Twin Cinema by The New Pornographers
83
ChoruScore Critic consensus / 100

Released Aug 22, 2005 Matador

Established consensus 18 professional reviews Updated Aug 25, 2026

Broadly positive consensus

The New Pornographers's Twin Cinema finds the supergroup sharpening its power-pop craft into some of their most irresistible moments yet, and critics largely agree that the record delivers memorable hooks, lush vocal harmonies, and standout performances.

How ChoruScore works

Critics' Top Tracks

The songs critics returned to most

01

Use It

5 critic mentions

“two sips from the cup of human kindness....and I’m shit-faced, just laid to waste” — Drowned In Sound
02

Streets of Fire

1 critic mention

“the glistening ' Streets of Fire ' (complete with Graham Greene’s ‘whiskey priest’)” — Drowned In Sound
03

The Bleeding Heart Show

3 critic mentions

“nor will there be a bridge as glorious as the simple series of “oohs” on which Case and Newman harmonize in “The Bleeding Heart Show.” — Slant Magazine
Full critic consensus

The New Pornographers's Twin Cinema finds the supergroup sharpening its power-pop craft into some of their most irresistible moments yet, and critics largely agree that the record delivers memorable hooks, lush vocal harmonies, and standout performances. Across 18 professional reviews the album earned an 83.11/100 consensus score, a signal that reviewers consistently admired the band's ability to balance singalong immediacy with darker lyrical undertones and 1970s-tinged pop references. Songs singled out repeatedly include “Use It”, “The Bleeding Heart Show”, “Twin Cinema” and “Sing Me Spanish Techno” as among the best songs on Twin Cinema, with “Use It” emerging most often as a highlight for its blunt wit and hook-forward construction.

Professional reviews emphasize the album's collaborative dynamic - Neko Case's torchy deliveries, Carl Newman's deft songcraft, and Dan Bejar's weird textures combine to create the record's signature vocal interplay and melodic craftsmanship. Critics praised piano-backed balladry such as “The Bones of an Idol” and more propulsive cuts like “The Jessica Numbers” for showing range beyond pure power-pop, even as several reviewers cautioned the 14-track running order sometimes dilutes impact. The consensus suggests Twin Cinema rewards repeated listens: the best tracks land as essential moments while the whole collection confirms the band's modest ambition and consistent songwriting skill.

Taken together the reviews frame Twin Cinema as a confident, well-crafted chapter in The New Pornographers' catalog - not a radical reinvention, but a resonant distillation of their strengths. For those asking whether Twin Cinema is good and which are the best songs on the record, critics point to “Use It”, “The Bleeding Heart Show” and “Twin Cinema” as reliable entry points before diving deeper into the album's collaborative rewards.

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

Twin Cinema

2 mentions
75
02:59
2

The Bones of an Idol

3 mentions
89
02:51
3

Use It

5 mentions
100
03:26
4

The Bleeding Heart Show

3 mentions
99
04:27
5

Jackie, Dressed In Cobras

3 mentions
69
03:06
6

The Jessica Numbers

3 mentions
69
03:06
7

These Are the Fables

4 mentions
68
03:29
8

Sing Me Spanish Techno

2 mentions
93
04:16
9

Falling Through Your Clothes

2 mentions
10
02:53
10

Broken Beads

2 mentions
49
03:00
11

Three Or Four

1 mention
48
03:07
12

Star Bodies

0 mentions
—
04:07
13

Streets of Fire

1 mention
100
02:41
14

Stacked Crooked

2 mentions
36
04:18
15

High Art, Local News

0 mentions
—
03:00

Get the next albums worth your time.

Critic-backed picks in one clean digest. No clutter.

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 18 critics who reviewed this album

Critic's Take

The New Pornographers keep doing what they do best on Twin Cinema, a record of bright hooks and modest ambition that never quite becomes a masterpiece. The reviewer's steady, observant voice points to the hard-rocking title track and the urgent “Use It” as clear best tracks on Twin Cinema, while the moody, meditative “These Are the Fables” shows their more introspective side. He praises the group's collective approach and tunefulness, noting that charm and catchiness compensate for the modest scale. Overall, Twin Cinema presents several of the best songs on the album without overturning expectations, a pleasing refinement rather than a leap forward.

Key Points

  • The best song is the title track because it is called "hard-rocking" and "invigorating" and embodies the album's bright hooks.
  • The album's core strengths are tunefulness, collective performance, and catchy harmonies that favor modest refinement over grand ambition.

