{"data":{"agreement":[{"album":"Critical Thinking","artist":"Manic Street Preachers","artist_slug":"manic-street-preachers","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/manic-street-preachers","slug":"manic-street-preachers-critical-thinking","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/manic-street-preachers-critical-thinking","image_url":"images\/manic-street-preachers\/critical-thinking\/05d9a130-e406-5460-8bbb-62f1796ab45e.jpg","release_date":"2025-02-07","release_year":"2025","consensus_score":79,"confidence_percent":90,"review_count":11,"source_count":11,"score_mean":79.1,"score_std":2.9,"score_min":70,"score_max":80,"score_range":10,"agreement_score":73.8,"disagreement_score":26.3,"agreement_label":"Near-unanimous","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-10-15T19:43:56+00:00","summary":"Manic Street Preachers' Critical Thinking turns familiar rock instincts into a spirited case for facing uncertainty with beauty, rage, and a measure of hope. The critical reception...","highest_review":{"score":80,"source":"The Line of Best Fit","source_slug":"the-line-of-best-fit","author":null,"published_at":"2025-05-05","url":"https:\/\/www.thelineofbestfit.com\/albums\/manic-street-preachers-critical-thinking-finest-sonic-experiments"},"lowest_review":{"score":70,"source":"DIY Magazine","source_slug":"diy-magazine","author":null,"published_at":"2025-02-12","url":"https:\/\/diymag.com\/review\/album\/manic-street-preachers-critical-thinking"},"source_spread":[{"score":70,"source":"DIY Magazine","source_slug":"diy-magazine","author":null,"url":"https:\/\/diymag.com\/review\/album\/manic-street-preachers-critical-thinking"},{"score":80,"source":"The Line of Best Fit","source_slug":"the-line-of-best-fit","author":null,"url":"https:\/\/www.thelineofbestfit.com\/albums\/manic-street-preachers-critical-thinking-finest-sonic-experiments"}]},{"album":"Somewhere Good","artist":"Tara Clerkin Trio","artist_slug":"tara-clerkin-trio","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/tara-clerkin-trio","slug":"tara-clerkin-trio-somewhere-good","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/tara-clerkin-trio-somewhere-good","image_url":"images\/tara-clerkin-trio\/somewhere-good\/a670fd02-a06d-5426-b18b-f12f449b3e40.jpg","release_date":"2026-06-05","release_year":"2026","consensus_score":82,"confidence_percent":90,"review_count":7,"source_count":7,"score_mean":81.6,"score_std":3.5,"score_min":80,"score_max":90,"score_range":10,"agreement_score":60.6,"disagreement_score":26.9,"agreement_label":"Strong agreement","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-10-01T02:09:16+00:00","summary":"Tara Clerkin Trio's Somewhere Good unfolds as a quietly spellbinding study in texture and restraint, earning praise from critics for its melancholic, psychedelic nostalgia and inve...","highest_review":{"score":90,"source":"AllMusic","source_slug":"allmusic","author":"Tim Sendra","published_at":"2026-06-05","url":"https:\/\/www.allmusic.com\/album\/somewhere-good-mw0004781529"},"lowest_review":{"score":80,"source":"The Line of Best Fit","source_slug":"the-line-of-best-fit","author":"Janne Oinonen","published_at":"2026-06-05","url":"https:\/\/www.thelineofbestfit.com\/albums\/tara-clerkin-trio-somewhere-good-review-experimentation-has-rarely-sounded-as-inviting"},"source_spread":[{"score":80,"source":"The Line of Best Fit","source_slug":"the-line-of-best-fit","author":"Janne Oinonen","url":"https:\/\/www.thelineofbestfit.com\/albums\/tara-clerkin-trio-somewhere-good-review-experimentation-has-rarely-sounded-as-inviting"},{"score":90,"source":"AllMusic","source_slug":"allmusic","author":"Tim Sendra","url":"https:\/\/www.allmusic.com\/album\/somewhere-good-mw0004781529"}]},{"album":"Easier Said Than Done","artist":"Pool Kids","artist_slug":"pool-kids","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/pool-kids","slug":"pool-kids-easier-said-than-done","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/pool-kids-easier-said-than-done","image_url":"images\/pool-kids\/easier-said-than-done\/7056d21d-da7c-5fb6-a996-9689c46ce4ab.jpg","release_date":"2025-08-15","release_year":"2025","consensus_score":78,"confidence_percent":90,"review_count":7,"source_count":7,"score_mean":78,"score_std":3.5,"score_min":70,"score_max":80,"score_range":10,"agreement_score":60.6,"disagreement_score":26.9,"agreement_label":"Strong agreement","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-08-27T03:19:27+00:00","summary":"Pool Kids's Easier Said Than Done arrives as a clear-eyed, autumn-tinged collection that refines the band's emo-revival instincts into hook-driven, emotionally vivid songs. Critics...","highest_review":{"score":80,"source":"AllMusic","source_slug":"allmusic","author":null,"published_at":"2025-09-26","url":"https:\/\/www.allmusic.com\/album\/easier-said-than-done-mw0004556333"},"lowest_review":{"score":70,"source":"The Line of Best Fit","source_slug":"the-line-of-best-fit","author":null,"published_at":"2025-08-18","url":"https:\/\/www.thelineofbestfit.com\/albums\/pool-kids-easier-said-than-done-wade-into-deep-end"},"source_spread":[{"score":70,"source":"The Line of Best