Since I Left You by The Avalanches

The Avalanches Since I Left You

87
ChoruScore
8 reviews
Established consensus
Nov 6, 2001
Release Date
Universal Music Australia Pty. Ltd.
Label
Established consensus Strong critical consensus

The Avalanches's Since I Left You arrives as a jubilant, sun-soaked kaleidoscope of samples that critics call both a party-starter and a careful exercise in studio craft. Across eight professional reviews the record earned an 86.56/100 consensus score, and reviewers consistently point to the title cut “Since I Left You

Reviews
8 reviews
Last Updated
Feb 21, 2026
Confidence
89%
Scale
0-100 critics
Primary Praise

The opener “Since I Left You” is best because it establishes the album's dazzling sample collage and irresistible groove.

Primary Criticism

Shared criticism is still limited across the current review sample.

Who It Fits

Best for listeners looking for sampling and crate-digging and collage/patchwork production, starting with Since I Left You and Frontier Psychiatrist.

Standout Tracks
Since I Left You Frontier Psychiatrist Stay Another Season

Full consensus notes

The Avalanches's Since I Left You arrives as a jubilant, sun-soaked kaleidoscope of samples that critics call both a party-starter and a careful exercise in studio craft. Across eight professional reviews the record earned an 86.56/100 consensus score, and reviewers consistently point to the title cut “Since I Left You” and the turntablist oddity “Frontier Psychiatrist” as the album's clearest standout tracks. That immediate praise answers the frequent question of whether Since I Left You is good: consensus suggests yes, a richly textured collection worth repeated plays.

Critics celebrate the album's sampling collage, its seamless montage and its knack for turning crate-digging curios into coherent songs. Reviews highlight playfulness and humor in moments like “Frontier Psychiatrist”, the summery disco-pop shimmer of “Since I Left You”, and the breezy charm of “Stay Another Season”. Several writers note the emotional undercurrent beneath the party grooves, where nostalgia, seaside pop touches and genre-blending - from disco and funk to tropicalia and hip-hop - make the record both danceable and oddly intimate. Reviewers consistently praise the flow and sequencing that keep surprises coming without wearing the listener out.

Not all criticism is absent: a few reviewers warn that dense, loop-heavy passages verge on overload, and some favor the album's quieter, glistening moments as the most revealing. Still, the critical consensus frames Since I Left You as a landmark in sample-based composition, a playful yet meticulously crafted collage whose best tracks - including “Since I Left You”, “Frontier Psychiatrist” and “Stay Another Season” - serve as ideal entry points before the record's rarer, more reflective moments unfold. Below, the collected professional reviews map how and why the record endures.

Critics' Top Tracks

The standout songs that made critics take notice

1

Since I Left You

8 mentions

"Much of the beauty of the opening title song ... lies in the way that the Avalanches turn obvious sonic mismatches into something all their own."
Pitchfork
2

Frontier Psychiatrist

7 mentions

"Frontier Psychiatrist," one of two singles already released from the album, is simply one of the funniest songs I've heard in ages."
Pitchfork
3

Stay Another Season

4 mentions

"As it segues to "Stay Another Season", while still retaining the vocals from the first track, you're sure to be hopping up and down"
Tiny Mix Tapes
Much of the beauty of the opening title song ... lies in the way that the Avalanches turn obvious sonic mismatches into something all their own.
P
Pitchfork
about "Since I Left You"
Read full review
8 mentions
90% sentiment

