Humanhood by The Weather Station
77
ChoruScore
14 reviews
Jan 17, 2025
Release Date
Fat Possum
Label

The Weather Station's Humanhood arrives as a searching, often beautiful reckoning where Tamara Lindeman folds personal crisis into communal music. Across reviews, critics single out songs such as “Humanhood”, “Neon Signs”, “Sewing”, “Body Moves” and “Mirror” as the record's clearest emotional centers, and the album's blend of folk-jazz, improvised arrangements and layered production consistently frames those moments as the best songs on Humanhood. With a 76.86/100 consensus score across 14 professional reviews, the critical reception skews favorable while acknowledging occasional friction between experiment and cohesion.

Critics' Top Tracks

The standout songs that made critics take notice

1

general instrumentation

1 mention

"buoyed by some of the most extravagant and raucous instrumentation in the band’s history"
Clash Music
2

Sewing

11 mentions

"On final track Sewing, Lindeman resolves to accept the bad with the good"
The Skinny
3

Neon Signs

11 mentions

"Lead single Neon Signs is a vibrant, flickering song about the breakdown of trust"
The Skinny
buoyed by some of the most extravagant and raucous instrumentation in the band’s history
C
Clash Music
about "general instrumentation"
Read full review
1 mention
85% sentiment

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

Descent

9 mentions
73
01:00
2

Neon Signs

11 mentions
100
05:07
3

Mirror

10 mentions
100
04:56
4

Window

10 mentions
100
02:41
5

Passage

9 mentions
40
00:48
6

Body Moves

13 mentions
100
03:27
7

Ribbon

10 mentions
78
03:18
8

Fleuve

7 mentions
35
01:10
9

Humanhood

14 mentions
100
04:11
10

Irreversible Damage

10 mentions
97
05:36
11

Lonely

10 mentions
83
04:36
12

Aurora

9 mentions
37
01:37
13

Sewing

11 mentions
100
05:58

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 15 critics who reviewed this album

Critic's Take

Written in the wake of personal crisis, The Weather Station's Humanhood stakes its best songs in quiet, aching detail - songs like “Irreversible Damage” and “Ribbon” become the album's emotional centers. The record folds banjo and fiddle into washes of synth, letting tracks such as “Mirror” and “Lonely” breathe with extended, wordless outros that feel purposeful and necessary. Lindeman's voice remains the gravitational center, turning conversational on “Lonely” and confessional on the title track, which makes the best tracks on Humanhood register as intimate recovery songs as much as political statements. This is an album that listens to its own fractures and finds music inside them, so the best songs here are those that let the pieces speak.

Key Points

  • “Irreversible Damage” is the album's emotional centerpiece because of its intimate conversation and prominent instrumentation.
  • The album's core strengths are Lindeman's voice, the fusion of acoustic and electronic textures, and collaborative, circuitous arrangements.
Sputnikmusic logo

Sputnikmusic

Unknown
Jan 22, 2025
72

Critic's Take

In a voice that balances intimacy with weary clarity, The Weather Station's Humanhood finds its strongest moments in the quietly wrenching songs such as “Window”, “Body Moves” and “Sewing”. The record wears its confessional core openly, the looser songwriting and jazzy-folk arrangements letting tracks like “Mirror” and the title track breathe while Lindeman unpacks mental health with candid, poetic lines. For listeners asking about the best songs on Humanhood, those three tracks crystallize the album's merge of tender orchestration and razor-edged lyricism, offering the clearest emotional payoffs. This is an album that soothes and unsettles in equal measure, rewarding attentive listening rather than casual skimming.

Key Points

  • The best songs - notably "Window", "Body Moves" and "Sewing" - merge tender orchestration with razor-edged, confessional lyricism.
  • Humanhood's core strengths are its intimate, poetic lyrics and a looser, jazzy-folk musical palette that rewards attentive listening.

Themes

mental health alienation intimacy musical improvisation dreamy atmospherics vs. raw content

Critic's Take

The Weather Station’s Humanhood finds Tamara Lindeman reconnecting through the body and nature, and it is on tracks like “Body Moves” and the title track “Humanhood” where the record’s rewards are clearest. Hedderman’s ear for spacious, jazz-inflected arrangements pays off - “Body Moves” wraps the listener in warm piano and sax while the title song turns water into a literal lifeline. The record’s instrumental vignettes, from the fluttering opener “Descent” to the luminous close of “Sewing”, make the best songs feel both intimate and expansively arranged. This is an album that channels pain into a stubborn, tender clarity, and those moments make the best tracks on Humanhood resonate long after they end.

Key Points

  • The best song, "Body Moves", pairs warm jazz textures with sincere lyricism to make it the record’s emotional centerpiece.
  • Humanhood’s core strengths are its spacious, jazz-inflected arrangements and intimate exploration of body, water and pain that turn suffering into clarity.

