Comparison answer surface 5 Seconds of Summer discography

EVERYONE’S A STAR! vs EVERYONE'S A STAR!

EVERYONE'S A STAR! currently leads EVERYONE’S A STAR! in Chorus's 5 Seconds of Summer critic-consensus view.

EVERYONE’S A STAR! sits at 70/100 across 2 reviews, while EVERYONE'S A STAR! sits at 75/100 across 4 reviews. EVERYONE'S A STAR! has the deeper review sample right now. Use this comparison to see where the stronger critic favorite sits against the adjacent discography benchmark.

Score Gap
5
points on Chorus's 0-100 scale
Review Gap
2
reviews separating the current samples
Tighter Consensus
Still forming
lower spread means critics are clustering more tightly
EVERYONE’S A STAR! by 5 Seconds of Summer
Early read

EVERYONE’S A STAR!

5 Seconds of Summer

ChoruScore
70
Reviews
2
Confidence 85%
Sources 4
Range 60-80
Spread 8.7
Chorus Call
Mostly positive consensus

Early read based on 2 professional reviews. 5 Seconds of Summer's EVERYONE’S A STAR! arrives as a confident reinvention that blends modern rock and pop with self-aware satire, and critics generally find it an entertaining, if uneven, step forward. Across two professional reviews the record earned a 70/100 consensus score, with reviewers praising the band’s willi

Primary Praise

The reviewer names “NOT OK” the standout for its raw, loud impact.

Primary Criticism

arrives as a confident reinvention that blends modern rock and pop with self-aware satire, and critics generally find it an entertaining, if uneven, step forward.

Standout Tracks
NOT OK Boyband No. 1 Obsession
Source Spread
60 · Standard 80 · Kerrang!
EVERYONE'S A STAR! by 5 Seconds of Summer
Consensus forming Higher score More reviews Higher confidence

EVERYONE'S A STAR!

5 Seconds of Summer

ChoruScore
75
Reviews
4
Confidence 88%
Sources 4
Range 60-80
Spread 8.7
Chorus Call
Broadly positive consensus

Consensus is still forming across 4 professional reviews. 5 Seconds of Summer's EVERYONE'S A STAR! opens with a knowing wink, an album that turns the band's past into playful fuel while staking a claim to grown-up pop ambition. Critics' reviews coalesce around a record that mixes Y2K and '80s synth revival with retro alt-rock and pop-punk energy, and the quick verdict from th

Primary Praise

The best song succeeds by pairing self-aware lyrics with big, synth-driven hooks and confident production.

Primary Criticism

No dominant criticism has separated itself from the current review sample yet.

Standout Tracks
Boyband No. 1 Obsession Evolve
Source Spread
60 · Rolling Stone 80 · Clash Music