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

Since I Left You

8 mentions
100
04:22
2

Stay Another Season

4 mentions
100
02:19
3

Radio

2 mentions
87
04:21
4

Two Hearts In 3/4 Time

3 mentions
74
03:24
5

Avalanche Rock

1 mention
77
00:22
6

Flight Tonight

4 mentions
90
03:52
7

Close To You

3 mentions
100
03:56
8

Diners Only

1 mention
5
01:34
9

A Different Feeling

7 mentions
100
04:22
10

Electricity

3 mentions
100
03:29
11

Tonight May Have To Last Me All My Life

4 mentions
69
02:20
12

Pablo's Cruise

1 mention
69
00:52
13

Frontier Psychiatrist

7 mentions
100
04:47
14

ETOH

0 mentions
05:03
15

Summer Crane

0 mentions
04:39
16

Little Journey

2 mentions
25
01:36
17

Live At Dominoes

3 mentions
54
05:38
18

Extra Kings

2 mentions
62
03:42
19

Since I Left You - Cornelius Remix

0 mentions
05:35
20

Tonight May Have To Last Me All My Life - Edan Remix

0 mentions
03:53
21

Frontier Psychiatrist - Mario Caldato Jr's 85% Remix

0 mentions
04:04
22

Close To You - Sun Araw Remix

0 mentions
06:10
23

Since I Left You - Stereolab Remix

0 mentions
04:36
24

Flight Tonight - Canyons Travel Agent Dub

0 mentions
06:00
25

Radio - Sinkane Remix

0 mentions
08:33
26

Since I Left You - Prince Paul Remix

0 mentions
03:48
27

Electricity - Harvey's Nightclub Re-Edit

0 mentions
06:30
28

Summer Crane - Black Dice Remix

0 mentions
03:38
29

Extra Kings - Deakin Remix

0 mentions
04:42
30

Tonight May Have To Last Me All My Life - MF DOOM Remix

0 mentions
02:54
31

Tonight May Have To Last Me All My Life - Dragged By Leon Vynehall

0 mentions
05:24
32

A Different Feeling - Carl Craig's Paperclip People Remix

0 mentions
10:37
33

Thank You Caroline - Original Avalanches Demo Tape

0 mentions
04:11
Free email

The short list, not the firehose.

New albums and standout tracks, filtered through real critic reviews.

Critic-vetted Fast read Unsubscribe anytime

No spam. Just the albums and tracks worth your time.

Chorus email is intentionally low-volume.

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 17 critics who reviewed this album

Critic's Take

The Avalanches's Since I Left You is presented here as maybe the best sample record ever made, and the reviewer locks onto the title track and “Stay Another Season” as emblematic high points. The piece praises the album-opening title track as a pastiche of weightless shimmer, noting a lazy day's disco groove, and singles out “Stay Another Season” for its blissed-out breeze and Madonna guitar lift. The review likewise highlights the seaside charm of “Two Hearts In 3/4 Time” and the turntablist flash of “Frontier Psychiatrist” to explain why these are the best tracks on Since I Left You, all while stressing the album's obsessive, giddy collage-making. Overall the tone is celebratory and exacting, emphasizing craft and joyous recombination more than conventional dancefloor utility.

Key Points

  • The title track's shimmering pastiche and disco groove make it the album's defining high point.
  • The album's core strength is its obsessive, giddy collage-making that recombines diverse samples into a joyful whole.

Themes

sampling and crate-digging collage/patchwork production nostalgia and seaside pop genre-blending (dance, hip-hop, tropicalia)

Critic's Take

The Avalanches make Since I Left You feel like an unapologetic party-starter, and the best songs - “Since I Left You” and “Stay Another Season” - do exactly that, hauling you off the couch. The reviewer revels in the dizzying sample collage and the way moments keep revealing themselves, calling the album a brilliant collage that never wears thin. Praise is effusive and vivid, insisting that the record's grooves and surprises keep giving long after first listen. If you search for the best tracks on Since I Left You, start with those opener moments that set the tone and then let the rest of the album keep you moving.

Key Points

  • The opener “Since I Left You” is best because it establishes the album's dazzling sample collage and irresistible groove.
  • The album's core strength is its dense, tasteful use of hundreds of samples to create endlessly discoverable, danceable songs.

Themes

sampling collage danceable grooves playfulness emotional undercurrent

Critic's Take

The Avalanches craft a jubilant, meticulously funny collage on Since I Left You, and the best songs - notably “Frontier Psychiatrist” and “A Different Feeling” - show precisely why. LeMay revels in how mismatched sounds become coherent, praising the way “Radio” centers around a mantra-like vocal and a thick disco bassline while “A Different Feeling” wedges 1974 horn blasts against 1988 video-game bleeps. The writing highlights the album's humor and surprise, with “Frontier Psychiatrist” called out as one of the funniest songs in ages. Ultimately the record is lauded as both party-friendly and emotionally resonant, its samples turned into something alive and uniquely cohesive.

Key Points

  • The best song, "Frontier Psychiatrist," is the standout for its inventive, hilarious use of many spoken-word samples and memorable scratches.
  • The album's core strength is transforming hundreds of disparate samples into a seamless, emotionally rich party record.