Fit","source_slug":"the-line-of-best-fit","author":null,"url":"https:\/\/www.thelineofbestfit.com\/albums\/pool-kids-easier-said-than-done-wade-into-deep-end"},{"score":80,"source":"AllMusic","source_slug":"allmusic","author":null,"url":"https:\/\/www.allmusic.com\/album\/easier-said-than-done-mw0004556333"}]},{"album":"Luster","artist":"Maria Somerville","artist_slug":"maria-somerville","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/maria-somerville","slug":"maria-somerville-luster","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/maria-somerville-luster","image_url":"images\/maria-somerville\/luster\/23efe83f-d48d-554b-8692-76cc5302251b.jpg","release_date":"2025-04-25","release_year":"2025","consensus_score":82,"confidence_percent":90,"review_count":7,"source_count":7,"score_mean":82.1,"score_std":3.6,"score_min":80,"score_max":90,"score_range":10,"agreement_score":59.9,"disagreement_score":27.6,"agreement_label":"Strong agreement","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-10-01T22:26:24+00:00","summary":"Maria Somerville's Luster unfolds like a coastal reverie, its dream-pop and shoegaze textures braided with Celtic spirituality and modern electronic flourishes to striking effect....","highest_review":{"score":90,"source":"Clash Music","source_slug":"clash-music","author":"Robin Murray","published_at":"2025-04-28","url":"https:\/\/www.clashmusic.com\/reviews\/maria-somerville-luster\/"},"lowest_review":{"score":80,"source":"The Quietus","source_slug":"the-quietus","author":"Kate French-Morris","published_at":"2025-04-29","url":"https:\/\/thequietus.com\/quietus-reviews\/maria-somerville-luster-review\/"},"source_spread":[{"score":80,"source":"The Quietus","source_slug":"the-quietus","author":"Kate French-Morris","url":"https:\/\/thequietus.com\/quietus-reviews\/maria-somerville-luster-review\/"},{"score":90,"source":"Clash Music","source_slug":"clash-music","author":"Robin Murray","url":"https:\/\/www.clashmusic.com\/reviews\/maria-somerville-luster\/"}]},{"album":"You & I Are Earth","artist":"Anna B Savage","artist_slug":"anna-b-savage","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/anna-b-savage","slug":"anna-b-savage-you-i-are-earth","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/anna-b-savage-you-i-are-earth","image_url":"images\/anna-b-savage\/you-i-are-earth\/a3d1aa97-2848-594e-b6aa-6e77450e152e.jpg","release_date":"2025-01-24","release_year":"2025","consensus_score":77,"confidence_percent":90,"review_count":7,"source_count":7,"score_mean":77.4,"score_std":3.8,"score_min":70,"score_max":80,"score_range":10,"agreement_score":58.6,"disagreement_score":28.9,"agreement_label":"Strong agreement","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-10-02T07:57:32+00:00","summary":"Anna B Savage's You & I Are Earth arrives as a quietly commanding statement, where intimate songwriting meets folklore, place and shimmering aquatic imagery. Across seven professio...","highest_review":{"score":80,"source":"The Line of Best Fit","source_slug":"the-line-of-best-fit","author":null,"published_at":"2025-01-29","url":"https:\/\/www.thelineofbestfit.com\/albums\/anna-b-savage-you-and-i-are-earth-unabashed-love-album"},"lowest_review":{"score":70,"source":"AllMusic","source_slug":"allmusic","author":null,"published_at":"2025-01-27","url":"https:\/\/www.allmusic.com\/album\/you-i-are-earth-mw0004401947"},"source_spread":[{"score":70,"source":"AllMusic","source_slug":"allmusic","author":null,"url":"https:\/\/www.allmusic.com\/album\/you-i-are-earth-mw0004401947"},{"score":80,"source":"The Line of Best Fit","source_slug":"the-line-of-best-fit","author":null,"url":"https:\/\/www.thelineofbestfit.com\/albums\/anna-b-savage-you-and-i-are-earth-unabashed-love-album"}]},{"album":"Peaches!","artist":"The Black Keys","artist_slug":"the-black-keys","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/the-black-keys","slug":"the-black-keys-peaches","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/the-black-keys-peaches","image_url":"images\/the-black-keys\/peaches\/45816c0a-7a5e-511f-8666-c0f90dbc48c3.jpg","release_date":"2026-05-01","release_year":"2026","consensus_score":78,"confidence_percent":90,"review_count":10,"source_count":10,"score_mean":78.4,"score_std":3.8,"score_min":70,"score_max":82,"score_range":12,"agreement_score":66.1,"disagreement_score":33.9,"agreement_label":"Strong agreement","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-10-01T09:19:11+00:00","summary":"The Black Keys's Peaches! reconnects the duo with the ragged, swamp-born blues that defined their early years, delivering gritty covers and a handful of genuinely electrifying mome...","highest_review":{"score":82,"source":"Beats Per Minute","source_slug":"beats-per-minute","author":"Ian Barker","published_at":"2010-05-24","url":"https:\/\/beatsperminute.com\/album-review-the-black-keys-brothers\/"},"lowest_review":{"score":70,"source":"Rolling Stone","source_slug":"rolling-stone","author":"Jon Dolan","published_at":"2026-04-29","url":"https:\/\/www.rollingstone.com\/music\/music-album-reviews\/black-keys-peaches-review-1235549028\/"},"source_spread":[{"score":70,"source":"Rolling Stone","source_slug":"rolling-stone","author":"Jon Dolan","url":"https:\/\/www.rollingstone.com\/music\/music-album-reviews\/black-keys-peaches-review-1235549028\/"},{"score":82,"source":"Beats