Acadia by Yasmin Williams
83
ChoruScore
6 reviews
Oct 4, 2024
Release Date
Nonesuch
Label

Yasmin Williams's Acadia unfolds as an exuberant, technically daring statement that turns fingerstyle guitar into communal storytelling. Across six professional reviews, critics point to the record's blend of pastoral warmth and adventurous composition as evidence that Acadia both honors folk traditions and expands them through inventive arranging and guest turns.

The critical consensus earned a 82.67/100 score across 6 professional reviews, with reviewers consistently praising tracks like “Cliffwalk (feat. Dom Flemons)”, “Hummingbird (feat. Allison de Groot & Tatiana Hargreaves)” and “Virga”. Critics note Williams's technical guitar virtuosity and rhythmic inventiveness on opener “Cliffwalk”, the tempo play and bluegrass-leaning interplay on “Hummingbird”, and the album's quieter, meditative moments on “Virga”. Reviewers from Dusted Magazine, KLOF Mag, PopMatters, The Line of Best Fit, Pitchfork and The Skinny highlight the record's melding of acoustic and electric textures, successful collaborations, and a sense of growth that makes many of the best songs on Acadia feel both immediate and carefully crafted.

While praise centers on Williams's adventurous compositions and warm guest contributions, some critics temper enthusiasm by noting occasional shifts toward denser arrangements and drums that interrupt the pastoral flow. Even so, the dominant narrative frames Acadia as a standout guitar-centric collection that balances virtuosity with generosity, leaving a clear impression of an artist widening her palette. For readers wondering "is Acadia good" and "what are the best songs on Acadia", the critical consensus points to a confidently realized, worth-listening record anchored by “Cliffwalk (feat. Dom Flemons)”, “Hummingbird (feat. Allison de Groot & Tatiana Hargreaves)” and “Virga”.

Critics' Top Tracks

The standout songs that made critics take notice

1

Cliffwalk

1 mention

"Cliffwalk opens the digital edition of the album, with Williams accompanied by music scholar Dr. Dom Flemons"
The Skinny
2

Cliffwalk (feat. Dom Flemons)

5 mentions

"ready to break down some hoary definitions"
Dusted Magazine
3

Hummingbird

1 mention

"This celebratory tone continues on Hummingbird, in which Allison de Groot’s banjo and Tatiana Hargreaves' fiddle conjure up images of barn dances"
The Skinny
Cliffwalk opens the digital edition of the album, with Williams accompanied by music scholar Dr. Dom Flemons
T
The Skinny
about "Cliffwalk"
Read full review
1 mention
95% sentiment

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

Cliffwalk (feat. Dom Flemons)

5 mentions
100
04:44
2

Harvest (feat. Kaki King & Darian Donovan Thomas)

5 mentions
100
04:05
3

Hummingbird (feat. Allison de Groot & Tatiana Hargreaves)

5 mentions
100
05:51
4

Virga (feat. Darlingside)

5 mentions
72
06:22
5

Sisters

5 mentions
25
06:57
6

Dawning (feat. Aoife O'Donovan)

5 mentions
72
06:27
7

Dream Lake (feat. Malick Koly)

5 mentions
82
04:12
8

Nectar (feat. Magro)

4 mentions
51
02:59
9

Malamu (feat. Marcus Gilmore & Immanuel Wilkins)

4 mentions
72
04:20

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 7 critics who reviewed this album

Critic's Take

Yasmin Williams keeps extending her language on Acadia, where the best tracks - notably “Cliffwalk (feat. Dom Flemons)” and “Harvest (feat. Kaki King & Darian Donovan Thomas)” - show her knack for marrying fingerstyle invention with warm collaboration. The review privileges those pieces because they crystallize her gifts: rhythmically intricate guitar figures, generous arranging choices, and moments that feel like small, emphatic revelations. The voice here is admiring but precise, pointing to exact songs as evidence of Williams's widening reach. The result answers plainly what are the best tracks on Acadia while staying true to the reviewer’s measured enthusiasm.

Key Points

  • The best song is exemplary because it crystallizes Williams's expanded fingerstyle language with a standout collaboration.
  • The album's core strengths are inventive instrumental guitar textures and thoughtful collaborative arrangements.