Themes

sampling as composition humor and playfulness seamless montage/flow nostalgia and collage

Critic's Take

In a sunburnt, ecstatic way Christian Ward repeatedly crowns The Avalanches and their Since I Left You as a kaleidoscopic masterpiece, singling out “Since I Left You” and “A Different Feeling” as moments of sublime filtered disco-pop. He leavens giddy praise with sly comparisons to Daft Punk, arguing the title track feels at home in a '50s musical while “A Different Feeling” matches the French duo's best work. The review keeps a wry, slightly nerdy tone - admiring the record's joyful sampling and the triumphant final 15 minutes of disco-soul drama. Read as a guide to the best songs on Since I Left You, the piece steers you toward those standout tracks precisely because they encapsulate the album's irreverent, bittersweet pop alchemy.

Key Points

  • The title track is best because it encapsulates the album's joyous, musical-theatre sheen and sampling craft.
  • The album's core strengths are ecstatic, inventive sampling and a sun-kissed disco-pop flow that mashes genres into cohesive drama.

Themes

sampling collage nostalgia disco-pop travel genre-mashing

Critic's Take

In a voice equal parts giddy and analytical, The Avalanches's Since I Left You is celebrated for its joyous, sample-warped highs, with the title track and “Frontier Psychiatrist” singled out as the album's best songs. The review delights in how “Since I Left You” unfurls ‘‘light-hearted flutes and tropical guitars’’ into an infectiously catchy pastiche, while “Frontier Psychiatrist” turns found dialogue into kooky, fresh songwriting. The critic praises the record's nonstop inventiveness and party-ready moments like “Close to You” and “Electricity”, arguing these best tracks make the album a genuinely entertaining, dancefloor-minded masterpiece.

Key Points

  • The title track is best for its irresistible, cohesive charm and catchy vocal loop.
  • The album's core strengths are inventive sample collage, playful production, and consistent dancefloor-friendly sequencing.

Themes

sample-based collage dancefloor eclecticism nostalgia playfulness studio craftsmanship vs spontaneity

Al

Almost Cool

Unknown
Unknown date
88

Critic's Take

I went into Since I Left You already primed by The Avalanches' goofy Gimix, and the album mostly delivers that same joyous, sample-stuffed ride. The coup here is clearly “Frontier Psychiatrist”, a single so funky and funny it lodges in your head and proves why it ranks among the best songs on Since I Left You. Other standout moments like “Etoh” and “Live At Dominoes” show the group can calm down for artful texture then crank back up for irresistible party momentum. If you want the best tracks on Since I Left You, start with “Frontier Psychiatrist”, then let “Etoh” and “Live At Dominoes” guide you through the album's genre-hopping fun.

Key Points

  • The best song is "Frontier Psychiatrist" because its funky beat and kooky samples make it unforgettable.
  • The album's core strengths are its exuberant sample collage, genre-hopping variety, and party-ready energy.

Themes

sampling collage genre-blending playful humor danceability

Critic's Take

The Avalanches make a dizzy, sample-stuffed hour on Since I Left You, where the best tracks — “Two Hearts in 3/4 Time” and “Diners Only” — showcase the band’s loop-happy excess and near-manic creativity. The assessment balances affection for the album’s imagination with a caution about its potential to overwhelm.

Key Points

  • The best song(s) balance manic sample-collage with moments where samples are allowed to glisten.
  • The album's core strength is its dense, imaginative sampling that alternates between dizzying excess and surprising tenderness.

Themes

sampling collage retro pop culture splices dense production vs. quieter moments dance vs. outsider listening
60

Critic's Take

The Avalanches make Since I Left You sound like a joyous ode to sampling, where tracks such as “Since I Left You” and “Frontier Psychiatrist” skitter between forgotten disco and proto-hip-hop loops with dazzling ease. The reviewer praises the album's dense, complex collages yet notes an easy-going, sexy, summery air that keeps the record danceable rather than merely clever. Overall the tone is admiring and warm, celebrating how these grooves both contemplate and move the body.

Key Points

  • The title track best encapsulates the album's joyous sampling and summery, danceable spirit.
  • The album's core strengths are its dense, eclectic samples and an easy-going air that keeps complex assemblage feel lively and sexy.

Themes

sampling danceable grooves disco and funk influences summery atmosphere complex assemblage