Per Minute","source_slug":"beats-per-minute","author":"Ian Barker","url":"https:\/\/beatsperminute.com\/album-review-the-black-keys-brothers\/"}]},{"album":"EUSEXUA Afterglow","artist":"FKA twigs","artist_slug":"fka-twigs","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/fka-twigs","slug":"fka-twigs-eusexua-afterglow","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/fka-twigs-eusexua-afterglow","image_url":"images\/fka-twigs\/eusexua-afterglow\/1b187f0e-3ec2-589a-97bd-78e72d4782d7.jpg","release_date":"2025-11-14","release_year":"2025","consensus_score":77,"confidence_percent":85,"review_count":8,"source_count":8,"score_mean":77,"score_std":4,"score_min":70,"score_max":80,"score_range":10,"agreement_score":65.5,"disagreement_score":34.5,"agreement_label":"Strong agreement","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-10-01T10:06:32+00:00","summary":"FKA twigs's EUSEXUA Afterglow channels club nightlife and post-club comedown into a shimmering, sometimes delirious suite of songs that critics call equal parts hedonism and intros...","highest_review":{"score":80,"source":"Hot Press","source_slug":"hot-press","author":"Chloe Craft","published_at":"2025-11-26","url":"https:\/\/www.hotpress.com\/music\/album-review-fka-twigs-eusexua-afterglow-23119498"},"lowest_review":{"score":70,"source":"Rolling Stone","source_slug":"rolling-stone","author":"Will Hermes","published_at":"2025-11-14","url":"https:\/\/www.rollingstone.com\/music\/music-album-reviews\/fka-twigs-eusexua-afterglow-review-1235464790\/"},"source_spread":[{"score":70,"source":"Rolling Stone","source_slug":"rolling-stone","author":"Will Hermes","url":"https:\/\/www.rollingstone.com\/music\/music-album-reviews\/fka-twigs-eusexua-afterglow-review-1235464790\/"},{"score":80,"source":"Hot Press","source_slug":"hot-press","author":"Chloe Craft","url":"https:\/\/www.hotpress.com\/music\/album-review-fka-twigs-eusexua-afterglow-23119498"}]},{"album":"This Mirror Weighs a Ton","artist":"Interpol","artist_slug":"interpol","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/interpol","slug":"interpol-this-mirror-weighs-a-ton","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/interpol-this-mirror-weighs-a-ton","image_url":"images\/interpol\/this-mirror-weighs-a-ton\/902b0cf6-3f05-5e0a-8e51-e997da62515d.jpg","release_date":"2026-08-28","release_year":"2026","consensus_score":79,"confidence_percent":88,"review_count":12,"source_count":12,"score_mean":79,"score_std":4,"score_min":70,"score_max":84,"score_range":14,"agreement_score":63.7,"disagreement_score":36.3,"agreement_label":"Strong agreement","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-10-03T21:18:42+00:00","summary":"Interpol's This Mirror Weighs a Ton arrives as a late-career reinvigoration that balances noir moods with newfound rhythmic openness, earning praise across the board for its ambiti...","highest_review":{"score":84,"source":"Sputnik Music","source_slug":"sputnik-music","author":null,"published_at":null,"url":"https:\/\/www.sputnikmusic.com\/review\/91168\/Interpol-This-Mirror-Weighs-a-Ton\/"},"lowest_review":{"score":70,"source":"The Line of Best Fit","source_slug":"the-line-of-best-fit","author":"Matt Young","published_at":"2026-08-21","url":"https:\/\/www.thelineofbestfit.com\/albums\/interpol-this-mirror-weighs-a-ton-return-to-reflective-thrilling-state"},"source_spread":[{"score":70,"source":"The Line of Best Fit","source_slug":"the-line-of-best-fit","author":"Matt Young","url":"https:\/\/www.thelineofbestfit.com\/albums\/interpol-this-mirror-weighs-a-ton-return-to-reflective-thrilling-state"},{"score":84,"source":"Sputnik Music","source_slug":"sputnik-music","author":null,"url":"https:\/\/www.sputnikmusic.com\/review\/91168\/Interpol-This-Mirror-Weighs-a-Ton\/"}]},{"album":"The Former Site Of","artist":"The New Pornographers","artist_slug":"the-new-pornographers","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/the-new-pornographers","slug":"the-new-pornographers-the-former-site-of","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/the-new-pornographers-the-former-site-of","image_url":"images\/the-new-pornographers\/the-former-site-of\/2e93b618-6668-59b4-bf7c-e03de8da9688.jpg","release_date":"2026-03-27","release_year":"2026","consensus_score":80,"confidence_percent":87,"review_count":8,"source_count":8,"score_mean":79.6,"score_std":4,"score_min":70,"score_max":85,"score_range":15,"agreement_score":63.3,"disagreement_score":36.8,"agreement_label":"Strong agreement","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-10-01T07:57:14+00:00","summary":"The New Pornographers's The Former Site Of reframes the band's signature power-pop instincts into a quietly reflective suite that contemplates grief, mortality, and collective iden...","highest_review":{"score":85,"source":"Hot Press","source_slug":"hot-press","author":null,"published_at":null,"url":null},"lowest_review":{"score":70,"source":"AllMusic","source_slug":"allmusic","author":"Timothy Monger","published_at":"2026-03-27","url":"https:\/\/www.allmusic.com\/album\/the-former-site-of-mw0004755383"},"source_spread":[{"score":70,"source":"AllMusic","source_slug":"allmusic","author":"Timothy