Wolf Alice The Clearing
Wolf Alice's The Clearing arrives as a restless, often soaring chapter in the band's catalogue that blends Laurel Canyon warmth, Seventies soft-rock sheen and sudden bursts of arena-size drama. Across thirteen professional reviews the record earned a 77.92/100 consensus score, and critics consistently point to a handful of songs as the album's clearest rewards: “Bloom Baby Bloom”, “White Horses” and repeated mentions of “Passenger Seat” and “Play It Out” mark the record's high points.
The critical consensus frames The Clearing as ambitious and polished - an intentional pop shift that trades some of the band's earlier jaggedness for radio-ready melodies and studio gloss. Praise concentrates on spectacle and vocal bravado, with many reviewers calling “Bloom Baby Bloom” a triumphant, cinematic centerpiece and “White Horses” the album's most affecting, intimate payoff. Reviewers also highlight genre-blending flourishes - Latin rhythms, gospel-soul detours and Elliott Smith-like tenderness - that give tracks like “Just Two Girls” and “Thorns” both warmth and craft.
Yet critics are not unanimous. Several reviews salute the band's maturation, band cohesion and confident ambition, while others fault moments of over-polish and safe balladry that blunt prior ferocity. That tension - ambition versus safety, spectacle versus intimacy - is the through-line: when The Clearing commits to risk the results feel essential; when it retreats to studio comfort, the album flattens. Taken together, the professional reviews suggest The Clearing is worth attention for its standout songs and its portrayal of aging, friendship and artistic growth, setting up a record that both expands Wolf Alice's reach and provokes debate about what they left behind.
Critics' Top Tracks
The standout songs that made critics take notice
White Horse
1 mention
"drummer Joel Amey takes lead vocals on the swirling, psychedelic rush of "White Horse," with Rowsell’s soaring backing vocals"— Under The Radar
Bloom Baby Bloom
11 mentions
"the curtain was lifted on “Bloom Baby Bloom”, the bold and triumphant comeback single"— The Line of Best Fit
Play It Out (lyrical mention)
1 mention
"with its irony of growing old and questioning motherhood"— The Line of Best Fit
drummer Joel Amey takes lead vocals on the swirling, psychedelic rush of "White Horse," with Rowsell’s soaring backing vocals
Track Ratings
How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.
Thorns
Bloom Baby Bloom
Just Two Girls
Leaning Against The Wall
Passenger Seat
Play It Out
Bread Butter Tea Sugar
Safe in the World
Midnight Song
White Horses
The Sofa
What Critics Are Saying
Deep insights from 14 critics who reviewed this album
Critic's Take
In a voice that alternates admiration and exasperation, Wolf Alice on The Clearing trade jaggedness for glossy pop sheen, and the review makes clear which songs survive that trade-off. The reviewer leans on “Passenger Seat” and “Bread Butter Tea Sugar” as vindications of the pop tilt, while praising the intimacy of “White Horses” as a standout moment. The tone is measured but pointed - the album contains brilliant moments, yet often sands down the sharp edges that once defined the band. This narrows the answer to queries about the best tracks on The Clearing: listen first to “Passenger Seat”, “Bread Butter Tea Sugar”, and the quietly fresh “White Horses” for the album's clearest rewards.
Key Points
-
The best song(s) are the tracks that embrace Kurstin's pop sheen successfully, notably "Passenger Seat" for vindicating the album's approach.
-
The album's core strengths are charismatic performances and some intimate, fresh moments, balanced against a tendency to sand down the band's sharper edges.
Themes
Critic's Take
Wolf Alice's The Clearing finds its best songs in moments of clarity and emotional heft, namely “Thorns”, “White Horses” and the closing “The Sofa”. The reviewer frames the record as Ellie Rowsell’s odyssey through grief, so the best tracks on The Clearing land where drama meets restraint - the operatic rush of “Bloom Baby Bloom” gives way to the gorgeous, fuzzy-headed surrender of “The Sofa”. There are also shining turns of lush soft-rock in “Just Two Girls” and affecting piano balladry at the album’s hinge, “Play It Out”, which help explain why listeners search for the best tracks on The Clearing.
Key Points
-
The best song, 'Thorns', anchors the record’s mid-youth crisis theme and is explicitly recommended by the reviewer.
-
The album’s core strengths are confident, refined songwriting that blends 1970s influences with emotional range from operatic highs to tender balladry.
