5 Seconds of Summer EVERYONE’S A STAR!
Released Nov 14, 2025 5 Seconds Of Summer
Consensus forming 4 professional reviews Updated Aug 27, 2026
Broadly positive consensus
Consensus is still forming across 4 professional reviews. 5 Seconds of Summer's EVERYONE'S A STAR!
How ChoruScore worksCritics' Top Tracks
The songs critics returned to most
NOT OK
1 critic mention
“stick it on loud and tell me it doesn’t work.” — Standard
Boyband
3 critic mentions
“as they do here on Boyband, in which Luke Hemmings piss-takingly singing about being an imaginary boyfriend” — Standard
istillfeelthesame
1 critic mention
“The downtempo, synth-heavy outro of “istillfeelthesame” exemplifies the group’s willingness to use production details to enhance the song’s concept” — PopMatters
Full critic consensus
5 Seconds of Summer's EVERYONE'S A STAR! retools the group's pop heritage into a sharper, stadium-ready rock-pop statement that critics say mostly succeeds. Across four professional reviews the record earned a 75/100 consensus score, with reviewers repeatedly pointing to songs that interrogate boyband identity and trade glossy polish for jagged credibility. The quick verdict: yes, EVERYONE'S A STAR! has memorable moments and a clear artistic purpose.
Critics consistently highlight “Boyband” as the album's centerpiece, praising its anthemic chorus, retro synths, and satirical lyricism that reframes stardom and parasocial pressure. Reviews from PopMatters, Standard, and Kerrang! also single out other standout tracks when discussing the best songs on EVERYONE'S A STAR! — “NOT OK” earns mention for its propulsive, take-it-loud energy, while PopMatters homes in on the tender core of “Ghost” and “I’m Scared I’ll Never Sleep Again”, plus the downtempo synth outro of “istillfeelthesame” that deepens the album's emotional range. Across professional reviews, commentators note the record's mix of modern rock and pop, occasional punk and hip-hop inflections, and an embrace of reinvention that aims for festival-ready thrills.
While praise centers on the band's renewed credibility and clever self-aware satire, some critics temper enthusiasm by noting unevenness in tone - the shift from cheeky takedowns to intimate loneliness does not always land—yet the consensus suggests EVERYONE'S A STAR! is a confident step forward. For readers asking whether the album is worth listening to, the critical consensus score and multiple cited highlights make a persuasive case to explore the best tracks and judge the band's reinvention for yourself.
Track Ratings
How critics rated each track, relative to this album (0-100). Only tracks that made critics feel something are rated.
Everyone’s A Star!
NOT OK
Telephone Busy
Boyband
No. 1 Obsession
I'm Scared I’ll Never Sleep Again
istillfeelthesame
Ghost
Sick of Myself
Evolve
The Rocks
Jawbreaker
Get the next albums worth your time.
Critic-backed picks in one clean digest. No clutter.
What Critics Are Saying
Deep insights from 4 critics who reviewed this album
Critic's Take
5 Seconds of Summer articulate on EVERYONE’S A STAR! that they are a band first, a pop commodity second, and the best tracks prove the point. The reviewer lingers on “istillfeelthesame” for its downtempo, synth-heavy outro that deepens the song, and on “Boyband” for lyrics that skew the boy-band image into something sharper. Tender moments like “I’m Scared I’ll Never Sleep Again” and “Ghost” are singled out as the album’s emotional core, showing why listeners ask about the best songs on EVERYONE’S A STAR!. Overall, the record balances catchy synths with vulnerable writing to stake its claim among the band’s strongest work.
Key Points
-
istillfeelthesame stands out for its synth-heavy outro and reflective production.
-
The album's strength is balancing catchy synth-driven melodies with vulnerable, honest songwriting about fame and loneliness.
Themes
Critic's Take
5 Seconds of Summer approach EVERYONE’S A STAR! like retrospective surgeons, and the review repeatedly points to the strength of tracks that interrogate the band’s image. The critic lingers on “Boyband” as a centerpiece, noting its retro synth and grooving bass that nail the album’s themes. This reading highlights the best songs on EVERYONE’S A STAR! as those that mix modern rock, pop and a lick of funk while confronting the boyband label head-on. The review’s tone is analytical and slightly wry, framing the best tracks as both musically broad and thematically pointed.
Key Points
-
The best song is "Boyband" because it pairs retro synth and grooving bass with a direct interrogation of the boyband label.
-
The album’s core strengths are its thematic revisiting of past image and a broad instrumental palette blending modern rock, pop, funk and '80s synth.
Themes
St
Critic's Take
5 Seconds of Summer sound like they’re having fun on EVERYONE’S A STAR!, and the reviewer singles out “NOT OK” and “Boyband” as the best tracks for different reasons. He calls “NOT OK” a big highlight you should "stick it on loud" - a Smack My Bitch Up-lite blast that proves the new sound works. Meanwhile “Boyband” is praised for its piss-taking lyricism and anthemic chorus that captures the album’s cheeky freedom. The review frames these best songs as evidence that the band’s reinvention - equal parts Prodigy and Strokes - gives them surprising credibility and festival-ready thrills.
Key Points
-
The reviewer names “NOT OK” the standout for its raw, loud impact.
-
The album's core strength is a confident reinvention that blends punk, hip-hop and festival-ready stadium rock.