Monger","url":"https:\/\/www.allmusic.com\/album\/the-former-site-of-mw0004755383"},{"score":85,"source":"Hot Press","source_slug":"hot-press","author":null,"url":null}]},{"album":"EELS","artist":"Being Dead","artist_slug":"being-dead","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/being-dead","slug":"being-dead-eels","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/being-dead-eels","image_url":"images\/being-dead\/eels\/fc7d951c-d413-5b24-a6da-b179693427d4.jpg","release_date":"2024-09-27","release_year":"2024","consensus_score":84,"confidence_percent":89,"review_count":10,"source_count":9,"score_mean":83.6,"score_std":4.3,"score_min":80,"score_max":90,"score_range":10,"agreement_score":63.3,"disagreement_score":36.8,"agreement_label":"Strong agreement","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-08-25T22:15:20+00:00","summary":"Being Dead's EELS","highest_review":{"score":90,"source":"PopMatters","source_slug":"popmatters","author":"Patrick Gill","published_at":"2024-11-04","url":"https:\/\/www.popmatters.com\/being-dead-eels-review-2"},"lowest_review":{"score":80,"source":"No Ripcord","source_slug":"no-ripcord","author":"Juan Edgardo Rodriguez","published_at":"2024-11-03","url":"https:\/\/www.noripcord.com\/reviews\/music\/being-dead\/eels"},"source_spread":[{"score":80,"source":"No Ripcord","source_slug":"no-ripcord","author":"Juan Edgardo Rodriguez","url":"https:\/\/www.noripcord.com\/reviews\/music\/being-dead\/eels"},{"score":90,"source":"PopMatters","source_slug":"popmatters","author":"Patrick Gill","url":"https:\/\/www.popmatters.com\/being-dead-eels-review-2"}]},{"album":"Dance, No One's Watching","artist":"Ezra Collective","artist_slug":"ezra-collective","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/ezra-collective","slug":"ezra-collective-dance-no-ones-watching","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/ezra-collective-dance-no-ones-watching","image_url":"images\/ezra-collective\/dance-no-ones-watching\/2b9977a6-7321-5c44-a01c-3bb41927c96e.jpg","release_date":"2024-09-27","release_year":"2024","consensus_score":83,"confidence_percent":90,"review_count":8,"source_count":8,"score_mean":82.5,"score_std":4.3,"score_min":80,"score_max":90,"score_range":10,"agreement_score":63.3,"disagreement_score":36.8,"agreement_label":"Strong agreement","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-10-02T11:01:26+00:00","summary":"Ezra Collective's Dance, No One's Watching arrives as a jubilant, dance-first statement that stitches London jazz to Afrobeat, highlife and neo-soul with contagious momentum. Acros...","highest_review":{"score":90,"source":"musicOMH.com","source_slug":"musicomhcom","author":"Ben Hogwood","published_at":"2024-09-27","url":"https:\/\/www.musicomh.com\/reviews\/albums\/ezra-collective-dance-no-ones-watching"},"lowest_review":{"score":80,"source":"Hot Press","source_slug":"hot-press","author":"Caroline Kelly","published_at":"2024-10-01","url":"https:\/\/www.hotpress.com\/music\/album-review-ezra-collective-dance-no-ones-watching-23052472"},"source_spread":[{"score":80,"source":"Hot Press","source_slug":"hot-press","author":"Caroline Kelly","url":"https:\/\/www.hotpress.com\/music\/album-review-ezra-collective-dance-no-ones-watching-23052472"},{"score":90,"source":"musicOMH.com","source_slug":"musicomhcom","author":"Ben Hogwood","url":"https:\/\/www.musicomh.com\/reviews\/albums\/ezra-collective-dance-no-ones-watching"}]},{"album":"Cannonball","artist":"Man\/Woman\/Chainsaw","artist_slug":"man-woman-chainsaw","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/man-woman-chainsaw","slug":"man-woman-chainsaw-cannonball","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/man-woman-chainsaw-cannonball","image_url":"images\/manwomanchainsaw\/cannonball\/584aadeb-9e8e-5fa6-a698-793d2736e6d5.jpg","release_date":"2026-08-07","release_year":"2026","consensus_score":83,"confidence_percent":90,"review_count":8,"source_count":8,"score_mean":82.5,"score_std":4.3,"score_min":80,"score_max":90,"score_range":10,"agreement_score":63.3,"disagreement_score":36.8,"agreement_label":"Strong agreement","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-10-10T10:24:25+00:00","summary":"Man\/Woman\/Chainsaw's Cannonball arrives as a debut that braids post-punk bite with widescreen pop ambition, and critics largely agree it succeeds where it leans into drama and dyna...","highest_review":{"score":90,"source":"musicOMH.com","source_slug":"musicomhcom","author":"John Murphy","published_at":"2026-08-07","url":null},"lowest_review":{"score":80,"source":"Exclaim","source_slug":"exclaim","author":"Ian Gormely","published_at":"2026-08-13","url":"https:\/\/exclaim.ca\/music\/article\/man-woman-chainsaw-cannonball-album-review"},"source_spread":[{"score":80,"source":"Exclaim","source_slug":"exclaim","author":"Ian Gormely","url":"https:\/\/exclaim.ca\/music\/article\/man-woman-chainsaw-cannonball-album-review"},{"score":90,"source":"musicOMH.com","source_slug":"musicomhcom","author":"John Murphy","url":null}]}],"disagreement":[{"album":"Even In Arcadia","artist":"Sleep