Themes

collective band dynamic power pop hooks modesty versus ambition 1960s/70s guitar pop references

Sp

Spin

Unknown
Unknown date
91

Critic's Take

In a voice that practically drips admiration, The New Pornographers's Twin Cinema is presented as the band’s best yet, a record where songs like “Use It” and “Jackie, Dressed In Cobras” feel like instant classics. The reviewer revels in the album’s sun-splashed AM radio melodies and hook-heavy arrangements, insisting that “Use It” and “Sing Me Spanish Techno” could be number one singles in an alternate universe. There is particular praise for Neko Case and Carl Newman’s interplay, and for Dan Bejar’s triumphant contributions such as “Streets of Fire” and “Broken Beads”, which add weird, beguiling texture. The narrative insists this is a true group effort now, each member allowed to shine, making Twin Cinema feel gloriously complete and hard to resist.

Key Points

  • The best songs like "Use It" win through irresistible hooks, rollicking energy, and distinctive lyrics.
  • The album’s core strength is collaborative songwriting and rich vocal harmonies that let multiple members shine.

Themes

super-group collaboration power-pop hooks and harmonies vocal interplay individual member contributions

Critic's Take

The New Pornographers sound more assured than ever on Twin Cinema, a record whose best songs - notably “Use It” and “Falling Through Your Clothes” - marry instant hummability with surprising ambition. Rob Mitchum's sentences skip between admiration and detail, celebrating Newman's richer piano work and Kurt Dahle's drum push that lift tracks like “The Jessica Numbers” and “The Bleeding Heart Show”. The review names these standouts in a tone equal parts enthusiastic and analytic, arguing that the album's top tracks are both immediate and multi-layered. That balance is why searchers asking for the best songs on Twin Cinema will repeatedly find themselves circling back to “Use It” and “Falling Through Your Clothes”.

Key Points

  • The best song is best because rhythmic invention and Newman's expanded piano arrangements make it both immediate and ambitious.
  • The album's core strengths are its layered pop songwriting, prominent drum production, and successful blending of multiple singer-songwriters into a cohesive sound.

Themes

power pop craftsmanship rhythmic complexity collaborative supergroup dynamics mature songwriting

Ir

Irish Times

Unknown
Aug 26, 2005
80

Critic's Take

The New Pornographers deliver on Twin Cinema with a clutch of propulsive, hook-laden songs that make the best tracks on Twin Cinema irresistible. The reviewer's eye latches onto AC Newman’s knack for vintage-tinged pop and darker lyrical details, which is why “The Bleeding Heart Show” and “The Jessica Numbers” stand out as highlights. There is a pleasing balance here between sugary melody and personalised, occasionally darker themes, so listeners hunting the best songs on Twin Cinema will find themselves returning to those tracks again and again. This is, in short, a treasure trove of quality that rewards repeated plays.

Key Points

  • The Bleeding Heart Show is best because it epitomises the album's hook-laden, propulsive indie-pop.
  • The album’s core strength is blending 1970s pop influences with darker, personalised lyrical themes and strong melodies.

Themes

indie pop/rock 1970s pop influences darker lyrical themes melodic craftsmanship

Critic's Take

The New Pornographers sound like they have sharpened every edge on Twin Cinema, and the best songs - “Use It” and “The Bleeding Heart Show” - show why: hooks piling atop hooks and harmonies that soar. Jonathan Keefe’s voice delights in the band’s.Propulsive sense of purpose and reckless swagger, praising Newman’s songcraft even as he finds the album overlong. He points to individual moments of perfection - the filthy wit in “Use It” and the glorious bridge in “The Bleeding Heart Show” - as the clearest answers to what the best tracks on Twin Cinema offer. Yet Keefe also warns that at 14 tracks the record overstays its welcome, so the best tracks are most potent in concentrated doses.

Key Points

  • “Use It” is the best track for its unforgettable lyric and peak hookcraft.
  • The album’s strengths are dense harmonies, soaring melodies, and meticulous three-minute pop construction, though the 14-track length makes it overlong.

Themes

power-pop craft vocal harmonies songcraft vs. album length collaboration
70

Critic's Take

The New Pornographers sound exactly like themselves on Twin Cinema, a record of catchy, singalong power-pop that rarely surprises but often delights. The reviewer repeatedly flags the title track “Twin Cinema” and “Use It” as clear best tracks, praising a killer guitar solo and the band’s knack for building excitement. In quieter moments, songs led by Neko Case such as “The Bones of an Idol” are singled out as sweeping and near-masterpiece level, thanks to rhythmic piano and lilting background vocals. Overall, the best songs on Twin Cinema are the immediate, shoutable numbers and the piano-led ballads that show the band’s formula still works without being revolutionary.

Key Points

  • The title track is the album's best for its killer guitar solo and shoutable chorus.
  • The album's core strength is crafted, singable power-pop balanced with memorable piano-led slower songs.

Themes

pop craftsmanship catchy choruses piano-backed balladry power pop formula
Mojo logo

Mojo

Unknown
Unknown date
60