Themes
Critic's Take
Wolf Alice arrive on The Clearing with the surety of a band that have both earned and refined their swagger, and the best songs - notably “Bloom Baby Bloom” and “Thorns” - showcase Ellie Rowsell at her most commanding and intimate at once. Izzy Sigston's writing leans celebratory but precise, praising the triumphant comeback single “Bloom Baby Bloom” for its bold, Axl Rose-channeling pre-chorus and singling out “Thorns” as an opener that wouldn’t feel out of place in a Bond sequence. The review highlights quieter moments too - “Play It Out” and “Leaning Against The Wall” - as evidence of the band maturing on their own terms, balancing vulnerability with theatricality. Overall the best tracks on The Clearing are those that place Rowsell centre stage while the rest of the band shuffle alongside, delivering both spectacle and tenderness across the record.
Key Points
-
The best song is “Bloom Baby Bloom” because it is praised as a bold, triumphant comeback that spotlights Rowsell’s vocals.
-
The album’s core strengths are Rowsell’s commanding vocal performances and the band’s matured, cohesive arrangements that balance spectacle and intimacy.
Themes
Critic's Take
Wolf Alice's The Clearing finds its strongest moments in the theatrical highs of “Bloom Baby Bloom” and the aching payoff of “White Horses”. Miranda Wollen writes with a frank, observant tone, noting how “Bloom Baby Bloom” simmers into an unabashedly cinematic chorus while “White Horses” becomes the album's high point through Joel Amey's vocal turn. She frames “Play It Out” as the album's emotional anchor - a quiet piano prayer that grounds the record even as it flirts with mainstream pop. The result is a pastiche that often succeeds in vivid atmosphere, even when it slips into triteness later on.
Key Points
-
“White Horses” is the best song for its vocal turn and cathartic chorus that synthesize the album's movement and sureness.
-
The album's core strength is vivid, emotive imagery and rich atmospheres even as it shifts toward mainstream pop.
Themes
Critic's Take
Wolf Alice sound reborn on The Clearing, a confident and elegant evolution where the best songs - “Bloom Baby Bloom” and “Passenger Seat” - reveal the band at their most assured. Andy Von Pip praises Ellie Rowsell’s voice as a stunning instrument throughout, noting how tracks such as “Thorns” and “Safe in the World” balance grandeur with intimacy in a way that answers searches for the best songs on The Clearing. The review foregrounds crafty songwriting and irresistible choruses, explaining why the best tracks here feel timeless rather than derivative. This is the record that may finally move Wolf Alice from cult to mainstream without surrendering their identity.
Key Points
-
The best song is "Bloom Baby Bloom" because it is called an extraordinary shapeshifter anchored by an irresistible chorus.
-
The album’s core strengths are assured songwriting, Ellie Rowsell’s versatile vocals, and tasteful classic-rock influences.
Themes
Critic's Take
Wolf Alice arrive on The Clearing as a band widening their scope while staying rooted, and the best songs show that balance. The titanic lead single “Bloom Baby Bloom” is the obvious highlight, a Fleetwood Mac-sized arena banger that showcases newfound ambition. Subtle opener “Thorns” eases you in, while the concise “Passenger Seat” proves their ear for vintage pop songcraft. The mini cycle of “Bread Butter Tea Sugar”, “Safe In The World” and “Midnight Song” supplies studio sheen and cements why these are the best tracks on The Clearing.
Key Points
-
The best song, “Bloom Baby Bloom”, is best because it amplifies Wolf Alice’s ambition into an arena-ready, Fleetwood Mac-like banger.
-
The album’s core strengths are its confident pop transition, studio polish, and a tethering to the band’s roots that keeps ambition grounded.
Themes
Critic's Take
Wolf Alice sound intent on marrying arena-sized hooks with artful influence on The Clearing, and the best songs on the album make that case plainly. Opener “Thorns” unveils layered, ABBA-like harmonies that set the tone, while “Just Two Girls” channels mid-70s Fleetwood Mac filtered through a Jenny Lewis sensibility. Bloom Baby Bloom and “Leaning Against The Wall” also stand out for their risky turns - Latin rhythms and Elliott Smith-into-gospel detours give the best tracks on The Clearing an adventurous, radio-ready sheen. Overall, Rowsell remains compelling throughout, which is why these tracks feel like Wolf Alice at their most assured.
Key Points
-
Thorns is best because its layered, ABBA-like harmonies immediately establish the album's melodic ambition.
-
The album's core strength is blending 70s pop influences with contemporary pop production to create radio-friendly yet adventurous songs.
Themes
Critic's Take
Wolf Alice lean into Laurel Canyon warmth on The Clearing, and the best songs - notably “Bloom Baby Bloom” and “Just Two Girls” - show why. The reviewer revels in the band's anarchic songcraft on “Bloom Baby Bloom”, praising its raucous bridge and dream-poppy chorus, while “Just Two Girls” is described in warm, nostalgic terms and carried by Rowsell's proud chorus. Lesser material drifts into acoustic monotony, though rollicking moments like “White Horses” and the boogie of “Bread Butter Tea Sugar” puncture that calm. The closing “The Sofa” is singled out for being both light-footed and forthright lyrically, ending the album on a thoughtful note.