Themes

body water trust pain healing

Critic's Take

The Weather Station's Humanhood feels like an exercise in presence, and the best songs - notably “Humanhood” and “Neon Signs” - capture that inward-to-universal ache in Lindeman's voice. The title track jolts you into the present with an image of diving into Lake Ontario, while “Neon Signs” gives the album its stark opening confession. Bedrock tracks such as “Window” and “Body Moves” expand those moments, their arrangements stretching folk into a jazz-tinged song cycle. Ultimately the record works because Lindeman's improvisational band instincts and Karen Ng's foregrounded woodwind make private crisis feel gloriously communal.

Key Points

  • The title track “Humanhood” is best for jolting the listener into presence and framing the album's thematic project.
  • The album's core strengths are Lindeman's intimate lyricism made expansive by improvisational arrangements and prominent woodwind, turning private crisis into universal music.

Themes

mental health presence / staying in the moment improvisation folk-jazz fusion personal to universal
Mojo logo

Mojo

Jan 16, 2025
80

Critic's Take

The Weather Station's Humanhood feels like a quietly devastating patchwork, and the best songs - notably “Sewing” and “Neon Signs” - show Tamara Lindeman stitching personal fracture into something almost consoling. Jim Wirth writes with a steadied, slightly rueful authority, dwelling on how “Neon Signs” captures an alienated street-walk and how closing track “Sewing” literally looks up from the work of repair. He frames “Body Moves” and the title track as small reckonings - moments where water, movement and physicality loosen anxiety - and praises the album as a superbly honed musical novella that owns its pain. The result answers the question of the best tracks on Humanhood by privileging songs that marry lyrical frankness to subtle musical shifts, with “Sewing” the emotional centrepiece.

Key Points

  • “Sewing” is the best song because it functions as the emotional centrepiece where Lindeman stitches personal fracture into repair.
  • The album’s core strengths are candid songwriting, water/nature imagery as solace, and subtle musical shifts that translate private anxiety into communal feeling.

Themes

mental health isolation nature/water as healing environmental anxiety self-reconstruction

Critic's Take

The Weather Station’s Humanhood thrives when Lindeman lets compositions breathe, and the best songs - notably “Neon Signs” and “Window” - show why. John Amen’s review praises the album's free-flowing, experimental reach while noting a high-fi gloss that keeps pieces accessible. He foregrounds the interplay of piano and percussion on “Ribbon” and the summery, mercurial feel of “Mirror”, explaining why listeners asking for the best tracks on Humanhood will point to those moments. In short, Humanhood rewards patience, offering standout tracks amid a restless, artful palette.

Key Points

  • “Neon Signs” is best for its fluid piano, eager drums, and moody vocal that bridge orchestral pop and jazz.
  • The album’s core strengths are its experimental, free-flowing arrangements and the blend of sophisticated pop with salon jazz textures.

Themes

experimentation vs cohesion mind-body relationship minimalism and maximalism deconstruction and incompleteness sophisticated pop and salon jazz crossover

Critic's Take

In a voice that delights in genre mischief, The Weather Station delivers Humanhood as a storm of styles where the best songs - “Mirror”, “Body Moves” and “Lonely” - repeatedly land. The reviewer revels in how improvisation and eclectic instrumentation make those tracks feel like discoveries, praising the way Lindeman's voice threads through folk, neo-soul and minimalist arrangements. At times the chaos holds songs back, but when restraint meets experiment, as on “Mirror” and “Body Moves”, the result is thrilling and humane. The writing stresses that these standouts show why the album's genre-loss is more gift than gimmick.

Key Points

  • The best song is 'Mirror' because its daring blend of folk, R&B and neo-soul is called 'a real triumph'.
  • The album's core strength is adventurous genre-blending and intimate vocal performances born from improvisation.

Themes

genre-blending improvisation ambience vs chaos vocal intimacy

Critic's Take

In this review the writer frames The Weather Station's Humanhood as a patient, probing follow-up that locates its best songs in intimate, observational detail. The critic repeatedly elevates “Humanhood” and “Body Moves” as moments where lyric and arrangement crystallize, calling them standout songs that reveal the album's concerns about embodiment and aftermath. The voice is analytical and conversational, steering readers toward the best tracks on Humanhood by focusing on the record's quiet power and narrative focus.

Key Points

  • The title track “Humanhood” is best because it crystallizes the album's lyric and arrangement into a clear emotional center.
  • The album's core strengths are intimate observation, patient arrangements, and thematic focus on embodiment after climate-focused records.

Themes

humanity climate aftermath introspection embodiment relationships

Critic's Take

In this review Shawn Donohue hears the best tracks on Humanhood as those that turn dense arrangements into emotional levers. The Weather Station finds real highs in “Mirror” and “Neon Signs”, where odd piano plinks, hip-hop percussion and disco-laden beats let Lindeman’s yearning cut through the swirl. The closer “Sewing” stands out as a thematic summit, Lindeman using the act of sewing as a metaphor for keeping on amid chaos. Overall, the album’s assembled, layered sound makes those moments of clarity feel earned rather than accidental.

