The Minus 5
The Minus 5 is an American pop rock band headed by musician Scott McCaughey of Young Fresh Fellows, often in partnership with R.E.M. guitarist Peter Buck.
How Critics See The Minus 5
Chorus pulls the clearest critic-consensus signals out of this discography: the highest-rated record, the tightest agreement, the sharpest split, and the best place to start.
Oar On, Penelope!
2025
Highest ChoruScore in this discography at 78/100 across 2 reviews.
The Minus 5's Oar On, Penelope! arrives as a congenial, rollicking snapshot of collaboration and spontaneity, and the critic consensus suggests it largely succeeds. Across professi...
Oar On, Penelope!
2025
Best balance of score, review depth, and critic agreement for a first listen.
The Minus 5's Oar On, Penelope! arrives as a congenial, rollicking snapshot of collaboration and spontaneity, and the critic consensus suggests it largely succeeds. Across professi...
