The Hard Quartet by The Hard Quartet

The Hard Quartet The Hard Quartet

72
ChoruScore
10 reviews
Oct 4, 2024
Release Date
Matador
Label

The Hard Quartet's The Hard Quartet opens like a well-stocked jukebox run through four seasoned, idiosyncratic players, and critics largely agree the record rewards attentive listening. Across ten professional reviews the album earned a 72.1/100 consensus score, with reviewers repeatedly pointing to the group's easy chemistry, guitar craftsmanship and a winning mix of shaggy lo-fi charm and classic-rock warmth. Critics consistently flagged “Rio's Song”, “Chrome Mess”, “Our Hometown Boy” and “Heel Highway” as standout tracks, while “Action For Military Boys” drew attention for its stylistic shifts and lyrical bite.

Reviewers emphasize collaborative dynamics as the album's creative engine - the record thrives when improvisation and vocal interplay steer grooves toward harmonized payoffs. Praise centers on Byrdsian jangle, crunchy garage-Americana textures and moments of Pavement-like slacker wit, with several critics celebrating Jim White and guest players for elevating the arrangements. At the same time, professional reviews note unevenness: the sprawling runtime and some loose, dissonant detours make parts feel indulgent, and a few tracks sag in the second half. That split yields a mixed-but-favorable portrait rather than unanimous acclaim.

Taken together, the critical consensus suggests The Hard Quartet is worth hearing for fans of collaborative supergroup dynamics, guitar-driven indie rock and off-the-cuff experiments; its best songs - “Rio's Song”, “Chrome Mess”, “Our Hometown Boy” and “Heel Highway” - provide the clearest entry points. Below, detailed reviews unpack when the quartet's camaraderie produces essential, must-hear moments and when the record's looseness blunts impact.

Critics' Top Tracks

The standout songs that made critics take notice

1

Our Hometown Boy

6 mentions

"mid-’60s Byrdsian gem Our Hometown Boy"
Mojo
2

Chrome Mess

7 mentions

"preening avant-glam (steamrollering opener Chrome Mess)"
The Guardian
3

Rio's Song

8 mentions

"They single out "Rio's Song""
Dusted Magazine
mid-’60s Byrdsian gem Our Hometown Boy
M
Mojo
about "Our Hometown Boy"
Read full review
6 mentions
85% sentiment

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

Chrome Mess

7 mentions
100
02:41
2

Earth Hater

7 mentions
87
02:15
3

Rio's Song

8 mentions
100
02:17
4

Our Hometown Boy

6 mentions
100
02:53
5

Renegade

9 mentions
83
02:13
6

Heel Highway

8 mentions
100
04:26
7

Killed By Death

9 mentions
100
02:36
8

Hey

6 mentions
86
04:29
9

It Suits You

5 mentions
40
02:35
10

Six Deaf Rats

6 mentions
74
06:40
11

Action For Military Boys

9 mentions
100
04:50
12

Jacked Existence

6 mentions
76
02:42
13

North of the Border

5 mentions
64
03:55
14

Thug Dynasty

7 mentions
68
02:53
15

Gripping the Riptide

5 mentions
25
04:33

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 11 critics who reviewed this album

Critic's Take

In a searching, conversational voice the reviewer crowns The Hard Quartet as a record where attentive interplay yields its best moments. They single out “Rio's Song” and “Renegade” as tracks that crystallize the album's strengths, praising their interplay and problem-solving approach to composition. The narrative stresses listening to others as the creative motor, framing those best tracks as rewards for collective focus. That makes clear which are the best songs on The Hard Quartet for listeners seeking collaborative, exploratory post-punk.

Key Points

  • The best song is praised for its attentive interplay and how it crystallizes the album's collaborative strengths.
  • The album's core strength is collective listening and experimental problem-solving in composition.