Token","artist_slug":"sleep-token","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/sleep-token","slug":"sleep-token-even-in-arcadia","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/sleep-token-even-in-arcadia","image_url":"images\/sleep-token\/even-in-arcadia\/ea4848be-3af3-565d-b8ca-baa867fb8cef.jpg","release_date":"2025-05-09","release_year":"2025","consensus_score":68,"confidence_percent":89,"review_count":10,"source_count":10,"score_mean":68.3,"score_std":23.8,"score_min":23,"score_max":100,"score_range":77,"agreement_score":0,"disagreement_score":100,"agreement_label":"Sharp split","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-10-01T22:21:28+00:00","summary":"Sleep Token's Even In Arcadia arrives as a grand, polarizing statement that splits critics over ambition and execution. Across ten professional reviews the record earned a 68.3\/100...","highest_review":{"score":100,"source":"New Musical Express (NME)","source_slug":"new-musical-express-nme","author":"Rishi Shah","published_at":"2025-05-08","url":"https:\/\/www.nme.com\/reviews\/album\/sleep-token-even-in-arcadia-review-3860051"},"lowest_review":{"score":23,"source":"Pitchfork","source_slug":"pitchfork","author":"Eli Enis","published_at":"2025-05-14","url":"https:\/\/pitchfork.com\/reviews\/albums\/sleep-token-even-in-arcadia\/"},"source_spread":[{"score":23,"source":"Pitchfork","source_slug":"pitchfork","author":"Eli Enis","url":"https:\/\/pitchfork.com\/reviews\/albums\/sleep-token-even-in-arcadia\/"},{"score":100,"source":"New Musical Express (NME)","source_slug":"new-musical-express-nme","author":"Rishi Shah","url":"https:\/\/www.nme.com\/reviews\/album\/sleep-token-even-in-arcadia-review-3860051"}]},{"album":"ARIRANG","artist":"BTS","artist_slug":"bts","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/bts","slug":"bts-arirang","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/bts-arirang","image_url":"images\/bts\/arirang\/3db7740e-92a9-5b42-ab7e-e5bfccb29fe6.jpg","release_date":"2026-03-20","release_year":"2026","consensus_score":71,"confidence_percent":89,"review_count":9,"source_count":9,"score_mean":71.1,"score_std":22.8,"score_min":30,"score_max":100,"score_range":70,"agreement_score":0,"disagreement_score":100,"agreement_label":"Sharp split","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-10-05T10:05:03+00:00","summary":"BTS's ARIRANG arrives as a ceremonial homecoming that stitches Korean heritage to arena-ready pop, and critics largely agree the record's high points justify the ambition. Across n...","highest_review":{"score":100,"source":"Rolling Stone UK","source_slug":"rolling-stone-uk","author":"Joseph Kocharian","published_at":"2026-03-20","url":"https:\/\/www.rollingstone.co.uk\/music\/bts-deliver-k-pop-perfection-with-their-fifth-studio-album-arirang-59779\/"},"lowest_review":{"score":30,"source":"The Needle Drop","source_slug":"the-needle-drop","author":"The Needle Drop","published_at":"2026-03-26","url":"https:\/\/theneedledrop.com\/album-reviews\/bts-arirang-album-review\/"},"source_spread":[{"score":30,"source":"The Needle Drop","source_slug":"the-needle-drop","author":"The Needle Drop","url":"https:\/\/theneedledrop.com\/album-reviews\/bts-arirang-album-review\/"},{"score":100,"source":"Rolling Stone UK","source_slug":"rolling-stone-uk","author":"Joseph Kocharian","url":"https:\/\/www.rollingstone.co.uk\/music\/bts-deliver-k-pop-perfection-with-their-fifth-studio-album-arirang-59779\/"}]},{"album":"The Great Impersonator","artist":"Halsey","artist_slug":"halsey","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/halsey","slug":"halsey-the-great-impersonator","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/halsey-the-great-impersonator","image_url":"images\/halsey\/the-great-impersonator\/b6ea665b-c280-5448-b374-1c10e9b5aad6.jpg","release_date":"2024-10-25","release_year":"2024","consensus_score":72,"confidence_percent":91,"review_count":16,"source_count":16,"score_mean":72.1,"score_std":21.3,"score_min":10,"score_max":100,"score_range":90,"agreement_score":0,"disagreement_score":100,"agreement_label":"Sharp split","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-10-17T06:10:50+00:00","summary":"Halsey's The Great Impersonator turns illness, mortality, motherhood, and fame into an ambitious self-portrait, but its era-hopping concept works best when homage gives way to ungu...","highest_review":{"score":100,"source":"New Musical Express (NME)","source_slug":"new-musical-express-nme","author":"Kristen S. H\u00e9","published_at":"2024-10-25","url":"https:\/\/www.nme.com\/reviews\/album\/halsey-the-great-impersonator-review-3806286"},"lowest_review":{"score":10,"source":"The Needle Drop","source_slug":"the-needle-drop","author":"The Needle Drop","published_at":"2024-10-30","url":"https:\/\/theneedledrop.com\/album-reviews\/halsey-the-great-impersonator-album-review\/"},"source_spread":[{"score":10,"source":"The Needle Drop","source_slug":"the-needle-drop","author":"The Needle Drop","url":"https:\/\/theneedledrop.com\/album-reviews\/halsey-the-great-impersonator-album-review\/"},{"score":100,"source":"New Musical Express (NME)","source_slug":"new-musical-express-nme","author":"Kristen S. H\u00e9","url":"https:\/\/www.nme.com\/reviews\/album\/halsey-the-great-impersonator-review-3806286"}]},{"album":"Come Ahead","artist":"Primal