Key Points

  • “Mirror” is the best song for its inventive instrumentation and disorienting, rewarding finale.
  • The album’s core strength is its layered, assembled sound that lets moments of clarity emerge from dense arrangements.

Themes

disconnection and yearning for connection layered/assembled sound synthetic vs. organic instrumentation searching for meaning in modern life

Critic's Take

The Weather Station's Humanhood finds Tamara Lindeman moving inward and outward at once, and the best songs on Humanhood make that tug feel revelatory. In the reviewer's voice: the aching opener “Neon Signs” is a gently rocking meditation that pins down the album's emotional center, while “Window” and “Body Moves” propel the record with flight and coiled groove respectively. The title track “Humanhood” and the stark “Irreversible Damage” translate private reckoning into vivid musical scenes, and the six-minute closer “Sewing” quietly stitches those insights into something earned.

Key Points

  • “Neon Signs” is the best song because it establishes the album's emotional center with tense piano, pulsing rhythm, and memorable lyricism.
  • The album's core strengths are its intricate, warmly organic arrangements and Lindeman's ability to translate private reckoning into vivid musical scenes.

Themes

personal crisis transition catharsis community environmental analogies
100

Critic's Take

The Weather Station’s Humanhood feels like a restless reclamation of self, the songs in motion and searching. The review highlights “Neon Signs” as a vibrant, flickering lead single and names the title track “Humanhood” and closer “Sewing” as central emotional anchors. Lindeman’s voice threads through flurries of woodwind and shivery percussion, making these best tracks on Humanhood stand out for their urgency and tenderness. The writing points listeners toward those songs as the clearest expressions of the album’s themes of collective healing and environmental loss.

Key Points

  • The best song is “Neon Signs” because it is called a vibrant, flickering lead single that captures the album’s urgent emotional core.
  • The album’s core strengths are Lindeman’s intimate songwriting and the restless, windblown arrangements that render themes of self and environmental loss visceral.

Themes

selfhood and depersonalisation collective healing environmental change displacement and reclamation

Critic's Take

The Weather Station's Humanhood finds Tamara Lindeman leaning into maximalist textures while keeping her voice as the album's moral centre, and the best songs underscore that balance. The title track, “Humanhood”, rings with choppy snares and intimate despair that make it one of the best tracks on Humanhood. Closer “Sewing” and the woodwind-tinged “Ribbon” also stand out, the former closing with the same cathartic pathos and the latter glowing from Karen Ng's saxophone and clarinet. Read as a whole, these songs exemplify why critics are already calling Humanhood one of the most full-throated creations from the band.

Key Points

  • The title track “Humanhood” is best for its choppy snares and emotional core that encapsulate the album's balance.
  • The album's core strengths are Lindeman's warm, ethereal vocals and the vivid, nature-inspired maximalist instrumentation.

Themes

nature-inspired soundscapes desolation and isolation maximalist instrumentation vocal warmth and pathos continuity with past work

Critic's Take

In his measured, observant tone, Steve Horowitz presents The Weather Station's Humanhood as a collaborative, improvisatory work where the band shapes songs like “Descent” and “Body Moves” into evocative moods rather than narratives. He notes a persistent, poetic sensibility - short, suggestive titles such as “Window” and “Passage” point to atmosphere over plot, and the leader, Tamara Linderman, remains central even as the ensemble colors her lines. Horowitz singles out how “Descent” opens as a flute-led journey and how “Body Moves” and “Window” let the band comment around Linderman's emotional statements. The result, he suggests, makes the best tracks on Humanhood feel like small revelations, intimate and collectively wrought rather than solo confessions.

Key Points

  • “Descent” is the best song because it sets the album’s tone with a flute-led instrumental that blossoms into ensemble interplay.
  • The album’s core strengths are its collaborative improvisatory approach, poetic lyrics, and mood-driven arrangements that balance melancholy and renewal.

Themes

memory renewal improvisation disconnection and reconnection collaborative ensemble

Critic's Take

The Weather Station sound more forceful and experimental on Humanhood, and the best tracks - notably “Neon Signs” and “Body Moves” - crystallize that shift. Steve Erickson writes with brisk analytical clarity, noting how “Neon Signs” ends in an atonal flutter and how “Body Moves” anxiously describes bodily confusion, making them standout moments. The title track “Humanhood” registers as a lyrical hinge - "Maybe I can get back to my body" - which ties the album's yearning to its environmental unease. Overall the record is prickly and less accessible, but its layered production and rhythmic complexity reward attentive listening for fans seeking the best songs on Humanhood.

Key Points

  • “Neon Signs” is the best track for its striking atonal ending and incisive lyrics about transactional relationships.
  • The album's strengths are layered production, rhythmic complexity, and a persistent lyrical focus on the body amid environmental anxiety.

Themes

identity mind-body tension yearning for physicality environmental anxiety experimentation with production