Shiverstruck by IAN SWEET

IAN SWEET Shiverstruck

76
ChoruScore Critic consensus / 100

Released Jul 24, 2026 Polyvinyl Records

Established consensus 5 professional reviews Updated Oct 6, 2026

Broadly positive consensus

IAN SWEET's Shiverstruck arrives as a study in intimate contradiction, pairing hooky indie/synth pop with moments of stark vulnerability to uneasy but affecting effect.

How ChoruScore works

Critics' Top Tracks

The songs critics returned to most

01

Hired Gun

1 critic mention

“Hired Gun"—a fantastic, important song with motorik propulsion” — Paste Magazine
02

Criminal Kissing

5 critic mentions

“that toys with the idea of meeting up for breakfast with the absent ex ("I swear I'm not this reckless/But what if tomorrow…")” — AllMusic
03

Jilian

2 critic mentions

“Jilian" is a poignant and promising concept for a track” — Paste Magazine
Full critic consensus

IAN SWEET's Shiverstruck arrives as a study in intimate contradiction, pairing hooky indie/synth pop with moments of stark vulnerability to uneasy but affecting effect. Across five professional reviews, critics point to Medford's knack for melodic immediacy and candid lyricism while debating whether the record's momentum always pays off. The consensus score sits at 76/100 from five reviews, signaling generally favorable but measured praise.

Critics consistently praise standout tracks that crystallize the album's themes of relocation, heartache, and introspection. “Criminal Kissing” emerges most often as a highlight, lauded for propulsive drums and fuller, catchier production that channels melancholy into pop catharsis. “Jilian” and “Wild Heart” receive attention for their earworm hooks and move-from-New York sentiment, while “Hired Gun” is singled out for motorik drive and sharp guitar work. Reviewers also point to the quieter pieces - opener “987” and the title track “Shiverstruck” - as moments where sparse arrangements let Medford's emotional rawness and homesick intimacy register most fully.

While several critics celebrate the record's authentic, confessional voice and its winsome melodies, some note a sense of stalled motion or uneven imagery that prevents a sustained catharsis. The critical consensus suggests that the best songs on Shiverstruck make it worth hearing: they balance vulnerability, sorrow, and popcraft in ways that reward repeat listens. Below, the full reviews unpack where the album shines, where it hesitates, and what it reveals about Medford's evolving songwriting.

Track Ratings

How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.

View:
1

987

4 mentions
73
03:12
2

Criminal Kissing

5 mentions
99
03:52
3

Silver Screen

0 mentions
—
04:10
4

Jilian

2 mentions
93
04:24
5

Deadweight

2 mentions
54
03:51
6

Shiverstruck

4 mentions
89
02:52
7

Hired Gun

1 mention
100
04:20
8

La La Love

1 mention
83
04:47
9

Wild Heart

2 mentions
68
04:03
10

Speed Demon

1 mention
5
04:16

Get the next albums worth your time.

Critic-backed picks in one clean digest. No clutter.

What Critics Are Saying

Deep insights from 5 critics who reviewed this album

Critic's Take

IAN SWEET's Shiverstruck homes in on the best songs with a directness that favors melody and catharsis, especially on “Criminal Kissing” and “Deadweight”. The reviewer's voice lingers on the album's breakup-through-relocation core, noting how “Criminal Kissing” swirls with melancholy while “Deadweight” turns depression into an infectious singalong. Medford's knack for earwormy, midtempo hooks is evident in “Jilian”, which drives home the move-from-New York sentiment, and the title track offers the lone stripped-down moment of despair. Overall these best tracks demonstrate why listeners searching for the best songs on Shiverstruck will find catharsis in its combination of vulnerability and hooky pop.

Key Points

  • Deadweight is the best song because it turns depression into an infectious, singalong chorus.
  • The album's core strengths are its hooky melodies, candid breakup themes, and a balance of movement and stripped-down despair.

Themes

breakup relocation heartache vulnerability hooky indie/synth pop

Critic's Take

IAN SWEET makes intimacy feel invasive on Shiverstruck, and the best songs land because they trade polish for truth. The reviewer keeps returning to “Criminal Kissing” as a standout, praising its fuller, catchier production, while quieter tracks like “Shiverstruck” and opener “987” are praised for sparseness and emotional immediacy. The voice throughout is admiring and intimate, insisting that the record's authenticity is its greatest achievement.

Key Points

  • The best song is “Criminal Kissing” because it pairs fuller production with irresistible immediacy.
  • The album’s core strength is its authentic emotional intimacy, delivering both stripped-back and upbeat indie pop with empathy.

Themes

emotion authenticity empathy intimacy indie pop
80

Critic's Take

IAN SWEET returns on Shiverstruck with songs that feel more like confessions than pop pieces, and the best songs on Shiverstruck are the ones that hang in the silence - “987” and “Shiverstruck” stand out for their intimacy and weight. Melissa Beatty’s prose is intimate and admiring, noting how “987” opens with hushed guitar and how the title track leaves you "lost in the dark, eyes shut tight," which explains why listeners search for the best tracks on Shiverstruck. The record blooms into richer arrangements by “Criminal Kissing” yet always returns to that raw, affecting core that makes these songs linger long after they end.

Key Points

  • The title track is the emotional centerpiece, enveloping the listener and showcasing the album's weight.
  • The album's core strength is its intimate, unfiltered emotionality that lingers after each song.

Themes

sorrow self-reflection intimacy longing emotional rawness

Critic's Take

On IAN SWEET’s Shiverstruck the best tracks are where Medford reclaims intimacy and bite, notably “Jilian” and “Hired Gun”. The review’s voice finds “Jilian” poignant and promising, a song that feels like a pivot even if the album sometimes backtracks. Likewise, “Hired Gun” is praised as fantastic and important, with motorik propulsion and wicked guitar parts. The title track “Shiverstruck” encapsulates the record’s hit-and-miss nature, yielding moments of real arresting lyricism amid familiar territory.

Key Points

  • The best song, "Hired Gun," combines propulsive music and sharp commentary to stand out.
  • The album’s strengths are intimate lyricism and occasional striking lines, but it often retreads earlier material.

Themes

evolution vs stagnation mental health relationships homesickness

Critic's Take

IAN SWEET’s Shiverstruck bristles with small, inward moments but rarely detonates into the catharsis it hints at. Abby Jones foregrounds Medford’s knack for messy, combustible detail and praises how “Criminal Kissing” winks over propulsive drums. She finds the opener “987” pretty but undermined by vague imagery. Overall, Jones treats Shiverstruck as an album of stalled motion with flashes of promise that don’t quite cohere.

Key Points

  • The best song, "Wild Heart", earns praise as a rousing, propulsive penultimate moment and a glimpse of thematic redemption.

Themes

heartbreak inertia move/homecoming introspection