Scream","artist_slug":"primal-scream","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/primal-scream","slug":"primal-scream-come-ahead","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/primal-scream-come-ahead","image_url":"images\/primal-scream\/come-ahead\/710c0735-f333-516c-9785-fe20d3eaec97.jpg","release_date":"2024-11-08","release_year":"2024","consensus_score":65,"confidence_percent":90,"review_count":13,"source_count":13,"score_mean":65.2,"score_std":19.4,"score_min":10,"score_max":80,"score_range":70,"agreement_score":0,"disagreement_score":100,"agreement_label":"Sharp split","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-10-02T10:51:13+00:00","summary":"Primal Scream's Come Ahead arrives as a flirtation between jubilant funk and pointed protest, with the cinematic opener “Ready To Go Home” and charged singles like &ldq...","highest_review":{"score":80,"source":"Hot Press","source_slug":"hot-press","author":"Will Russell","published_at":"2024-11-08","url":"https:\/\/www.hotpress.com\/music\/album-review-primal-scream-come-ahead-23058235"},"lowest_review":{"score":10,"source":"The Quietus","source_slug":"the-quietus","author":"JR Moores","published_at":"2024-10-30","url":"https:\/\/thequietus.com\/quietus-reviews\/primal-scream-come-ahead-review"},"source_spread":[{"score":10,"source":"The Quietus","source_slug":"the-quietus","author":"JR Moores","url":"https:\/\/thequietus.com\/quietus-reviews\/primal-scream-come-ahead-review"},{"score":80,"source":"Hot Press","source_slug":"hot-press","author":"Will Russell","url":"https:\/\/www.hotpress.com\/music\/album-review-primal-scream-come-ahead-23058235"}]},{"album":"The Afterparty","artist":"Lykke Li","artist_slug":"lykke-li","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/lykke-li","slug":"lykke-li-the-afterparty","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/lykke-li-the-afterparty","image_url":"images\/lykke-li\/the-afterparty\/674dbe78-bacd-536c-a8ee-b3ac42107c9a.jpg","release_date":"2026-05-08","release_year":"2026","consensus_score":69,"confidence_percent":88,"review_count":8,"source_count":8,"score_mean":69.1,"score_std":17.8,"score_min":43,"score_max":100,"score_range":57,"agreement_score":0,"disagreement_score":100,"agreement_label":"Sharp split","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-06-25T10:57:05+00:00","summary":"Lykke Li's The Afterparty arrives as a compact, nocturnal document that trades in disco noir and late-night confessionals, and the critical consensus suggests it mostly succeeds at...","highest_review":{"score":100,"source":"The Skinny","source_slug":"the-skinny","author":"Rick Fulton","published_at":"2026-05-05","url":"https:\/\/www.theskinny.co.uk\/music\/reviews\/albums\/lykke-li-the-afterparty"},"lowest_review":{"score":43,"source":"Spectrum Culture","source_slug":"spectrum-culture","author":null,"published_at":null,"url":"https:\/\/spectrumculture.com\/2026\/05\/07\/lykke-li-the-afterparty-review\/"},"source_spread":[{"score":43,"source":"Spectrum Culture","source_slug":"spectrum-culture","author":null,"url":"https:\/\/spectrumculture.com\/2026\/05\/07\/lykke-li-the-afterparty-review\/"},{"score":100,"source":"The Skinny","source_slug":"the-skinny","author":"Rick Fulton","url":"https:\/\/www.theskinny.co.uk\/music\/reviews\/albums\/lykke-li-the-afterparty"}]},{"album":"everyone for ten minutes","artist":"Bleachers","artist_slug":"bleachers","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/bleachers","slug":"bleachers-everyone-for-ten-minutes","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/bleachers-everyone-for-ten-minutes","image_url":"images\/bleachers\/everyone-for-ten-minutes\/e3a8adfb-337a-5f56-b26c-7c9b5e56d177.jpg","release_date":"2026-05-22","release_year":"2026","consensus_score":69,"confidence_percent":88,"review_count":11,"source_count":9,"score_mean":69.5,"score_std":17.2,"score_min":40,"score_max":100,"score_range":60,"agreement_score":0,"disagreement_score":100,"agreement_label":"Sharp split","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-10-01T09:25:07+00:00","summary":"Bleachers's everyone for ten minutes arrives as a sunlit, often sentimental collection that marries synth-driven production with courtyard-sized singalongs and a recurring preoccup...","highest_review":{"score":100,"source":"DIY Magazine","source_slug":"diy-magazine","author":"Ben Tipple","published_at":"2024-03-06","url":"https:\/\/diymag.com\/review\/album\/bleachers-bleachers"},"lowest_review":{"score":40,"source":"Far Out Magazine","source_slug":"far-out-magazine","author":"Tom Phelan","published_at":"2026-05-22","url":"https:\/\/faroutmagazine.co.uk\/bleachers-everyone-for-ten-minutes-album-review\/"},"source_spread":[{"score":40,"source":"Far Out Magazine","source_slug":"far-out-magazine","author":"Tom Phelan","url":"https:\/\/faroutmagazine.co.uk\/bleachers-everyone-for-ten-minutes-album-review\/"},{"score":100,"source":"DIY Magazine","source_slug":"diy-magazine","author":"Ben Tipple","url":"https:\/\/diymag.com\/review\/album\/bleachers-bleachers"}]},{"album":"Pink Elephant","artist":"Arcade