm. Corcoran lingers on how “Lost” admits “this person’s really gone,” and notes that pared-back arrangements make those admissions land with uncanny weight. She praises the uptempo single “M” for cushioning guitars and ending in a fairytale flute, and singles out “Dreaming of Falling” for its confession of persistent darkness. The result is an Evergreen that is pristine, careful, and quietly devastating, offering some of Soccer Mommy’s clearest, best songs yet.
Key Points
-
“Lost” is best because it confronts grief head-on with sparse, affecting arrangements that make moments land.
-
The album’s core strengths are intimate lyricism and pastoral, meticulously crafted production that frames mourning as a slow, restorative process.
Themes
Critic's Take
Soccer Mommy’s Evergreen is at its best when songs like “Changes” and “M” put grief and memory front and center, pairing intimate confession with orchestral sweep. Patrick Gill’s tone is measured but admiring, noting that “Driver” and “Anchor” provide necessary jolts amid a generally gentle, nature-soaked record. The review reads like a recommendation for listeners seeking the best songs on Evergreen - namely “Changes” and “M” - because they most vividly translate personal loss into lasting melodies.
Key Points
-
The best song is "Changes" because it most vividly translates grief and fear of memory fading into a standout, emotional centerpiece.
-
The album’s core strength is its matured, organic sound that pairs intimate songwriting with orchestral arrangements and nature imagery.
Themes
Cl
Critic's Take
Soccer Mommy's Evergreen finds its strongest moments in plainly emotional songs like “Changes” and the punchier “Driver”, where Allison's knack for aching detail meets bolder instrumentation. Vicky Greer writes with a measured ache, noting how “Changes” serves as the album's emotional heart while “Driver” brings grungier alt-rock muscle to break the nostalgia. She praises “Abigail” as the catchiest track, and highlights “Anchor” as a thrilling diversion into darker pop textures. Overall the best tracks on Evergreen are those that marry Allison's raw vulnerability with memorable musical contrasts, even if the record sometimes slips into sentimentality at the expense of hooks.
Key Points
-
The best song is "Changes" because it serves as the album's emotional heart and delivers direct, affecting nostalgia.
-
The album's core strengths are its emotional vulnerability and atmospheric nostalgia, even if memorable hooks are sparse.
Themes
Critic's Take
Soccer Mommy’s Evergreen is a quietly gorgeous inventory of loss and memory, and the best songs - notably “Lost” and “Thinking Of You” - carry the album with intimate clarity. The reviewer lingers on the direct rumination of “Lost” and the shimmery mid-album summit of “Thinking Of You”, noting how strings and flute bathe those moments in a sentimental tug. There is welcome variety too, from the rocked-up cheek of “Driver” to the ’80s synth playfulness of “Abigail”, but it is the reflective pieces that define the best tracks on Evergreen.
Key Points
-
“Lost” is the best song because it is described as the album’s most direct rumination with vivid, intimate lines.
-
The album’s core strength is its elegiac focus on loss and memory, rendered in lush arrangements and reflective songwriting.
Themes
Critic's Take
Soccer Mommy’s Evergreen feels like a deliberate unspooling of grief and small consolations, with the best tracks mining sorrow for quiet resilience. The review singles out “M” as spellbinding, a centerpiece where memory and mourning meet an upbeat grace, and names “Abigail” and “Driver” as immediate highlights for their charm and muscular guitar work. Bennett’s voice is experiential and conversational, noting how stripped-back arrangements let songs breathe and how moments of sunlight keep the record from collapsing into despair. For listeners asking "best songs on Evergreen" or "best tracks on Evergreen," the review makes clear that “M”, “Abigail” and “Driver” are the ones to start with, each exemplifying the album’s balance of sorrow and sturdiness.
Key Points
-
The review identifies "M" as the best song for its spellbinding depiction of grief rendered with upbeat grace.
-
Evergreen’s core strength is its stripped-back, demo-like production that foregrounds Sophie Allison’s songwriting and emotional honesty.
Themes
Critic's Take
Soccer Mommy's Evergreen finds its clearest moments in songs like “Lost”, “Abigail” and “Thinking Of You”. The reviewer's voice stays intimate and poetic, noting how “Lost” sets a pensive tone and “Abigail” offers escapist tenderness, which makes these the best tracks on Evergreen. Throughout the album Allison turns private bruises into luminous lines, so when you search for the best songs on Evergreen start with those that marry raw feeling and subtle beauty. The album's balance of grief and peaking rays of hope is what makes its top tracks linger in the memory.
Key Points
-
The best song is 'Lost' because it sets the pensive tone with 'silk-soft vocals' and a quoted, affecting lyric.
-
The album's core strengths are candid lyricism, emotional honesty, and a balance of melancholy with subtle rays of hope.
Themes
Ke
Critic's Take
On Evergreen Sophia Allison strips everything back and lets grief steer the record, which makes the best songs—like “Evergreen” and “Driver”—land with quiet force. Emma Wilkes’ review hears the abandonment of previous experimentalism as a deliberate choice, so the best tracks on Evergreen feel pared-down, intimate and hard to shake. The album’s strongest moments come when Allison simply sits with loss, allowing melody and lyric to do the heavy lifting.