Themes

collaboration experimentation listening and response

Critic's Take

In a warm, conversational voice the review celebrates The Hard Quartet as classic-rock comfort food; the best tracks - notably “Earth Hater” and “Our Hometown Boy” - distill its blend of goofball impulses and gorgeous melodies. The critic praises the group chemistry and points to “Rio's Song” and “Heel Highway” as moments where individual personalities shine, while arguing the album’s pleasures come from communal interplay. It reads as an affectionate recommendation for listeners searching for the best songs on The Hard Quartet, emphasizing earworm choruses, sly lyrics, and a relaxed, veteran confidence.

Key Points

  • “Our Hometown Boy” is best for its pure power-pop rush, chiming guitars, and a soaring solo coda.
  • The album’s core strength is the quartet’s communal chemistry, blending humor, veteran musicianship, and varied classic-rock styles.

Themes

collaboration classic rock revival humor vs. profundity vocal interplay eclectic styles

Critic's Take

On The Hard Quartet The Hard Quartet deliver a charmed, collaborative garage-Americana set where the best songs - notably “Earth Hater”, “Heel Highway” and “Rio” - stand out. Joshua Mills revels in the crunchy, chewy textures and blissful, woozy tunes, praising Jim White’s drumming and the warm guitars. He singles out Sweeney-led cuts as particularly satisfying, calling “Rio” a gorgeous slice of retro rock and “Killed By Death” a weary, rootsy highlight. The record’s shagginess is part of its charm, and Mills insists the songs are as tight as they need to be rather than overworked.

Key Points

  • The best songwork combines crunchy garage textures with warm harmonies and standout drumming, especially on "Rio" and "Earth Hater".
  • The album’s strengths are its collaborative charm, relaxed slacker persona, and tasteful musicianship that values looseness over overproduction.

Themes

collaboration garage rock Americana nostalgia slacker persona

Critic's Take

The Hard Quartet sounds like four old hands delighting in each other, and the best songs on The Hard Quartet — notably “Heel Highway” and “Killed By Death” — show that glee as songwriting, not jammy indulgence. Simpson relishes the pop sensibility amid the scuzzy guitars, praising “Heel Highway” for its paean to marijuana and “Killed By Death” for its “gorgeously entwined guitars” and meditations on mortality. He also flags “Action For Military Boys” as a shapeshifting highlight that evokes T Rex and the Libertines while speaking up for young soldiers. Overall the record is less cosy nostalgia and more veterans bringing the best out of each other, with a few misfires but plenty of wonder in the guitar work.

Key Points

  • Heel Highway is best for its lovely, trippy lyric and pop sensibility that elevates stoner imagery into songwriting.
  • The album’s core strength is veteran collaboration yielding wondrous guitar playing and consistently surprising tunes.

Themes

collaboration stoner/cosmic imagery guitar-driven rock nostalgic punk/glam references life and mortality
80

Critic's Take

In his slippery, appreciative manner Andrew Perry crowns The Hard Quartet as a delectable-sounding record that revels in guitar magic. He singles out “Chrome Mess” and “Six Deaf Rats” and the mid-ʼ60s Byrdsian “Our Hometown Boy” as the best songs on The Hard Quartet, noting their exuberant immediacy and improvisatory flourish. Perry writes with a fan’s close-reading eye - Pavement echoes surface but the performances and guests (Matt Sweeney, Emmett Kelly) make these tracks feel newly alive. The result answers searches for the best tracks on The Hard Quartet with specific praise for those standout moments and their muscular, in-the-moment execution.

Key Points

  • The best song is a tie among guitar-forward tracks like "Chrome Mess" and "Six Deaf Rats" for their immediacy and improvisational reach.
  • The album’s core strengths are extravagant musicianship, guitar craftsmanship, and successful blending of Pavement echoes with standout guest performances.

Themes

guitar craftsmanship Pavement comparisons improv and musicianship 60s Byrds influence

Critic's Take

Susan Hansen hears real chemistry on The Hard Quartet debut The Hard Quartet, singling out the feverish opener “Chrome Mess” and the wistful “Our Hometown Boy” as high points. Her prose is admiring and exact - she praises the band’s melding of rock, blues and slacker harmony and highlights moments like “Killed By Death” and “Action For Military Boys” that balance simplicity with depth. This is not a virtuoso flex for its own sake, she insists, but a measured, often glorious record where the best tracks reveal themselves through patience and listenability.