Fire","artist_slug":"arcade-fire","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/arcade-fire","slug":"arcade-fire-pink-elephant","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/arcade-fire-pink-elephant","image_url":"images\/arcade-fire\/pink-elephant\/10f7b8fc-cbf6-53f3-b147-1c8f29c99754.jpg","release_date":"2025-05-09","release_year":"2025","consensus_score":51,"confidence_percent":87,"review_count":9,"source_count":8,"score_mean":50.6,"score_std":17.1,"score_min":30,"score_max":80,"score_range":50,"agreement_score":0,"disagreement_score":100,"agreement_label":"Sharp split","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-10-01T22:19:35+00:00","summary":"Arcade Fire's Pink Elephant lands as a polarizing, often frustrating chapter in the band's catalog, one where ambition and apology collide. Across nine professional reviews the rec...","highest_review":{"score":80,"source":"The Telegraph (UK)","source_slug":"the-telegraph-uk","author":null,"published_at":"2025-05-09","url":"https:\/\/www.telegraph.co.uk\/music\/news\/arcade-fire-pink-elephant-review\/"},"lowest_review":{"score":30,"source":"Paste Magazine","source_slug":"paste-magazine","author":"Matt Mitchell","published_at":"2025-05-18","url":"https:\/\/www.pastemagazine.com\/music\/arcade-fire\/arcade-fire-hope-youll-forget-about-the-pink-elephant-in-the-room"},"source_spread":[{"score":30,"source":"Paste Magazine","source_slug":"paste-magazine","author":"Matt Mitchell","url":"https:\/\/www.pastemagazine.com\/music\/arcade-fire\/arcade-fire-hope-youll-forget-about-the-pink-elephant-in-the-room"},{"score":80,"source":"The Telegraph (UK)","source_slug":"the-telegraph-uk","author":null,"url":"https:\/\/www.telegraph.co.uk\/music\/news\/arcade-fire-pink-elephant-review\/"}]},{"album":"Music, Fashion, Film","artist":"Charli xcx","artist_slug":"charli-xcx","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/charli-xcx","slug":"charli-xcx-music-fashion-film","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/charli-xcx-music-fashion-film","image_url":"images\/charli-xcx\/music-fashion-film\/5339f426-f0ad-5591-a015-c4a4bf1f32e0.jpg","release_date":"2026-07-24","release_year":"2026","consensus_score":80,"confidence_percent":90,"review_count":13,"source_count":13,"score_mean":80.4,"score_std":16.9,"score_min":40,"score_max":100,"score_range":60,"agreement_score":0,"disagreement_score":100,"agreement_label":"Sharp split","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-10-07T06:09:46+00:00","summary":"Charli xcx's Music, Fashion, Film mounts a deliberate pivot toward guitar-driven songcraft, where questions about artistry, persona and celebrity double as anthemic hooks and intim...","highest_review":{"score":100,"source":"Dork","source_slug":"dork","author":"Abigail Firth","published_at":"2026-07-24","url":"https:\/\/readdork.com\/reviews\/charli-xcx-music-fashion-film"},"lowest_review":{"score":40,"source":"Far Out Magazine","source_slug":"far-out-magazine","author":"Tom Taylor","published_at":"2026-07-24","url":"https:\/\/faroutmagazine.co.uk\/charli-xcx-music-fashion-film-album-review\/"},"source_spread":[{"score":40,"source":"Far Out Magazine","source_slug":"far-out-magazine","author":"Tom Taylor","url":"https:\/\/faroutmagazine.co.uk\/charli-xcx-music-fashion-film-album-review\/"},{"score":100,"source":"Dork","source_slug":"dork","author":"Abigail Firth","url":"https:\/\/readdork.com\/reviews\/charli-xcx-music-fashion-film"}]},{"album":"BITCH","artist":"Lizzo","artist_slug":"lizzo","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/lizzo","slug":"lizzo-bitch","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/lizzo-bitch","image_url":"images\/lizzo\/bitch\/966ef075-7916-505b-98ac-ea8bd48793f5.jpg","release_date":"2026-06-05","release_year":"2026","consensus_score":58,"confidence_percent":88,"review_count":9,"source_count":9,"score_mean":57.8,"score_std":16.9,"score_min":40,"score_max":90,"score_range":50,"agreement_score":0,"disagreement_score":100,"agreement_label":"Sharp split","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-06-24T18:48:42+00:00","summary":"Lizzo's BITCH arrives as a fiercely performative, often contradictory record that splits critics between admiration for her vocal bravado and frustration with uneven execution. Acr...","highest_review":{"score":90,"source":"Riff Magazine","source_slug":"riff-magazine","author":"Mike DeWald","published_at":"2026-06-04","url":"https:\/\/riffmagazine.com\/album-reviews\/lizzo-bitch\/"},"lowest_review":{"score":40,"source":"The Arts Desk","source_slug":"the-arts-desk","author":"Erin Lewis","published_at":"2026-06-05","url":"https:\/\/www.theartsdesk.com\/new-music\/law-diminishing-returns-sets-lizzo"},"source_spread":[{"score":40,"source":"The Arts Desk","source_slug":"the-arts-desk","author":"Erin Lewis","url":"https:\/\/www.theartsdesk.com\/new-music\/law-diminishing-returns-sets-lizzo"},{"score":90,"source":"Riff Magazine","source_slug":"riff-magazine","author":"Mike DeWald","url":"https:\/\/riffmagazine.com\/album-reviews\/lizzo-bitch\/"}]},{"album":"Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not","artist":"Arctic