Key Points
-
The best song is “Bloom Baby Bloom” because its anarchic structure, raucous bridge, and dream-poppy chorus reinvigorate contemporary rock.
-
The album's core strengths are nostalgic warmth and occasional bursts of rollicking energy amid a mostly mellow, acoustic midsection.
Themes
Critic's Take
Wolf Alice's The Clearing is where post-twenty chaos gives way to calm, and the best songs - “Thorns”, “Just Two Girls” and “Leaning Against The Wall” - prove the band have never been sharper at translating grown-up clarity into melody. Ellie Rowsell's lyricism is at its most incisive here, and the warm Cali-pop of “Just Two Girls” and the piano-led “Thorns” make a convincing case as the best tracks on The Clearing. Drummer Joel Amey's lead on “White Horses” and the tender acceptance of “Bread Butter Tea Sugar” round out an album that rewards patience and close listening.
Key Points
-
‘Thorns’ is best for its piano-led intimacy and direct self-reflection, echoing earlier career highs.
-
The album’s core strength is mature, incisive songwriting that transforms post-twenty turmoil into calm clarity.
Themes
Critic's Take
Wolf Alice's The Clearing feels like a band taking stock and staking a claim, a record that reiterates their legacy while pushing the stakes higher. The reviewer's tone is celebratory and assured, arguing that The Clearing is "another perfectly-pitched stepping stone" that makes the case for best tracks as those that carry that vital momentum. For listeners asking what the best songs on The Clearing are, the emphasis is on the album's overall cohesion and vitality rather than isolated singles - the record as a whole is presented as the standout.
Key Points
-
The best song(s) are those that contribute to the album's sense of momentum and vitality rather than a single standout track.
-
The album's core strength is its confident consolidation of Wolf Alice's legacy and clear ascent toward legendary status.
Themes
Critic's Take
In his clear-eyed take on The Clearing, Jon Dolan singles out the album's biggest moments - the stomping “Bloom Baby Bloom” and the massive payoff of “White Horses” - as proof that Wolf Alice finally put sweep and depth together. He writes in a measured, admiring tone that links Rowsell's raw vocals to Florence Welch and Dolores O'Riordan while also valuing quieter tracks like “The Sofa” and “Passenger Seat” for emotional heft. The result addresses queries about the best songs on The Clearing with both rock spectacle and intimate songwriting, highlighting why “Bloom Baby Bloom” and “White Horses” stand out.
Key Points
-
“Bloom Baby Bloom” is the album's showpiece, a stomping high-point that fuses Kate Bush-like daring with rock spectacle.
-
The album's core strength is combining sweeping classic-rock influences with intimate, honest songwriting about adulthood and self-discovery.
Themes
Critic's Take
Patrick Gill writes with a measured, slightly disappointed eye: Wolf Alice's The Clearing finds its best moments in the deceptively restless “Bloom Baby Bloom” and the groovy, Suede-tinged “White Horses”. Gill notes that “Bloom Baby Bloom” comes closest to the band’s old intensity while flirting with Fiona Apple and Florence & the Machine, and he highlights “White Horses” as the record's most compelling moment when Joel Amey sings over a steady Krautrock beat. Throughout the review he laments that the band sound more searching than sure, praising production but criticizing a loss of the venom that once defined them.
Key Points
-
“Bloom Baby Bloom” is the best song because it most closely recaptures Wolf Alice's earlier intensity while exploring new influences.
-
The album's core strengths are strong production and stylistic ambition, but it suffers from a tamed sound and inconsistent originality.
Themes
Critic's Take
In a review that alternates between admiring spectacle and exasperated diagnosis, Wolf Alice land one towering triumph on The Clearing with “Bloom Baby Bloom”, an avant-pop triumph that marries Steve Reich-like motifs to a feral, Kate Bush-quoting vocal. The second-best moment, “White Horses”, offers Joel Amey’s introspective verses and an Enya-ish chorus that briefly hints at the more ambitious record they might have made. Elsewhere the album drifts into safe, by-numbers balladry - think middle-of-the-road country and highway clichés in “Leaning Against The Wall” and “Passenger Seat” - leaving The Clearing feeling disappointingly cautious outside its two highs.
Key Points
-
‘Bloom Baby Bloom’ is best for its adventurous composition and Rowsell’s versatile, powerful vocals.
-
The album’s core strengths are vivid lyrics and strong vocal performance, undermined by cautious, by-the-numbers production.