Weird Nightmare Hoopla
Consensus is still forming across 3 professional reviews. Weird Nightmare's Hoopla bursts with sunlit melodicism and a clear mission: elevate melody over noise while nodding to garage roots. Across three professional reviews the record earned an 80/100 consensus score, with critics calling it a compact, summer-ready set that trades in 60s psychedelia, power pop revivalism, an
The best song is considered to be "Never in Style" for its jangling riffs and memorable melodies.
Shared criticism is still limited across the current review sample.
Best for listeners looking for melody over noise and nostalgia, starting with Bright City Lights and Might See You There.
Explore the full Chorus artist page, discography, and related genre paths.
See where this record sits inside the full critic-ranked discography.
Jump from this record into the broader critic-consensus lists for 2026.
Full consensus notes
Weird Nightmare's Hoopla bursts with sunlit melodicism and a clear mission: elevate melody over noise while nodding to garage roots. Across three professional reviews the record earned an 80/100 consensus score, with critics calling it a compact, summer-ready set that trades in 60s psychedelia, power pop revivalism, and DIY underground energy.
Critics consistently praise the album's songwriting and hooks, identifying standout tracks that define the record's strengths. “Might See You There” and “Pay No Mind” receive repeated attention for marrying Cheap Trick-style propulsion and garage snarl to irresistible hooks, while “Bright City Lights”, “Baby Don’t”, and “Forever Elsewhere” are highlighted as some of the best songs on Hoopla. Reviewers note heightened production that sharpens jangling riffs and doo-wop flourishes without erasing the band's gritty charm, producing upbeat pop-rock moments and wistful balladry alike.
While some critics point to occasional repetition, the dominant critical consensus frames Hoopla as a focused, pleasing return that foregrounds melody and classic songcraft. For those searching for a Hoopla review or wondering if the record is worth listening to, the consensus score across three professional reviews suggests this collection is a rewarding, nostalgia-tinged listen and a solid entry in Weird Nightmare's catalog.
Critics' Top Tracks
The standout songs that made critics take notice
Bright City Lights
1 mention
"Never in Style" and "Bright City Lights" are nostalgic gems"— AllMusic
Might See You There
2 mentions
"Drank your Mom’s whiskey until we couldn’t see/it’s been a lifetime I’m still trying to leave,"— No Ripcord
Pay No Mind
2 mentions
"Take the rifftastic "Pay No Mind," one of the funnest tracks on here,"— No Ripcord
the more moody moments... highlight the influence from underground scenes of the 80s and 90s with songs like Never In Style coming to mind
Track Ratings
How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.
Headful of Rain
Might See You There
Baby Don't
Forever Elsewhere
Never in Style
Pay No Mind
If You Should Turn Away
Little Strange
Bright City Lights
Where I Belong
Get the next albums worth your time.
Critic-backed picks in one clean digest. No clutter.
What Critics Are Saying
Deep insights from 3 critics who reviewed this album
Critic's Take
On Weird Nightmare's Hoopla Alex Edkins lets melody rule the day, turning toward tuneful power pop while retaining some of his heft. The best songs on Hoopla - “Never in Style” and “Bright City Lights” - are nostalgic gems with big jangling riffs and sweet melodies. “Might See You There” stands out too, injecting Cheap Trick propulsion into the mix. The record feels compact, focused and like a wistful nod to the musical discoveries that shaped him, with production that sharpens rather than softens the songs.
Key Points
-
The best song is considered to be "Never in Style" for its jangling riffs and memorable melodies.
-
Hoopla's core strength is tuneful, compact power pop songwriting balanced with rugged, muscular presentation.
Themes
Critic's Take
Weird Nightmare's Hoopla feels like a refreshing exhale, a record of beaming guitar pop that sticks and delights. Edkins moves from jangly stompers like “Never in Style” to yearning ballads such as “If You Should Turn Away” with the ease of someone tuning a 60s-70s radio dial, and those are the best songs on Hoopla because they pair craft with undeniable hooks. “Might See You There” and “Pay No Mind” are prime examples of how he mixes sweet recollection with garage snarl, making them among the best tracks on Hoopla. The album convinces you for a solid 30-plus minutes that timeless, sturdy pop can still thrill.
Key Points
-
The best song is driven by strong hooks and melodic power-chord progressions that marry garage snarl with pop sweetness.
-
The album’s core strength is its ability to craft timeless, sturdy power pop with attention to detail and joyful execution.
Themes
Di
Critic's Take
Weird Nightmare return with Hoopla, a sunlit, nostalgia-soaked record whose best songs - like “Baby Don’t” and “Forever Elsewhere” - trade in irresistible pop melodies and doo-wop flourishes that feel tailor-made for summer parties. The opener “Headful of Rain” immediately sets a high-energy tone with an alternative-guitar hook and an anthemic chorus, while “If You Should Turn Away” demonstrates the band’s softer, more lowkey charms. There are moments where the record lapses into repetition, but those small critiques do little to blunt the pleasure of its brightest tracks. This is an album that leans into its vintage tinge and catchy songwriting, delivering several of the best tracks on Hoopla without pretension.
Key Points
-
The best song is a tie between “Baby Don’t” and “Forever Elsewhere” for their joyful pop melodies and doo-wop hooks.
-
Hoopla's core strengths are its vintage, 60s-tinged psychedelic and beach-rock influences married to upbeat, summer-ready pop-rock songwriting.