Rome [Live] by The National

The National Rome [Live]

79
ChoruScore
5 reviews
Dec 13, 2024
Release Date
4AD
Label

The National's Rome [Live] reframes well-worn songs as arena-sized catharsis, offering a career-spanning document that often betters the studio originals. Across five professional reviews the consensus finds the band leaning into rocked-up arrangements, audience interaction, and heightened dynamics to create memorable, anthemic performances that highlight both longevity and live mastery.

Critics consistently praise live standouts such as “Tropic Morning News - Live in Rome”, “Fake Empire - Live in Rome”, “Terrible Love - Live in Rome” and “Bloodbuzz Ohio” as the best songs on Rome [Live], noting how crowd singalongs, horn flourishes and Bryan Devendorf's propulsive drumming amplify emotional urgency. The record earned a 79.2/100 consensus score across five professional reviews, with reviewers commending the catalogue-spanning set, strong musicianship, and Berninger's vocal foregrounding. Several critics point to nostalgia and audience engagement as central strengths, while others highlight production and mix choices that push older material into a bigger, rougher register.

There is nuance in the critical reception. Some reviewers celebrate the return to Alligator-era grit and the energized takes on “Don’t Swallow the Cap” and “Runaway”, while others note puzzling omissions and occasional mix emphasis that flatten quieter moments. Overall the professional reviews suggest Rome [Live] succeeds as both a victory lap and an emphatic live statement, making a strong case for those wondering is Rome [Live] good and which are the best songs on the record.

For readers seeking an informed verdict, the consensus points to a must-hear live snapshot of The National's emotive power and stage rapport, with clearly identifiable highlights to guide further listening.

Critics' Top Tracks

The standout songs that made critics take notice

1

Fake Empire - Live in Rome

1 mention

"That includes “Fake Empire”, which takes on grand proportions live."
PopMatters
2

Terrible Love - Live in Rome

1 mention

"For years, “Terrible Love” has been their bring-down-the-house finale"
PopMatters
3

Terrible Love

1 mention

""It takes an ocean not to break" declares Berninger on "Terrible Love""
Paste Magazine
That includes “Fake Empire”, which takes on grand proportions live.
P
PopMatters
about "Fake Empire - Live in Rome"
Read full review
1 mention
95% sentiment

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

Runaway - Live in Rome

2 mentions
48
05:48
2

Eucalyptus - Live in Rome

1 mention
44
04:17
3

Tropic Morning News - Live in Rome

2 mentions
98
05:28
4

New Order T-Shirt - Live in Rome

1 mention
5
04:47
5

Don't Swallow the Cap - Live in Rome

0 mentions
04:34
6

Bloodbuzz Ohio - Live in Rome

2 mentions
48
05:03
7

The System Only Dreams in Total Darkness - Live in Rome

2 mentions
48
04:08
8

I Need My Girl - Live in Rome

1 mention
69
04:07
9

Lemonworld - Live in Rome

1 mention
56
03:36
10

The Geese of Beverly Road - Live in Rome

1 mention
56
04:37
11

Lit Up - Live in Rome

1 mention
56
03:13
12

Alien - Live in Rome

1 mention
75
04:38
13

Humiliation - Live in Rome

1 mention
31
04:55
14

Murder Me Rachael - Live in Rome

1 mention
31
03:55
15

England - Live in Rome

1 mention
60
05:18
16

Graceless - Live in Rome

2 mentions
41
04:43
17

Fake Empire - Live in Rome

1 mention
100
03:27
18

Smoke Detector - Live in Rome

1 mention
38
06:50
19

Mr November - Live in Rome

1 mention
50
04:17
20

Terrible Love - Live in Rome

1 mention
94
05:15
21

Vanderlyle Crybaby Geeks - Live in Rome

1 mention
63
04:58

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 5 critics who reviewed this album

Critic's Take

I have watched The National grow from scruffy indie hopefuls to a consummate live act, and Rome captures that transformation in full. The review keeps returning to the live standouts - “Fake Empire”, “Terrible Love”, and “Tropic Morning News” - each becoming larger than their studio versions, with Berninger turning moments into communal catharsis. The record is most rewarding for those who have seen them in concert, as the instrumentation and audience interplay give songs like “I Need My Girl” and “Bloodbuzz Ohio” renewed life. Despite some puzzling omissions from the setlist, Rome is a strikingly good document of the band at the height of their powers.