Key Points
-
The best song highlights grief through pared-back songwriting that foregrounds lyric and melody.
-
The album's core strength is its restraint, favoring intimate, stripped arrangements over experimental flourishes.
Themes
Critic's Take
John Amen hears Soccer Mommy shedding theatrics and placing songwriting and voice front and center on Evergreen, making the best songs - notably “Lost” and “M” - register as intimate pop triumphs. Amen writes in a measured, analytical tone, admiring how Allison’s melodies and alluring vocals turn angsty lines into grin-inducing hooks. He emphasizes that tracks like “Abigail” and “Dreaming of Falling” continue the album’s blend of candor and transportive popcraft. The review frames these best tracks as proof that restraint and clear production let Allison’s matured voice and songwriting shine.
Key Points
-
The best song(s), particularly “M” and “Lost”, pair buoyant, hooky melodies with angsty lyrics, making them standouts.
-
The album’s core strengths are Allison’s matured vocals, candid songwriting, and restrained production that foregrounds emotional vulnerability.
Themes
In
Critic's Take
In her fourth record Sophie Allison delivers a quietly powerful set on Evergreen, where the best songs - notably “Lost” and “M” - distill grief into aching melody and clarity. The reviewer’s eye lingers on “Lost”, whose grand orchestral arrangement and haunting vocal make it an immediate centerpiece, and on “M”, a minimalist heart-rending piano piece that foregrounds raw honesty. Elsewhere, “Thinking Of You” builds like a soundtrack cue, adding tension and release, while the title track ties the record’s themes together with a hopeful refrain. This is an album of careful emotional architecture, where songwriting growth and intimate production let the best tracks shine as the clearest statements of Allison’s craft.
Key Points
-
The best song, "Lost", is best because its orchestration and haunting vocals make the album’s themes immediate and immersive.
-
The album’s core strengths are intimate, evolved songwriting and production that balances grief with quiet hope.
Themes
Critic's Take
Soccer Mommy arrives at her most unguarded work on Evergreen, and the best tracks - like “M” and “Driver” - show why. In the reviewer's small, detailed sentences there is equal weight to heartbreak and craft, so when he calls “Driver” "probably the best rocker she’s ever recorded" that feels decisive. The quiet opener “Lost” and the mid-album trio “Changes”, “Abigail” and “Thinking Of You” are singled out for their tactile, grieving specificity. Read together the best songs on Evergreen form a coherent, affecting portrait of living in grief rather than escaping it.
Key Points
-
“Driver” is the album’s most immediate triumph, called 'probably the best rocker she’s ever recorded'.
-
The album’s core strength is its unguarded, tactile exploration of grief and memory, rendered in intimate arrangements.
Themes
Critic's Take
In her fourth album, Soccer Mommy frames memory and change with crystalline restraint on Evergreen. The title track “Evergreen” emerges as the record's emotional centre, its line "I don’t wanna be let down / By another perfect memory" emblematic of the album's refusal of over-romanticisation. Allison's string-laced arrangements make the closer feel delicate and considered, while the record as a whole leans into autumnal transitions rather than sunk reverie. For listeners asking what the best tracks on Evergreen are, start with “Evergreen” and follow the record's dream-filled yet present-minded arc.
Key Points
-
The title track is the best song because it crystallises the album's themes with a memorable lyric and rich strings.
-
The album's core strengths are its restrained handling of nostalgia, string arrangements, and an autumnal, present-focused mood.
Themes
Critic's Take
Soccer Mommy's Evergreen finds its clearest victories in intimate, aching moments - notably “Driver” and “M”, which the reviewer singles out for production and chilling payoff. The best songs on Evergreen pair Sophie Allison's uncomfortably relatable lines with arrangements that swell and sting, from the drum build-up of “Driver” to the flute and string outro of “M”. Those tracks, alongside the title “Evergreen” and the candid “Dreaming of Falling”, crystallize why these are the album's standout moments and answer who should be on any list of the best tracks on Evergreen.
Key Points
-
The best song moments are those where arrangement and lyric converge, notably the flute-and-strings coda of 'M'.
-
The album's core strengths are candid lyrics about grief paired with spacious, acoustic-forward arrangements.
Themes
Critic's Take
Luke Pearson finds Soccer Mommy's Evergreen to be a tidy, mostly successful record where the best tracks - notably “M” and “Abigail” - showcase Allison's clearest vocal work and melodic gifts. He praises the bold use of classical chamber touches like the flute outro on “M”, even as he chides moments where those elements merely mimic bed tracks. The review highlights mid-album standout “Abigail” as the closest Allison gets to joy, and notes that songs such as “Salt in Wound” sustain the album's moody, college-rock current. Overall, Pearson frames the best songs as evidence that Allison's songwriting and voice remain compelling, even when production choices make the record feel safer than adventurous.
Key Points
-
The best songwork, especially on "Abigail" and "M", is driven by Allison's clear vocal presence and memorable melodic choices.
-
Evergreen's core strengths are strong songwriting and a bright vocal mix, tempered by conservative, traditionalist production choices.