Themes

instrumental guitar exploration collaboration Americana and folk textures meditative landscapes
87

Critic's Take

Yasmin Williams's Acadia feels like a celebration - the best songs, such as “Hummingbird” and “Harvest”, glow with meticulous playing and big-hearted guests. The record's highs are the extended, shifting pieces that let her technique breathe and surprise, so listeners asking "best tracks on Acadia" will find “Hummingbird” a standout for its tempo play and “Cliffwalk” a charming opener. Across the album the collaborations add warmth and contrast, which is why the best songs on Acadia feel both technically dazzling and warmly human.

Key Points

  • Hummingbird is the best song for its extended structure, tempo shifts, and heartfelt playing.
  • The album's core strength is collaborative warmth combined with meticulous, technically intricate guitar work.

Themes

collaboration technical guitar virtuosity pastoral/bucolic warmth momentum and tempo shifts melding acoustic and electric textures

Critic's Take

A restless explorer of technique and tone, Yasmin Williams stretches into new territory on Acadia, where the best tracks - “Cliffwalk”, “Hummingbird”, and “Dawning” - crystalize her leap forward. The record feels ambitious and scholarly yet never clinical, and opener “Cliffwalk” sets the album’s idiosyncratic romp in motion. “Hummingbird” offers the closest approach to bluegrass with joyful banjo and fiddle interplay, while “Dawning” draws elements together into a cooperative, quietly brilliant centerpiece. This is Williams coming into herself, technically assured and increasingly adventurous on the best tracks of Acadia.

Key Points

  • “Cliffwalk” is best for setting the album’s idiosyncratic, ambitious tone and signaling collaborative breadth.
  • The album’s core strengths are technical finesse, inventive collaborations, and balancing roots influences with exploratory sounds.

Themes

growth collaboration roots and innovation technical proficiency

Critic's Take

Janne Oinonen hears the best tracks on Acadia as proof of Yasmin Williams's astonishing craft: the opener “Cliffwalk” channels vintage fretboard acrobatics while “Harvest” spins Williams's guitar around Darian Donovan Thomas's bittersweet violin to heartbreaking effect. The review singles out “Dawning” as a six-minute slice of pastoral bliss and praises the adventurous shifts toward drums and electric textures on “Dream Lake” and “Nectar”. In this voice, the best songs on Acadia are those that balance tuneful accessibility with restless musical adventurousness, making the album feel like the most compelling guitar record of the year.

Key Points

  • The best song, "Dawning", is praised as a six-minute pastoral bliss that showcases Williams's compositional ambition and wordless vocals.
  • The album's core strengths are virtuosic fingerpicking, tasteful guest collaborations, and adventurous blending of folk, post-rock and jazz elements.

Themes

solo acoustic guitar tradition genre blending collaboration with guests pastoral and folk influences adventurous composition

Critic's Take

Bright and gregarious yet focused, Yasmin Williams’s Acadia spotlights its best tracks with a communal warmth - listen for “Hummingbird” and “Malamu” as high points. The reviewer’s affection for Williams’ technique and her collaborators makes clear why the best songs on Acadia feel both inventive and welcoming. “Hummingbird” hums like a garden in motion, while “Malamu” erupts into a joyful, risky finale that argues for these as the album’s standout tracks. Overall the album’s bright expansiveness and playful tangents mark its strongest achievements.

Key Points

  • “Malamu” is the best song for its ecstatic saxophone finale and bold fusion of jazz, folk, and rock.
  • The album’s core strength is Williams’ inventive guitar technique combined with warm, varied collaborations and nature-infused arrangements.

Themes

collaboration nature imagery folk-jazz fusion instrumental storytelling

Critic's Take

Yasmin Williams's Acadia feels like a communal celebration, and the best tracks on the album - “Cliffwalk”, “Hummingbird” and “Virga” - make that case plainly. Patrick Gamble writes with a warm, observant tone, noting how “Cliffwalk” opens the album with Dr. Dom Flemons' rhythm bones like "dancing shoes on a hardwood floor" and how “Hummingbird” conjures barn dances. He highlights “Virga” as gentle and unbothered, the sort of track that underlines Williams' egalitarian collaborations. The result is an album praised for its inventiveness on guitar and its inviting, communal spirit.

Key Points

  • The best song, "Cliffwalk", stands out for its vivid rhythmic imagery and celebratory opening.
  • The album’s core strengths are Williams' inventive guitar work and an egalitarian, nature-infused spirit of collaboration.

Themes

collaboration folk traditions nature guitar virtuosity celebration