U2 Carnaval De Luz
Released Nov 13, 2026 Universal-Island Records Ltd.
Established consensus 7 professional reviews Updated Nov 13, 2026
Mostly positive consensus
U2's Carnaval De Luz finds the band sounding newly alive, balancing familiar stadium-scale ambition with a more playful, exploratory touch.
How ChoruScore worksCritics' Top Tracks
The songs critics returned to most
The Greatest Show On Earth
6 critic mentions
“packed with enough celestial guitar, bass and drums to suggest it will become a With or Without You-type live anthem.” — The Guardian
La Reina
5 critic mentions
“La Reina should remind you, riding the tail of The Edge’s writhing riff to a soaringly exalted chorus” — Record Collector
Silencio
5 critic mentions
“The driving Silencio is as convincing a punk rocker as it’s possible to imagine from very rich men in their 60s.” — The Guardian
Full critic consensus
U2's Carnaval De Luz finds the band sounding newly alive, balancing familiar stadium-scale ambition with a more playful, exploratory touch. Its 73.57/100 consensus score across seven professional reviews points to a warmly received, if uneven, return: critics praise the renewed energy and the sense of a group relishing the chance to play together, while noting that not every grand gesture lands.
The critical consensus centers on reinvention without abandoning U2's core strengths. The cinematic sweep of “The Greatest Show On Earth” emerges as the most reliable highlight, with critics hearing both concert-ready scale and reflective intimacy in its celestial guitar-led arrangement. “La Reina” also draws repeated praise, shifting from a stomping strut toward a hymnal refrain, while “Silencio” brings punk-inflected force and a vivid link to the band's past. “If The World Is At War We Better Not Be” stands out for its searching reflection on faith, belief, and ordinary lives. Together, these songs capture the record's pull between light and darkness, introspection and celebration.
Some reviewers hear U2's best and most effective work in years, even decades, in this mix of nostalgia and forward motion. Others find the results inconsistent, pointing to a few thinner or more conventional stadium-sized moments. Still, critics repeatedly welcome the lighter, more engaged performance and the album's willingness to take risks without losing its melodic reach. For anyone asking whether Carnaval De Luz is worth hearing, the reviews suggest a rewarding, imperfect record whose standout songs make the case for U2's continuing capacity to surprise.
Track Ratings
How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.
Go (Carnaval De Luz)
La Reina
Street Of Dreams
The Mirror Maker (Rosalía)
Superficiality
If The World Is At War We Better Not Be
Silencio
The Greatest Show On Earth
Glorify
Midnight Sunshine
Can’t Stop Us Now
Torn (feat. Dolly Parton)
Get the next albums worth your time.
Critic-backed picks in one clean digest. No clutter.
What Critics Are Saying
Deep insights from 7 critics who reviewed this album
Ho
Critic's Take
U2 still know how to make a grand entrance on Carnaval De Luz. The best tracks on Carnaval De Luz include “Go (Carnaval De Luz),” a mammoth, wonderfully atmospheric invention, and “The Greatest Show On Earth,” where the spectacle opens into something far more intimate and challenging. Roll up, roll up: there’s a carnival coming to town!
Key Points
-
“Can't Stop Us Now” is the standout for its menacing build and swampy breakdown, which the reviewer calls a revelation.
-
The album’s strengths are its grand scale, adventurous genre shifts, and vulnerable moments of intimacy.
Themes
Critic's Take
U2 sound rejuvenated on Carnaval De Luz, audibly thrilled to be playing together in a room again. The best songs on Carnaval De Luz include “La Reina”, which veers into a beautifully hymnal mantra, and “If The World Is At War We Better Not Be”, a sublime reflection on faith, belief and ordinary lives. “The Greatest Show On Earth” has enough celestial guitar, bass and drums to suggest it will become a live anthem, while “Midnight Sunshine” is one of their sweetest, loveliest pop songs. Not everything hits such a high bar, but nothing lets the side down either: this is some of the band’s best work in more than 30 years.
Key Points
-
“La Reina” stands out as its monster rock riff gives way to a beautifully hymnal mantra.
-
The album’s core strength is its epically impassioned, elevating music, pairing spiritual themes with a rejuvenated, joyfully confident band.
Themes
Re
Critic's Take
U2 sound ambitious and engaged on Carnaval De Luz, a determinedly energetic and uplifting answer to their sibling EPs. The best tracks on Carnaval De Luz find the band leaning into their core strengths: “Silencio” packs a lot into its brief duration, while the reflective, wistful “The Greatest Show On Earth” makes its concert-ready glow feel earned. They sound like they’re swinging for the fences and hitting more targets than not.
Key Points
-
The Greatest Show On Earth stands out for its reflective, wistful meditation and a concert-ready glow the reviewer says feels earned.
-
The album’s core strength is U2’s return to energetic, melody-led songs that balance introspection with celebration.
Themes
Critic's Take
U2 do what they do best on Carnaval De Luz, making huge, widescreen, panoramic rock songs, though the results pull in different directions at once. The best tracks on Carnaval De Luz include “La Reina”, a stadium-whacking anthem, and “Silencio”, a crushing, punk-infused thriller; “The Greatest Show On Earth” is driven forwards by the kind of bombastic guitar line only The Edge can truly get away with. At times thrilling, it isn’t perfect, but nonetheless contains some of U2’s best and most effective music for a decade.
Key Points
-
The album’s core strengths are its panoramic rock songs, Bono’s powerful vocals, and a willingness to take risks.
Themes
Critic's Take
U2 return with a record that feels energized and alive, one foot in the past and one firmly in the present. The best tracks on Carnaval De Luz include “The Greatest Show on Earth,” a cinematic, brooding highlight, and “If The World Is at War We Better Not Be,” an arresting song that demands a listener's full attention. Ambitious but accessible, catchy but substantial, this is a solid record and an exciting return.
Themes
Critic's Take
U2 return on Carnaval De Luz with a spark that was missing, and the best tracks find Bono considering what he can summon with the right people around him. “Go (Carnaval De Luz)” is sprite and spunky, a two-and-a-half-minute mission statement; “La Reina” calls back to the sinewy, devilish glam of Achtung Baby before reaching further back. On “Can’t Stop Us Now,” Bono aims his troublesome ambition at the prospect of heading back on tour. These are songs of connection, and the thinned-out sound lets each member take the spotlight.
Key Points
-
“Go (Carnaval De Luz)” is the best song discussed, a sprite and spunky mission statement that opens the album with a spark.
-
The album’s core strength is its defiant joy and thinned-out sound, which lets the band members take the spotlight.
Themes
Critic's Take
U2 have revived a joy that reinvigorates their songwriting on Carnaval De Luz, with the outstanding “The Greatest Show On Earth” and the stomping strut of “La Reina” among its best tracks. “Silencio” nods to the band’s past, while “Superficiality” ventures into groovy disco and “Midnight Sunshine” lets its melody do the work. Not everything works as well: “Go (Carnaval De Luz)” is weirdly thin, and “Can’t Stop Us Now” is one more standard issue stadium anthem than the record needed. Still, Carnaval De Luz delivers on the lightness of touch that its title promises; for the first time in a long time, U2 sound more playful than preachy.
Key Points
-
“The Greatest Show On Earth” stands out, with soaring guitars that summon a stirring nod to The Joshua Tree.
-
The album’s core strength is its crackling energy and playful lightness, with disco, gospel, and melody-led pop alongside familiar U2 grandeur.