Key Points

  • The best song is the feverish opener “Chrome Mess” because it builds and explodes with compelling melodic distortion.
  • The album's core strengths are collaborative chemistry, varied sonics, and thoughtfully applied musicianship.

Themes

collaboration rock blends musicianship war and violence harmony

Critic's Take

From the off, The Hard Quartet reads like a deliberately wayward experiment, and Joe Goggins revels in the moments that land - notably “Renegade” for its thrashing punk bite and “Action For Military Boys” for its stylistic slalom. He highlights the record's improvised feel, praising atmospheric pieces like “Killed by Death” and “Jacked Existence” as countrified interludes that temper the chaos. The review frames the best tracks on The Hard Quartet as those where members grab the floor and drive the song, which is why “Renegade” and “Action For Military Boys” stand out most clearly. Goggins admits not everything works, but insists far more does than you’d expect given the gleeful throwing of ideas at the wall.

Key Points

  • The best song is “Renegade” because its thrashing punk energy crystallizes the band's most thrilling impulses.
  • The album's core strength is its improvisational, genre-hopping approach that lets members take the lead and produce unexpectedly successful moments.

Themes

supergroup dynamics improvisation genre-hopping collaboration vs. individuality

Critic's Take

The Hard Quartet sounds like a Matador Wilburys-style hangout, and the best songs on The Hard Quartet are the rollicking “Chrome Mess” and the woozy, patient “Jacked Existence”. Rob Sheffield writes with that shaggy, conversational delight that celebrates the album's Seventies head-slammers and loose second-half jams, praising Malkmus' nifty guitar on “Heel Highway” and the acoustic dirge vibe of “Jacked Existence”. The review frames these tracks as standout moments where the group's easy chemistry and cracked hippie-folk experiments pay off, making queries for "best tracks on The Hard Quartet" and "best songs on The Hard Quartet" point straight to those songs.

Key Points

  • “Jacked Existence” is best for its powerful, dank acoustic dirge mood and clear Traditional Techniques connection.
  • The album's core strengths are its supergroup chemistry, Seventies rock revivalism, loose second-half jams, and Malkmus' unmistakable guitar and vocal presence.

Themes

supergroup camaraderie seventies rock revival shaggy lo-fi charm acoustic dirge/folk influences

Critic's Take

The Hard Quartet’s debut The Hard Quartet mostly shines in its opening run, with the best songs delivered early - most notably “Rio’s Song”, which is a beautiful, guitar-driven meditation on mortality, and the crunchy, shifting rocker “Chrome Mess”. The first single “Earth Hater” and the Byrds-tinged “Our Hometown Boy” also stake claims as standout tracks, mixing Malkmus-style warble with singable hooks. The record’s second half sags at times, with overextended experiments like “Six Deaf Rats” and “Action For Military Boys” losing momentum, yet the album’s spirited, slightly peculiar indie rock remains a rewarding listen.

Key Points

  • The best song is "Rio’s Song" because it is described as the album's best tune, beautiful, guitar-driven, and emotionally soaring.
  • The album’s core strengths are spirited, slightly peculiar indie rock, strong early songwriting, and effective mix of lo-fi punk and folk-tinged melodies.

Themes

indie rock nostalgia lo-fi/punk energy Americana influences mortality questioning

Critic's Take

In a beer-and-banter voice the review finds the best songs on The Hard Quartet when the foursome gels - notably “Rio’s Song” and “Action For Military Boys” - where melodic warmth and searing, messy blues meet. Tom Taylor’s prose delights in the record’s riff-heavy volley and idiosyncratic textures, praising the album when harmonies and anthemic highs land. He warns that the frequent dissonance and sprawling 15-track runtime sometimes dilute impact, yet the highlights promise a fresh, analogue rock reward.

Key Points

  • The best songwork appears when the band gels harmoniously, especially on tracks like "Our Hometown Boy".
  • The album’s core strengths are textured production and a willingness to marry riff-heavy rock with lo-fi experimentalism.

Themes

lo-fi vs anthemic production dissonance vs harmony collaborative supergroup dynamics