Monkeys","artist_slug":"arctic-monkeys","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/arctic-monkeys","slug":"arctic-monkeys-whatever-people-say-i-am-thats-what-im-not","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/arctic-monkeys-whatever-people-say-i-am-thats-what-im-not","image_url":"images\/arctic-monkeys\/whatever-people-say-i-am-thats-what-im-not\/b9059fe1-d9f0-5503-b335-09d641a92763.jpg","release_date":"2006-01-23","release_year":"2006","consensus_score":82,"confidence_percent":89,"review_count":28,"source_count":27,"score_mean":82.5,"score_std":16,"score_min":40,"score_max":100,"score_range":60,"agreement_score":0,"disagreement_score":100,"agreement_label":"Sharp split","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-08-27T03:05:52+00:00","summary":"Arctic Monkeys's Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not lands as a bracing debut that captured a moment \u2014 northern nightlife translated into jagged guitar songs and keen soc...","highest_review":{"score":100,"source":"musicOMH.com","source_slug":"musicomhcom","author":"John Murphy","published_at":"2006-01-23","url":"http:\/\/www.musicomh.com\/reviews\/albums\/arctic-monkeys-whatever-people-say-i-am-thats-what-i-am-not"},"lowest_review":{"score":40,"source":"No Ripcord","source_slug":"no-ripcord","author":"Simon Briercliffe","published_at":"2006-03-05","url":"http:\/\/www.noripcord.com\/reviews\/music\/arctic-monkeys\/whatever-people-say-i-am-thats-what-im-not"},"source_spread":[{"score":40,"source":"No Ripcord","source_slug":"no-ripcord","author":"Simon Briercliffe","url":"http:\/\/www.noripcord.com\/reviews\/music\/arctic-monkeys\/whatever-people-say-i-am-thats-what-im-not"},{"score":100,"source":"musicOMH.com","source_slug":"musicomhcom","author":"John Murphy","url":"http:\/\/www.musicomh.com\/reviews\/albums\/arctic-monkeys-whatever-people-say-i-am-thats-what-i-am-not"}]},{"album":"Inferno","artist":"Boards of Canada","artist_slug":"boards-of-canada","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/boards-of-canada","slug":"boards-of-canada-inferno","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/boards-of-canada-inferno","image_url":"images\/boards-of-canada\/inferno\/97b4f417-f2e4-5ae6-bee4-120195987e1d.jpg","release_date":"2026-05-29","release_year":"2026","consensus_score":81,"confidence_percent":84,"review_count":18,"source_count":18,"score_mean":80.6,"score_std":15.7,"score_min":40,"score_max":100,"score_range":60,"agreement_score":0,"disagreement_score":100,"agreement_label":"Sharp split","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-06-24T20:58:36+00:00","summary":"Boards of Canada's Inferno arrives as a ritualistic, widescreen statement that threads biblical imagery, retro-futurist synths and haunted nostalgia into one of the duo's most vivi...","highest_review":{"score":100,"source":"musicOMH.com","source_slug":"musicomhcom","author":null,"published_at":null,"url":null},"lowest_review":{"score":40,"source":"The Arts Desk","source_slug":"the-arts-desk","author":"Ibi Keita","published_at":"2026-05-27","url":"https:\/\/www.theartsdesk.com\/new-music\/boards-canada-channel-dante-inferno-seem-even-more-lost"},"source_spread":[{"score":40,"source":"The Arts Desk","source_slug":"the-arts-desk","author":"Ibi Keita","url":"https:\/\/www.theartsdesk.com\/new-music\/boards-canada-channel-dante-inferno-seem-even-more-lost"},{"score":100,"source":"musicOMH.com","source_slug":"musicomhcom","author":null,"url":null}]},{"album":"American Football","artist":"American Football","artist_slug":"american-football","artist_url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/artists\/american-football","slug":"american-football-american-football","url":"https:\/\/chorus.reviews\/index.php\/albums\/american-football-american-football","image_url":"images\/american-football\/american-football\/4dc6831c-c9c9-58c5-b493-481f5bc969b2.jpg","release_date":"1999-09-14","release_year":"1999","consensus_score":78,"confidence_percent":84,"review_count":16,"source_count":16,"score_mean":77.6,"score_std":15.7,"score_min":40,"score_max":100,"score_range":60,"agreement_score":0,"disagreement_score":100,"agreement_label":"Sharp split","sample_state":"Established consensus","last_consensus_update_at":"2026-06-25T12:19:48+00:00","summary":"American Football's American Football returns to the twinkling, melancholic terrain that made the band a touchstone for Midwest emo, and critics largely agree its quiet emotional f...","highest_review":{"score":100,"source":"The Forty Five","source_slug":"the-forty-five","author":"Rhian Daly","published_at":"2023-05-13","url":"https:\/\/thefortyfive.com\/opinion\/reviews\/taylor-swift-live-in-philadelphia-eras-tour\/"},"lowest_review":{"score":40,"source":"Slant Magazine","source_slug":"slant-magazine","author":"Luke Chinworth","published_at":"2015-09-28","url":"https:\/\/www.slantmagazine.com\/games\/blood-bowl-2\/"},"source_spread":[{"score":40,"source":"Slant Magazine","source_slug":"slant-magazine","author":"Luke Chinworth","url":"https:\/\/www.slantmagazine.com\/games\/blood-bowl-2\/"},{"score":100,"source":"The Forty Five","source_slug":"the-forty-five","author":"Rhian Daly","url":"https:\/\/thefortyfive.com\/opinion\/reviews\/taylor-swift-live-in-philadelphia-eras-tour\/"}]}]},"meta":{"window_days":180,"min_reviews":5,"generated_at":"2026-10-21T01:57:55+00:00","candidate_count":250,"source":"Chorus - Critical Music Consensus","last_updated":"2026-10-21T01:57:55.191558Z"}}