Key Points

  • “Fake Empire” is best because it expands into grand, communal proportions live, becoming a centerpiece of the set.
  • The album’s core strengths are muscular musicianship, Berninger’s theatrical crowd work, and moments where studio songs gain fresh life onstage.

Themes

live performance energy audience engagement band musicianship setlist selection and omissions melancholy / sadness

Critic's Take

The National's Rome [Live] makes a compelling case for the best songs on the record being live standouts like “Don’t Swallow the Cap” and “Terrible Love”. Tom Williams writes with the measured, observant voice that praises Berninger's quivering baritone and the band's urgency, noting that the live “Don’t Swallow The Cap” is more commanding and vulnerable than its studio counterpart. He highlights how tracks such as “Eucalyptus” and “Fake Empire” find new power onstage, with crowd singalongs and triumphant horn sections amplifying their impact. The narrative consistently returns to longevity and audience rapport as reasons these are the best tracks on Rome and why the live versions outshine the originals.

Key Points

  • Live vocal delivery and emotional vulnerability make "Don’t Swallow The Cap" the set's standout.
  • The album’s core strengths are emotional urgency, audience connection, and the band’s sustained live mastery.

Themes

emotional urgency live mastery longevity audience connection nostalgia

Critic's Take

The National's Rome [Live] foregrounds the best tracks as live epics, with “Runaway” and “Bloodbuzz Ohio” standing out for their atmosphere and power. The reviewer's voice savours the slow, atmospheric opening of “Runaway” and the mammoth, propulsive interpretation of “Don’t Swallow The Cap”, while noting the soaring dynamism of “Eucalyptus”. It praises how the set balances the catalogue across eras and highlights how standout songs translate into euphoric live moments. The result answers fans asking for the best songs on Rome [Live] with clear favorites that shine in concert.

Key Points

  • “Runaway” is best as the perfect, atmospheric show starter that puts Matt Berninger's vocals front and center.
  • The album's core strength is translating The National’s studio songs into euphoric, anthemic live performances across eras.

Themes

live energy catalogue spanning set vocals on display anthemic performances

Critic's Take

The National's Rome [Live] highlights how the band turns intimacy into arena-sized catharsis, with the raw, rocked-up versions of “Tropic Morning News” and “Alien” standing out. The reviewer's wry, slightly exasperated voice notes that Rome favors early, heavier tracks over piano ballads, so the best songs on Rome [Live] are those that benefit from turned-up guitars and Bryan Devendorf's dominant drums. This record reads as both a victory lap and a concession, and when the band leans into Alligator-era grit the live arrangements truly reward listeners seeking the best tracks on Rome [Live].

Key Points

  • The best song is a Heavy-era highlight like "Tropic Morning News" because guitars and drums push it into true rock catharsis.
  • Album strengths are maximal live arrangements and triumphant climaxes that reveal the band as a fuller rock outfit.

Themes

live amplification rocking up older material nostalgia vs scale production/mix emphasis

Critic's Take

The National always trade in patient builds and cathartic peaks, and Rome [Live] captures that tradecraft with uncanny clarity. The review leans on early highlights like “Runaway” and the stand-out “Eucalyptus” to show how a dialed-in crowd and Berninger’s intense line readings push songs into memorable moments. Mid-show classics such as “Lit Up” and the hush-and-swell of “Alien” illustrate why the best tracks on Rome feel both raucous and deeply grown-up. In short, the best songs on Rome [Live] are the ones that let audience and band collide, producing the record’s most satisfying peaks.

Key Points

  • “Eucalyptus” is best because it crystallizes Berninger’s intensity and the band’s on-stage momentum.
  • The album’s core strengths are live energy, tight audience interplay, and a career-spanning song selection.

Themes

live energy audience interaction career retrospective emotive performance